Skip to content

Anwar’s anecdotes

anwar1.JPGFormer Malaysian Deputy Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim has an advice to people who complain that they have no time to read: Serve jail time.

Six years in prison
on trumped -up charges of corruption and sodomy has not diminished Anwar’s wit and sense of humor. Speaking at a forum in Makati organized by De la Salle University College of Business and Economics, Ramon V del Rosario Sr. Graduate School of Business, and Asian Institute of Democracy, Anwar said while in solitary confinement from 1998 to 2004, he was able to read the entire collection of the works of Shakespeare not once but “four-and-a-half” times.

He said he has also read all the writings of Jose Rizal, whom he considers the father of Asian renaissance. To underscore his message of justice, respect for basic human rights, and strengthening of democracy, Anwar borrowed Rizal’s quote: “Humanity will not be redeemed while reason is not free.”

Anwar made his talk engaging by telling anecdotes like the time he invited an obviously-harassed finance minister of another South East Asian country to watch the Leonardo de Caprio-Kate Winslet movie “Titanic.” This was at the height of the Asian economic crisis in 1997.

Anwar declined to name the nationality of the official but one can guess from some of the details he mentioned. The official said, “Why do I have to watch the ‘Titanic’. I’m already on the ‘Titanic,'” referring to his behemoth country whose economy was sinking.

The official told Anwar that he has warned his president, “Slow down, Papa.” But the President said, “No, we are a great nation.” The official sounded the panic call, “Papa, there is an iceberg.”

When the country’s economy was sinking, Anwar said the President’s instruction to his friend was “Save my family and my cronies. Dump the poor to the sea.”

“That’s untenable,” Anwar said as he bewailed the injustice in a situation where the gap between the rich and poor is vast and deep. He criticized the Malaysian government’s decision to increase petroleum prices by 41 percent and diesel by 61 percent as “unconscionable… without regard to the plight of the vast majority of the poor and the marginalized.” Malaysia is a net exporter of oil.

He devoted a large portion of his speech to the post-9/11 war on terror and its complications to the Muslim community. He expressed concern over the mis-impression of Islam as a source of the problem.

He said there is an obsession in identifying “moderate Muslims” while the social inequities that lead to the conflict and instability are left largely ignored.

He said except in Southern Thailand and Southern Philippines, Muslims have co-existed with other races and religions peacefully. That should be the case, he said, citing the situation in Malaysia where a multi-racial, multi-religious” opposition is emerging for the first time to challenge the ruling party.

He said Thailand should address the increasing radicalism of Muslims who are demanding self-rule and resisting the eradication of their dialect. “The eradication of the mother tongue is bound to fail. The situation calls for a solution that cannot be found in the barrel of a gun.”

In Mindanao, he said, “we must unshackle ourselves of the burden of historical stereotyping.” The Muslims in Mindanao have genuine grievances like dispossession of land and economic marginalization.

“Prospect of peace cannot see the light of day unless and until justice prevails. The theory that one can’t fight fire with fire can’t be truer in this regard,” he said.

Anwar urged his government to resume its engagement in the International Monitoring Team that keeps watch over the cease-fire agreement between the Philippine government and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front. The Malaysian government, which is brokering the peace talks between the Philippine government and the MILF, started withdrawing its peace keepers in Mindanao last month (to be completed in September) after it sensed that Gloria Arroyo does not have the political will to resolve the issue of ancestral domain.

During the open forum, Anwar was asked if the Muslims are really for peace, why they don’t participate in peacekeeping operations in Iraq, Afghanistan and Sudan.

Anwar pointed out the participation of Malaysian (also Libyan and Brunei) peacekeepers in Mindanao. As to Iraq, he asked, “How do you get into Iraq?”

He said Americans must get out of Iraq. He said someone had raised to him the possibility of a civil war if the Americans leave Iraq. His answer: “Why, there’s no civil war there now?”

In Afghanistan, he stressed that he disagrees with the Talibans, who are ultra-fundamentalists. But he pointed out that the Talibans, like Iraq’s Saddam Hussein, were the creations of the Americans.

He said we should learn from history that no system, no society has endured foreign occupation.

The war on terror, he said, has created a lot of misperceptions and paranoia. He related his conversations with a friend who asked him if he believed that the Americans with all their sophisticated communication facilities and weapons can’t find Al Qaeda’s Osama bin Laden. Anwar answered, “Yes.” His friend disagreed, “They know where bin Laden is but they don’t get him in order that they will have reasons to kill more Muslims.”

Published inForeign AffairsMalaya

24 Comments

  1. Gabriela Gabriela

    They say that prison life either destroys you or makes you stronger. Apparently it has sharpened Anwar Ibrahim’s mind and sense of humanity.

    In a way, he has triumphed over Mahathir Mohammad who is now reduced to whining over how his successor is ignoring him.

  2. J J

    Mahatir’s freedom of expression is being limited now by his successor simply because Mahatir himself had no respect for freedom of expression.

  3. Point is iba naman ang mga kulungan sa Pilipinas. Marami ring corruption! In fact, ang observation ko sa Muntinlupa, breeding ground ng mga hardened criminals instead of what it should be, a reformatory institution. It needs to be revamped in fact, and run by people with real high sense of morality. Right now, it is nothing but another republic within a republic run by the Mob.

  4. “They know where bin Laden is but they don’t get him in order that they will have reasons to kill more Muslims.”

    Very true, indeed. I like this quote from Anwar. How can the Americans say that they don’t know where Osama is? Foreign media in fact can interview him if they want to. Humina na ba ang CIA not to know where he is? Nagtatanga-tangahan lang si Dubya. If not him, dahil mukha naman talagang mokong, iyong mga kasama niyang mokong din!!! Tama si Anwar, gusto lang ni Dubyang maubos ang mga Moslems. Parang gaya noong araw na galit na galit ang mga German sa mga hudyo.

  5. Yuko, Anwar said he does not agree with that view. That’s the paranoia he said that is the result of this unhealthy environment created by the reckless and indiscriminate way the war on terror is being waged.

  6. I’d like to share this with you:

    When Anwar was physically maltreated in prison, one of those who first spoke out condemning it was Estrada. I think he was in a foreign visit then.

    The people in the DFA were panicking. An undersecretary even sent a memo to all the embassies negating Estrada’s statement and insructing embassadors to distance from Estrada’s comments (imagine, the President is the one setting the foreign policy agenda and the DFA was contradicting the president’s public pronouncement!). They were told to say , that the issue is an internal matter for Malaysia. They are taking the Asean line of no interference in the internal political conflicts of other countries.

    I was in Washington D.C. at that time and our ambassador to the U.S. then was Raul Rabe. When Rabe got the memo from the home office, he was ready to take the official line.

    He went to a diplomatic reception and he was surprised when a number of ambassadors congratulated him for what Estrada did.They said how they wish their president would also be as courageous to come out openly to condemn what was done to Anwar.

  7. When Estrada went to Malaysia on a state visit, he received Azizah in his hotel room, also against the advice of DFA officials. Malaysian officials were angry.

    That’s why Malaysia was glad when Estrada was ousted. I know that Prime Minister Badawi told Arroyo and other foreign affairs officials that.

  8. Anwar said with what he had gone through, “we don’t have many loyal friends.”

    That’s why he said he values the friendship of Estrada.

  9. Anwar said with what he had gone through, “we don’t have many loyal friends.”

    That’s why he said he values the friendship of Estrada.

    Sabi nga, “A friend in need is a friend indeed!” I think it is one virtue that Erap has that can make up for all his shortcomings unlike the pandak who is an epitome that Filipinos say about people from her home province—Pampanga!

  10. Ellen: That’s the paranoia he said that is the result of this unhealthy environment created by the reckless and indiscriminate way the war on terror is being waged.
    *****

    I agree. Still, there is no denying that with an agency like the CIA, it is impossible for the Americans NOT to know where Bin Laden is at the moment unless the CIA has become a useless agency.

    Truth is a lot many people say that he could have been dead. His son, nor any of his relatives, is not talking, though.

    The son, BTW, had applied for entry to UK, but he was denied. The British regard him as a threat even when he has married a British national. He actually reminded me of a picture of Christ I downloaded from the Internet. Once my husband asked me why I had a picture of Osama Bin Laden on my computer. I told him, it was not not Osama but Jesus Christ!

  11. he’s part of the The 2008 TIME 100 Leaders and Revolutionaries

    and yes, that was paul wolfowitz who wrote that writeup on mr. ibrahim.

    http://www.time.com/time/specials/2007/article/0,28804,1733748_1733757_1735709,00.html

    Anwar Ibrahim
    By Paul Wolfowitz

    During the 1990s, Malaysian Deputy Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim and a group of U.S. Senators organized a forum to exchange views among East Asians and Americans. Asked at one session about the role of Islam in politics, Anwar replied, “I have no use for governments which call themselves Islamic and then deny basic rights to half their population.”

    This devout Muslim leader was an impressive and eloquent advocate of tolerance, democracy and human rights. So we were shocked by his arrest and trial in 1998 on charges of corruption and sodomy. I felt his real “crime” had been to challenge Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad, whose impressive record will be forever stained by his treatment of Anwar. I joined Senator Sam Nunn and others to speak out in Anwar’s defense. When he was finally released from prison in 2004, U.S. policy on Iraq was unpopular in Malaysia, and Anwar was harshly critical. It would have been easy for him to disown our friendship, but he is not that kind of person. He kept the channels of dialogue open, even while making clear our disagreements.

    Anwar, 60, is back in the center of Malaysian politics. The coalition led by his wife Wan Azizah has become the main opposition bloc. His future role can be determined only by Malaysians. One can hope that they will embrace his brand of tolerance, valuing dialogue across political differences, and that this courageous leader will continue to play a leading role on the world stage.

  12. Off topic but this is really alarming. Tribune reports, “ABS-CBN’s Drilon kidnapped by ASG; P10M demanded.” They said the same thing when JLo was missing until the group of Atienza, et al admitted “snatching” him at NAIA on his arrival. God willing, Drilon will return home unharmed!

    Ellen, ingat!

  13. bitchevil bitchevil

    Ces Drilon is a brave woman. She declined police escort. Let’s all pray for her safety.

  14. bitchevil bitchevil

    What I can’t understand is why the ABS-CBN Management ordered news blackout regarding Ces Drilon’s kidnapping.

  15. Noong 2002, sabi 100 na lang sila, pero bakit ngayon threat pa rin sila at kailangan pa ang mga kano para supilin sila? Akala ko ba isang bala lang iyong ASG?

    I doubt kung hindi pa hihinto ang mga iyan at magtatrabaho na lang kung may nagawa talagang mabuti si unano. I just watched a movie of Viva about graft and corruption from the administration down. Policemen as usual were presented as hoodlums, and no wonder by crime groups like the ASG cannot be convinced to lay down their arms and live normal lives. Mas safe nga naman sila sa bundok among themselves huwag lang silang guluhin ng mga kano at sundalong kanin!!!

  16. Parang si Taruc noong 50’s. I grew up with those HUKs menacing people in Luzon, Visayas and Mindanao. Nakakatakot ngang magbiyahe na dadaan ka sa Pampanga noon dahil sa kanila kasi si Taruc taga Pampanga.

    He came to SFO and became friendly with my father as a matter of fact. Malapit kasi iyong mga kamag-anak niya sa amin sa Tate na kapitbahay din namin sa Pilipinas. Ibang-iba siya in fact doon sa propaganda when I was a kid, when we were made to quiver by the simple mention of Communism, Red Chinese, etc. na akala mo talaga mga demonyo sila.

    Isa pa talagang nakaalis ng mga prejudices ko dahil sa mga propaganda ng mga kano based on McCarthyism nila ay iyong nakita ko sa Peking. Mid-80’s 30 to 40 years behind sila noon. Naisip ko, ito ba ang lalaban sa Sputnik Amerika?

    Ngayon siyempre iba na rin. Malaki na ang kinita ng mga intsik doon sa tinatawag naming mga 100 yen. Mayaman na daw sila. In short, hindi talaga dapat makinig sa mga propaganda. Kung kaya, magsaliksik, tignan ng sarili, hanapin ang totoo. Huwag makinig sa mga sinungaling gaya ni Glora the Magnificent Cheat!

  17. hawaiianguy hawaiianguy

    Ces Drilon was kidnapped. That’s a big mistake on the part of the Abus. They should have kidnapped Aling Gloria in one of her trips to Mindanao. She is worth billions of pesos, and Andaya will release all the money available to save her. Sayang, sana siya ang kinidnap! O kung kaya si FatBoy na lang.

  18. Valdemar Valdemar

    Ang sodomy pala ay ang pagtatalik sa animal. Di naman malayo tayo sa mga animal.

  19. eddfajardo eddfajardo

    To Hawaiianguy:
    Ganoon din ang nasa isip ko na sana si Gloria Arroyo nalang ang nakidnap masaya pa sana ang mga Pilipino. Sana may araw din siya, ano? Iyang si fatboy, huwag kayo mag alala, malapit na iyan. Hindi iyan makakatakbo pati na rin iyong mga demonyong anak at kapatid niyan, malapit na!!!!

  20. norpil norpil

    malay natin, baka naman si gma ang nagpakidnap sa kanila.

  21. I guess it was Tommy Suharto and his father that was the subject of that anecdote, right?

    Regarding those who congratulated Rabe for Erap’s protocol faux pas, his attitude towards Mahathir earned him the respect of the Americans. Especially since Mahathir was a pain in the ass of Uncle Sam as he was vocal against US foreign policy.

    Today, Mahathir is just like you and me, a blogger.

  22. Nabasa ba ninyo yung post ko ng message ni Osama kay Bush?
    Coded daw -> 370HSSV-0773H

    Yun pala baligtad lang ang papel.

  23. You guessed right, Tongue. Anwar said “president” and Southeast Asian country. Only Indonesia and PHilippines have presidents as head of government. Others are headed by a prime minister or in the case of Brunei, a sultan.

    Your coded message anecdote is cute.

Leave a Reply