by Atty. Ernesto B. Francisco, Jr.
At first glance, the proposed right of reply legislation seems to be a valid proposition since it offers a fair chance to the public to reply to published or aired accusations or criticisms. However, a closer examination will show that far from bestowing the public with a right, the end result of this proposed legislation may be to protect public officials from valid accusations and criticisms coming from the public. But public officials are public figures who “have lost, to some extent at least, their right to privacy” and who should not be too “thin-skinned with reference to comment to (their) official acts.” Moreover, this proposed legislation, far from serving its avowed ends, may also be creating a boon to corruption.
Senate Bill 2150 is entitled “An Act Granting the Right of Reply and Providing Penalties for Violation Thereof” and is authored by Senators Aquilino Pimentel, Jr., Ramon Revilla, Jr., and Francis Escudero. It requires the free publication or airing of a reply to any accusation of a crime or offense or criticism that is published or aired.