Skip to content

GO on order to stop media count: unconstitutional

Statement of Adel Tamano, Genuine Opposition spokesman, on the order of the Comelec to stop media count (click here for the story):

The Comelec order to stop the quick counts is an unconstitutional infringement on press freedom and the public’s right to information. Moreover, Chairman Abalos’ statement that the TV networks could report votes but not collate the votes is plainly illogical.

Vote collation involves simple arithmetic and is merely a synthesis of the votes that Chairman Abalos admits the press can report on. Furthermore, since the quick counts have been historically accurate and permitted inthe past, then why prohibit them now?

The quick counts are an important source of information demanded by the public who want to know how their national candidates are faring in the elections. The counts are a matter of public interest and cannot be prohibited on a mere suspicion by the Comelec that the count will be used for trending.

Former Transportation and Communications Secretary Josie Lichauco explained the predicament of the TV networks:

If TV networks ordered by Comelec to stop their quickcounts don’t stop, it is so simple for the administration to cut them off the air because the air frequencies are now within the the presidency’s fingertips by virtue of E.O 454 which placed the National Telecommunications Commission under the administrative supervision and control of the Department of Transportation and Communication.

It should be, which it has been, as far as I can remeber, merely under administrative supervision, not control because the NTC is a quasi-judicial body.

Published inElection 2007

49 Comments

  1. Hindi ba nahihiya ang Comelec that it is lagging behind in its counting of ballots? Golly, sa Japan iyan, tanggal agad iyong chairman! Only thing is we do not waste money on useless agencies over here. Kung walang silbi ang Comelec, it should be abolished.

  2. bulakenyo bulakenyo

    Comelec is stopping the quick count for the reason na mahihirapan si pandak n mandaya dahil magkikita ang difference between comelec saka s quick count saka alam nila n once n mandaya ulit sila people will not be silent anymore talagang ipapako n sila ng mga pinoy

  3. Chabeli Chabeli

    Ang pikon talo !

    Gloria must be shouting & fuming mad at the results of the elections. Despite of the machinery of TU, Gloria’s dogs could not muster a 12-0 EXCEPT SO FAR in Maguindanao – although how that happened is very questionable. Gloria must be feeling short-changed. People’s VIGILANCE cannot be bought. We must continue to be vigilant until the very end.

  4. Kontra Daya knows who the manipulators in Mindanao are. Kailangan lang nila ng concrete evidences that I bet you is being provided by some independent foreign group ala-Garci tapes! In short, wala nang lusot si Pandak. Bistadung-bistado na siya. Naghihintay na lang ng bayad si Garci na natoto na rin siguro—Pay now, daya later!!! No pay, sorry ka na lang!

    But I pray there will be no exemption to the role when the time of reckoning comes. No more state witness and plea bargaining. Ganyan sa amin dito sa Japan as a matter of fact para matotong mag-take ng responsibility ang mga pilipino. Enough is enough. Tama na ang mga kabulastugan!

  5. Sus, ang bilis ng kamay. This should read, “…ARE being provided by some independent foreign group”

  6. Bakit hindi humihirit ang National Press Club ng Pilipinas on this illegal order ni Abaloslos? Bakit matatakot ang media sa kurakot na ito? Unbelievable ang tapang ng apog.

  7. Ellen:

    It’s 8-1-3 all over the world. At least, nagbantay ng boto nila ang mga OFW kahit na may mga tanga pa rin na bumoboto lang sa mga artista at asawa ng mga artista. Pag may balota nga na puro artista ang una, sabi namin, “Abangan mo tatawagin din si Victor Wood.” Tama nga!

    At least, nanalo ang mga manok namin sa partylist dito sa Japan. Ang hirap lang ngang turuan ang mga OFWs tungkol sa kanilang mga karapatan!

  8. skip skip

    With the Anti-Terror Law in effect, it would be a cinch for Gloria to pull the plug on broadcast outfits which air “objectionable” content.

  9. parasabayan parasabayan

    The tiyanak wants to stall the counting so she can think of how to stop the GO landslide. She has to re-group and re-strategize. “HELP GARCI” ang sigaw niya. Kaso mo bantay sarado ang mga tao. All over the country the voters are outside the canvassing places. You can see their vigilance. They are protecting their votes. Never mind Maguindanao kung nabili sila. Hindi lahat ng parte ng Pilipinas ay nabibili! Most of the canvassing places are being watched 24 hours a day. This should have been done in the 2004 elections di wala sana tayong sakit ng ulo!

  10. skip skip

    parasabayan:

    I agree with your observation. She is trying to recover from the shock. She too is trying to wear us down. In her demented mind, she is hoping we’d tire after weeks of slow count.

    She had grossly underestimated our hatred for her, hadn’t she?

  11. Funny but in Tokyo, iyong mga taga-embassy ang nag-give up. Walang uwian hanggang hindi natapos ang canvassing. Now the CoC documents are in Manila. Nabilang na!

  12. Skip:

    Sabi nga patigasan! Tignan natin ang siga ni Pandak ngayon!
    She better starts packing up her bags. Filipinos will not wait for another 20 years to topple her down. This we prove in this mid-term election.

  13. skip skip

    ystakei:

    I wish all my Overseas Pinoy friends are as patriotic as you. What I see instead are people so caught up in their cushy little lives abroad that they all but forgotten the country of their birth. Sad.

  14. Jon M Jon M

    skip, a time will come that Pinoys abroad will start to care. We have to be patient. In all things, we just have to do our part, try to help others see the light, and leave it there.

  15. Emilio_OFW Emilio_OFW

    Ms. Ellen,

    Let’s change the scenario – if the senatoriables of Team Unity Team Arroyo are leading the pack (top 12), will the
    COMELEC Chief issue the same order?

    skip/Jon M,

    In my little own way, I’ve shared and cared for those in needs. There are lots who are doing the same behind the scenes but contended with the “thank you” note from their beneficiaries.

  16. skip skip

    Jon M, Emilio_OFW:

    It is when I encounter people like you who are brimming with hope for the future of the Philippines that I am convinced that all is not lost.

    I guess we are indeed seeing the faint glimmer of hope. The electorate’s resounding rejection of Gloria’s evil empire is very very heartening.

    Then our brethren in lands yonder will see that the Philippines is indeed worth coming home to.

  17. Ellen;

    GMATV has tried to confirm with us the actual no. of votes cast in Japan as Malacanang is now claiming that their candidates won in Japan. We have copies of our CoC’s for Liberal Party and so they cannot refute our claim of the actual votes tabulated. Apoi got only 86 votes for partylist as you will see in the tabulation I sent you, but Malacanang is claiming that Apoi 500 votes from Filipinos in Japan when majority of the Filipinos here do not even know the partylists and a lot of them did not vote for any partylist. The highest scorer is Gabriela with 127 votes.

    Akala siguro ni Pandak nakadaya sila sa Japan. Tarantado talaga ang mga taong ito. Filipinos, bantayan ninyo ang boto ninyo.

  18. Careful dear friends, the Malacanang robbers are starting their modus operandi of turning the table down. Hindi na puede ang mga kalokohan ng mga hayup na iyan. Enough is enough. The Filipinos have spoken. They do not like the Pandak to stay there. Period.

  19. BOB BOB

    Naunahan sila ng Media…Tama ang ginawa ng media na tutukan ang counting ng votes, kaya dapat ay pasalamat tayo sa kanila dahil napaghandaan nila itong 2007 election, although kulang pa ay tiyak naman na sa susunod ay lalu silang makakapaghanda.. kaya sa inyong lahat, MABUHAY kayo !

  20. I wonder how much the Malacanang robbers paid the GMATV to publish a very erroneous report in their site as follows

    Palace ‘front’ org tops party-list poll in Japan
    http://www.gmanews.tv/story/42870/Palace-front-org-tops-party-list-poll-in-Japan

    Contrary to the claim below, APO! got only 86 votes while Gabriela, the topnotcher, got 127 votes. The rest are almost bokya with Bayan and Anakpawis garnering higher votes than many of the Malacanang palace’s boggie partylists. For a complete tabulation of the election in Japan please visit http://www.tokyope.org/oav/oavresults.php

    Ang kapal naman ng mukha ng nagpalathala nito na malalaman namang peke.

    This is how these crooks plan to rob the Filipinos now of their sacred votes and mandate. This should not be allowed.
    If this is not trending, what is? Bilib ka sa kawalanghiyaan ano? Ang kapal ng mga mukha! Pwe!

  21. chi chi

    Abalolos stopped media count because Garci is all ready to use cellphone!

  22. chi chi

    Let’s see if Blinky Tianak can pull off another “magic” this time! The wrath of pinoys awaits her in hell!

    This kuto-sized evil woman wont’ stop, but we “will do a Trillanes” to cut her off from the face of our beloved Pinas!

  23. vic vic

    It is Unconstitutional, but the only way to have the Law struck down is to challenge the Comelec by defying its Order and fight it out in the court of law.

    Had the Comelec been able to do their job and do a quick count themselves, and usually election results are known in less 24 hours (we can have all our results in maximum 3 hours) then the Media Count would have been unnecessary.

  24. The Malacanang robbers are starting to move. They have been sending fillers to the media after telling them to stop publishing election results so they can condition the minds of the voters when they make their false claims.

    The nerve of these crooks to even choose Japan as their guinea pig for this kind of modus operandi. What they probably did not expect is they cannot frighten the Filipinos in Japan who pollwatched during the counting of the ballots of voters in Japan, especially when they are permanent residents here with proper visas who are protected by the laws of this land.

    The nerve of these crooks likewise in publishing erroneous data that contradict those published in the Philippine Embassy site. Hindi ba nahihiya ang mga ungas na ito! Buking na buking na sila, sinungaling pa ng sinungaling. If they continue with this BS, we shall expose them in newspapers here in Japan.

    With the kind of reputation the Midget now has with the media here, they will just be happy to publish any statements we may ask them to publish. Baka mabato ng tae si Pandak pagdating niya sa Japan ngayon buwan na ito!

    Walang natatakot sa kaniya dito sa totoo lang!

  25. Apparently, GMATV has removed the news item on the above lies that the Malacanang robbers attempted to spread. Check out GMATV for full report.

    Please note that APO! got only 86 votes. Gabriela got 127, and it is the topnotcher followed by Bayan Muna, Anakpawis, Cibac, Akbayan, etc.

  26. Mrivera Mrivera

    chi Says: “This kuto-sized evil woman wont’ stop, but we “will do a Trillanes” to cut her off from the face of our beloved Pinas!”

    chiqitita, pinaihi mo naman ako sa salawal dahil sa paghagalpak ng tawa!

  27. Mrivera Mrivera

    daming partylist groups na ‘yan. pero ang karamihang kakatawan ay mga haragan din na ayaw mabawasan ang kayamanan at kunyaring maglilingkod para sa kapakanan ng mga kulang palad pero ang totoo ay para mangurakot at pagsilbihan ang interest ng babaing mukhang kuto (chi, pahiram).

  28. I suggest that if you have information that are worth publishing here, please send it to Ellen or post them here yourself so we can be sure the Malacanang robbers will not be able to pass on lies and deceits. This is why we are here in the first place.

    Just make sure you cannot be traced, for unlike us in Japan, we are susceptible to liquidation by the Pidal assassins. We have ample police protection as a matter of fact. I doubt likewise that the Philippine ambassador would agree to being privy to crimes being committed by these criminals calling themselves officials of the Philippine government. Nakakahiya sila!

  29. Oops, this should read, “Just make sure you cannot be traced, for unlike us in Japan, YOU are susceptible to liquidation by the Pidal assassins. OVER HERE, AT LEAST, WE have ample police protection as a matter of fact.

  30. Magno:

    Almost one hundred ang partylists, at karamihan ay partylists na ginawa sa utos ni Pandak lalo na iyong partylist ni SiRaulo. Naniniguro ang animal na manalo ang mga partylist niya para hindi siya matanggal. Palit noong hindi mabobotong congressmen niya dahil galit na nga ang mga tao. Iyong APO! nga halos kapareho ng pangalan ng Akbayan kaya nalito ang mga tao at iyong ang ibinoto kahit ayaw nila.

    Kahit ano ang sabihin nila, panalo ang GO sa Japan. 8-1-3 dito. Same in other countries kahit kaunti ang bumoto. Mabuti na rin iyon. Ironically, Japan pa ang piniling babuyin ang mga boto e dito nga ang mas maraming matatapang na ipapahiya sila kapag nagsinungaling sila. O di bistado agad sila. Ang tatapang talaga ng apog. Demonyo na ang mga iyan sa tapang ng mga hiya nila. Pwe! Kakadiri!

  31. Yes, Skip, there are a lot many dedicated Filipinos out there helping their fellow Filipinos in distress. At least, the members of my group are doing the things that many would rather not get involved in, especially when they can be at the mercy of these crooks who pimp them overseas but leave them at the mercies of unscrupulous recruiters and exploiters.

    As for myself, I am just lucky I have the resources, time, and drive to do what I am doing because I really want to be proud of the land of my birth, not be ashamed of it! Huwag na akong maging apo ng isang Katipunero!

  32. Sabi nga ni Lacson, “HUWAG MATAKOT SA MGA KURAKOT!” Time to show now that no one is afraid of this Midget trying hard to be big!

  33. BOB BOB

    Kaya pala No.1 si chavit sa maguindanao at 12-0 duon, di pala nagkaintindihan ang mga botante at mga leaders nila…akala pala nang mga botante ilagay sa balota lahat nang sa tingin niyo ay corrupt at bobo kaya ayun..no.1 si chavit sunod si pichay at sunod sunod na sila…., duon nasagot ang tanong ko kung bakit si Kiram ay no.12, hinuli siya kasi di pa daw corrupt , bago lang sa politika at muslim pa….ayun naman pala…..ok…

  34. chi chi

    Hahahah! Kaya pala No. 1 si Sabit sa Maguindanao at 12-0 doon in favor of TUTAS ay “human mistake” ng Namfrel!

    Oy, naunsyami si Blinky Tianak, Oinky, Sabit at TUTAs!

  35. chi chi

    Surprise. The latest Malacañang survey has this surprising result 1) Legarda 2) Escudero 3) Lacson 4) Villar 5) Honasan 6) Aquino 7) Trillanes 8) Cayetano 9) Arroyo 10) Zubiri 11) Defensor 12) Pichay.

    If this comes out, then dagdag-bawas worked but only to put in Malacañang favorites and only to push out Angara, Recto and even Pangilinan. Unbelievable!!!

    www. tribune.net (Maceda’s column)

  36. Emilio_OFW Emilio_OFW

    Pareng BOB,

    Ang hagalpak ko naman ng tawa sa iyong naisulat tungkol sa pagiging number 1 ni Chavit Singson sa Maguindanao.

    Katulad din noong nagkaroon ng hostage-taking sa mga bata sa harap ng Manila City Hall. Ang binabatikos ni Ducat ay ang sobrang corruption ng nagaganap sa gobyerno.

    Ayun at dali-daling nagpunta si Chavit doon dahil akala niya tinatawag siya. Dahil panay ang banggit ni Ducat ng corruption na kaakibat kay Chavit.

  37. rose rose

    Kaya Comolect ordered for a stop to the quick count ay dahil sa hindi nila nagustuhan at maamin sa sarili ang resulta for GO. At kaya naman No. 1 si Chabit sa Maquindanao ay walang ilaw at baligtad pala ang binabasa kaya yong huli nauuna.

  38. sleeplessinmontreal sleeplessinmontreal

    Ma’m Chi

    Sa sinabi mong ang pagkawala ni Angara, Recto at Pangilinan sa Magic 12 ay Unbelievable!!!?

    Tama po kayo, it’s UNBILIBABOY!!!

  39. rose rose

    Sabi ko na nga… sa isang news na nabasa ko a few minutes ago= No. 13 at 14 daw si Legarda at Escudero. Baligtad ang nabasa nila sa counting.

  40. Diego K. Guerrero Diego K. Guerrero

    The deliberately turtle-slow Comelec-National Board of Canvassers could be a part grand scam to cheat in favor of Gloria’s TUTA. Manual counting is prone to fraud. There’s no doubt that Elections chief Benjamin Abalos is playing dirty politics. It would be difficult to detect a manufactured provincial election returns if genuine ER’s are supplied by the Comelec. Who knows if there are duplicate serial numbers? Election fraud operators may have learned their mistakes. It seems that independent election body has failed to perform its constitutional mandate. Never trust a known thief. Bantay Salakay! Anak ng jueteng itigil na ang dagdag-bawas.

  41. rose rose

    Nahirapan nga sila magdaya sa higpit ni Bantay. Come to think of it- sabi ng anak ni Max Soliven nasa voter’s list pa daw ang tatay niya. Balitang balita ang magkamatay ni Soliven. Hindi nila alam? Kung nagamit ang pangalan niya sa pagboto sino kaya ang binoto?

  42. Rose:

    May protesta kami ng flying voter dito sa Japan. May isang bumoto na ang balota ay galing Amerika. Ayoko ko lang manggulo dahil hindi ko terotoryo. Sinabi ko na lang pakisulat sa minutes nila ang protesta namin. Ipapasa ko ang kasong ito sa GO dahil ito ang klase ng pandarayang gagawin ni Pandak sa 2010 kung andiyan pa siya, manipulation of OAV votes sent by mail. Sinabi ko sa mga taga-embassy na ito ay problem of jurisdiction, at implementation of a resolution and principle that the voter should be in Japan to vote. Iyong pagpapadala ng boto from another place may be considered flying voting, for we do not know if this person has voted likewise elsewhere lalo na’t hindi naman systematic ang sistema ng Comolec.

    On the other hand, siguro nagugulat din ang mga walanghiya na hindi umuubra ang ginagawa nilang pandaraya. Pati nga tayong supporter ng GO nagugulat sa nangyayari. If this is not an act of God, what is? Hallelujah!

  43. You bet, dear friends, walang tulugan on this dayaan! Let us be on guard all the time until this Pandak is removed once and for all!!! Move on daw? Baka move out!!! 😛

  44. chi chi

    Adel Tamano is doing a great job as GO spokesman. Thanks, Adel. Your turn in 2010!

  45. chi:
    Yes Adel Tamano has done a great job, but you see he has no reason to lie or try to pull the wool over the electorates eyes. Unlike Mr Tony’pet’ constantly trying to score points even to the extend of introducing a racialistic card, instead of keeping his poisoned mouth shut instead of showing panic. But as Adel said on ANC “Age does not always mean experience” ha ha ha Tony’pet’ just keep your mouth shut, you’ll learn! eventually.

  46. rose rose

    “age does not always mean experience.” Oo nga may tumatanda nang paurong. Mukhang marami nga sa pro-administration.

  47. Mrivera Mrivera

    sa paghaharap ng dalawa, nagkaroon ng pagpapalitan ng obserbasyon tungkol sa pangunguna ng swab-it swingson sa maguindanao na ayon kay adel ay isang hindi kapanipaniwalang resulta kung ikokonsidera na hindi isang muslim itong si swab-it kung ikukumpara kay kirat este kiram na isang tao sug. itong si tony pwet al-bano ay ipinagpipilitang malinis naman daw ang naging halalan sa lugar na ‘yun at walang dapat ipagduda o ipagtaka kung walang nanalong taga oposisyon at bumandera ang mga kandidatong TUtae.

    ang umuusok sa inis ay itong si tony “pwet” al-bano!

  48. BOB BOB

    Puede pa rin mangyari No.1 si swabit sa maguindanao , eh kung yung leader ng tribo sa maguindanao (Ampatuan’s) sinabi sa botante na ”Ang iboto niyong senador ay iyong kamukha ko ang ginagawa”….alam naman natin ang mga leader ng tribung muslim duon ay, Corrupt,sinungaling,mamamatay-tao,, madaming asawa,….kaya tama lang si swabit ang no.1….(sa kawalang-yaan..!!!)

  49. Bob,

    Huwag naman. Hindi naman lahat ng datu sa Mindanao ay walanghiya. May mga kakilala akong matitino. Napipilitan na lang kumapit sa patalim dahil ayaw nilang malipol at mawala sa mundo ang kanilang tribo. Kung alam mo lang ang pang-aapi sa kanila, baka bawiin mo ang sinasabi mo. Polygamy is a way of life sa kanila. Huwag na nating pakialaman iyon. Ang dapat nating itanong ay kung kasya pa ba ang inaaani ng mga lupa nilang natitigang dahil sa guerra-guerra ni inutil na Pandak para ipakain sa mga pamilya nila.

    Siguro naman kung sapat ang kinikita ng mga pilipino ay hindi naman siguro magpapabayad. Oops, mali yata. Ang dapat na sabihin ay siguro naman kundi nasanay sa lagay ang mga pilipino at may sapat na pagakakakitahan ng pera ay hindi madaling masusuhulan. Ang masama kasi mismong mga pare, ministro daw ng mga simbahan, etc. sila pa ang namumuno at nagtuturo ng mga kabalbalan sa mga tagapagsunod nila. Buti na lang iyong mga El Shaddai daw sa Hong Kong binoto si Trillanes kahit na iyong pinuno ng simbahan nila ay nagsabing mas iboboto niya ang mga TUta ni Pidal dahil sa tanong na “Magkano?” daw!

    Siguro naman itong si Ampatuan ay hindi naman pangkaraniwan. Siya ay isa bTU (bukod Tanging Ungas)!

Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.