Skip to content

Mike Arroyo challenges lawyer to “settle outside”

Mike Arroyo took the witness stand this morning in the hearing of the libel case he filed against Malaya Publisher Jake Macasaet and business editor Rosario Galang.

A reporter who was in the courtroom said, Arroyo, in a white barong, was arrogant as ever. In the course of the cross examination, Arroyo challenged Macasaet’s lawyer, Paul Arias , “Let’s settle this outside.”

Arias replied, “I’m willing to oblige you.”

Arroyo later apologized to the court for his “outburst.”

What did Arroyo mean when he said “Let’s settle this outside?” Was he challenging the lawyer to a fisftfight? After the hearing, he approached Arias and apologized.

Arroyo’s chief of staff, Juris Soliman, was expelled from the courtroom for making loud remarks whenever she didn’t like Arias’ questions.

Below are the two columns of Macasaet which are the basis of Arroyo’s libel suit:

First Couple’s idea of charity
Business Circuit,Malaya
July 9,2004

Weeks after the elections, a kind-hearted man tried to get in touch with Mike Arroyo in the hope of getting assistance for Rowena Juno, sister of a member of the Presidential Security Guard.

Juno has been in excruciating pain at the V. Luna Medical Center, suffering from brain cancer.

The executive assistant of Mike Arroyo promised P100,000 but the money never came. In the end the matter was referred to the Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office.

Before that, another person called up somebody, presumed to handle money in the office of President Arroyo. He was told that “we have no money.”

The request was also referred to the PCSO.

Ms. Juno spends an estimated P50,000 a day in the faint hope of getting well. But she has run out of money.

The story here is that Mike Arroyo is trying to build a name for charity. Now that the elections are over, he would not even part with any amount for the sister of a PSG member. Neither would the President draw some money from her Special Fund which is not subject to audit.

Politicians are the most charitable people on this planet while they are campaigning. After they win, they become tight-fisted. And the money may not even be theirs.

Thank you, Atty. Arroyo
Business Circuit, Malaya
july 13, 2004

Our small effort to get the attention of First Gentleman Mike Arroyo paid off handsomely. We said that there is this Rowena Juno, sister of a member of the Presidential Security Group who is confined at the V. Luna Hospital suffering from brain cancer.

A friend of hers called up the Office of the President for help but she was turned down although the request was referred to the Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office.

A similar attempt was made with a top assistant of the First Gentleman. The assistant promised P100,000 but the money never came. It turned out that the request was also referred by the assistant to the PCSO.

That got us to saying that since the First Gentleman promised to stay away from the powers of his wife and that he will devote his time to charity and sports, it should not be difficult for him to provide assistance to a sister of the person who helps secure the lives of the First Family.

Quite promptly, the First Gentleman sent somebody to V. Luna to inquire what Ms. Juno needs. Money, of course. But there could be other things that the patient might need. I suppose the First Gentleman’s charitable heart will take care of that, too.

Only problem is – if we have to set modesty aside – Attorney Arroyo moved only after he was told that we wrote about the poor girl’s pitiful situation. Suppose we had not reported it, would he have sent somebody to V. Luna to inquire about Ms. Juno’s needs?

I guess not. But I am personally grateful to the First Gentleman for his quick response. There are hundreds of cases reasonably similar to that of Ms. Juno. We hope we would not have to report them.

Published inMedia

59 Comments

  1. Jon M Jon M

    If these mild articles by Makasaet are libelous, what is not? Mike Arroyo is really just throwing his weight around bullying people. His wife of course encourages him by saying that if “these people” (the journalists) need to be taught a lesson, then Mike should go through with the cases!

    I wish they did settle the case outside of the court!

  2. jr_lad jr_lad

    hindi ko nga rin maintindihan kung bakit naging libelous ang sulat ni mr. jake macasaet sa itaas.

    pero sayang, hindi natuloy ang suntukan. maganda sanang pang-headline yun, “First Gentleman Nag-ala Pacquiao”.

    dapat mai-ban na rin sa korte yang sip-sip na chief of staff ni jose pidal. mula sa kongreso hanggang sa korte ang pambabastos nila, may magmumura, may manghahamon ng suntukan. akala siguro nasa kongreso pa rin sila. mga walang asal.

  3. Chabeli Chabeli

    I don’t get it, either..what was so libelous about the articles ?

    I subscribe to the article when it says that “Politicians are the most charitable people on this planet while they are campaigning. After they win, they become tight-fisted. And the money may not even be theirs.”

    I think even a dog knows this to be so ! Like his wife, Mike also diffculty w/ the truth. He is pissed off because he doesn’t like it when journalists tell the truth. Well, it’s just too bad. He should just go to & take a hike to some place where the truth does not exist..maybe, w/ Satan in Hell ? That’s not a bad idea.

  4. jr_lad jr_lad

    at bakit nga pala hindi naexpel si fatso o di kaya nacite for contempt of court? alam ko pambabastos sa korte yung ginawa niyang paghahamon ng suntukan. mukhang naintimidate niya rin yung judge just like in the lower house.

  5. Mrivera Mrivera

    meron ba namang baboy na marunong manuntok?

  6. Mrivera Mrivera

    itong juris soliman, parang sobrang sipsip yata kay ip (PIG) dye?

  7. vic vic

    And what is so Criminal about those letters? And that is why libel and slander should never be under the criminal code – it is just a waste of government resources.

    And the manner the counsels conduct themselves before the courts, including the plaintiff or witnesses are scandalous. The presiding Judge should not wait for the witness, in this case Mike Arroyo to apologize, but should have censored him in the first place. The court is not a congress or parliament where witness are imune to their testimony or threats. They could be charged for threats and intimidations for their words and action at the witness stand and also for contempts. If the Judges have the balls..

  8. Ellen,

    Mike Fatso Arroyo just proved that he’s just a hoodlum in barong tagalog.

    Just think: his wife, the unano is not even the duly-elected president of the republic.

    Can you imagine if she had been? He would not only have been a bully, he would’ve been worse than Generalissimo Franco, the fascist dictator of Spain who, while making the sign of the cross would order the killing of his enemies.

    No amount of civilized approach to this government would change a person who’s basically a tulisan – Mike ‘Jose Pidal’ Arroyo proved that.

    High time the Filipino nation brought this family of abusers and hoodlums down and put them in the gutter where they belong.

  9. luzviminda luzviminda

    Eh ano pa ba naman ang aasahan natin sa isang “GANGSTER”!!! Ano kaya ang masasabi ng mga taga-Ateneo? Puro KAHIHIYAN ang binibigay! Wala talagang modo at pinag-aralan! Malamang ang diploma niyan ay binayaran lang!!!

  10. Diego K. Guerrero Diego K. Guerrero

    Miguel Arroyo is a bully. Jake’s libel suit should be junked during the preliminary investigation. There’s nothing libelous about it. Sip-sip boto ang hinayupak na piskal. Sobrang balat- sibuyas itong si tabatsoy at PIKON pa. Bastos, parang isip bata naghamon pa ng mano-mano sa loob ng korte. Ano siya Pakiao?

  11. During the cross examination, our reporter said, Mike Arroyo said during the campaign he gives money, P1,000 or P2,000 to people and he is not sure if the money comes from his own funds or campaign funds.

  12. Luz,

    Spot on ka diyan talaga! Mag-asawang gangster.

    Kunyari pa raw galing sa mahusay na eskuwela – puro panloloko sa kapwa lang naman ang natutuhan.

    The worse, tinuturo nila ang kanilang gangsterism sa mga anak at apo nila.

  13. Ellen,

    Because of his “pang-yayabang”, this two-bit whore of a law school (kuno) graduate couldn’t help but show off some more.

    What a shithead that Mike Fatso Jose Pidal Arroyo is.

    I can’t believe Filipinos in their right mind still support him.

  14. chi chi

    How big is the belly of Fartso that he challenged a lawyer to “settle” the case outside? Baka iyong kanyang “bundat” ang ipangsusuntok niya sa abugado ni Mr. Jake! It’s a habitual show of arrogance for this pig to challenge anyone who strikes his bloated ego, because he’s actually feeling so inferior in the presence of good people.

    He badly wants pinoys to see and fear his bulkness, but all we see in him is his callousness and empty brains!

    Hindi pa ba ito isinusumpa ng mga Atenista?!

  15. Jr_Lad asked, “at bakit nga pala hindi naexpel si fatso o di kaya nacite for contempt of court?”

    Our reporter there said, he probably immediately realized his boorishness when Atty. Arias said, “Okay, I’m willing to settle this outside.”

    Arroyo immediately apologized to the court.

    On his way out, he approached Atty. Arias and apologized for his “outburst”. he offered his hand, saying, “Oh. okay na tayo.” With Atty. Arias, it was okay because it was Arroyo who looked stupid.

  16. His outburst only shows what breeding this boar has. Now wonder he was booed during an alumni homecoming in Ateneo. No Atenean in his right mind would want to be associated with this gangster. At least Al Capone dealt with his enemies himself than hide behind some gnome pretending to be president.

  17. Schumey,

    ” Now wonder he was booed during an alumni homecoming in Ateneo.”

    Really?

    Hahahah! Good, excellent!

  18. jr_lad jr_lad

    astang hari pala talaga etong si fatso. mukhang nawala sa sarili pati pagka-abugado nakalimutan. akala niya nasa kongreso pa rin siya at mga alipores niya ang nagpapatakbo sa korte.

    – –

    BREAKING NEWS: PACQUIAO WON’T RUN IN MAY ELECTION!

    hayy, kung hindi pa naboo sa cebu hindi pa sana natauhan.

  19. PV,

    I believe it was in 2003 or 05. Someone even blogged about the incident.

  20. Schumey,

    Excellent, excellent! They should do a repeat when they next have their homecoming!

    Wonder if Ducky Paredes joined the booing Ateneans.

  21. luzviminda luzviminda

    Basta sa eleksyon…CCLLAP VOTER, (Hands Clapping)Let’s GO!!!

    CAYETANO, Alan Peter (Pakibuo ang pangalan para mabilang)
    COSETENG, Anna Dominique “Nikki”
    LACSON, Panfilo “Ping”
    LEGARDA, Loren
    AQUINO, Benigno III “Noynoy”
    PIMENTEL, “Koko”

    VILLAR, Manuel “Manny”
    OSMEÑA, John
    TRILLANES, Antonio IV “Magdalo”
    ESCUDERO, Francis “Chiz”
    ROCO, Sonia

    Yung pang labindalawa, Kung si Gringo Honasan, Pakisingit na lang after Pimentel. CCLLAPH VOTER…Let’s GO!!!

  22. Mrivera Mrivera

    hindi kaya sa victoria court nag-aaya (naghahamon) si ip (PIG) dye dahil gusto niyang ma-settle sa malamig at malambot na kama sa gilid ng mesang merong bucket ng mamahaling alak?

    para magbunong braso sila!

    kayo naman! ‘sama ng iniisip n’yo.

  23. Mrivera Mrivera

    hindi n’yo ba alam na itong si ip (PIG) dye ay nag-namber por sa kanilang low klas? pero sabi ng iba dapat daw namber payb, kaso palaging absent daw ‘yungpanglima nilang kaklase kaya siya naging pang-apat.

    ewan lang daw kung nakapasa at napasama sa gradwesyon ng tatlo.

  24. Mrivera,

    Hahahaha! Bro, for sure, pasang-awa yan. Baka nga nag-donate pa yan sa Ateneo para lang pumasa.

  25. BOB BOB

    kagaya nang sabi ko , di kilala ni FG jose pidal itong si Atty. Paul Arias….kung hinahamon niya nang suntukan si Atty. dapat isama niya pati mga security escort niya, para pinag buhol lahat sila ni Atty.
    Siguro may nagbulong kay FG Jose pidal na expert sa wrestling and juditsu si Atty. Arias, kaya sabay kambio si fatso at nag sorry….Nakatapat siya…buti nga…hoy FG jose pidal..bisto ka na sa mga pagnanakaw mo sa kaban ng bayan…malapit kanang husgahan..lilitsunin ka nang taong bayan….

  26. artsee artsee

    Kahit kailan walang galang sa Korte ang mga tarantadong iyan sa Malacanang. Dapat na-contempt ang Baboy ng Judge. Ang inasal niya sa hearing ay dapat isama sa kampanya ng oposisyon para malaman ng tao kung anong klaseng tao ang asawa ni tiyanak.

  27. Agree Artsee, “Ang inasal niya sa hearing ay dapat isama sa kampanya ng oposisyon para malaman ng tao kung anong klaseng tao ang asawa ni tiyanak.”

    101% Agree!

  28. artsee artsee

    Gawin mo nang 102% agree para sigurado ate. Tutoo iyan. Marami ang nasa probinsiya ang hindi alam ang mga nangyayari sa Metro Manila. Hindi naman lahat may computer at internet. Ang mga mahihirap kasi ang inaatupag kung paano mabuhay araw-araw. Kapag hindi ipaalam sa kanila ang katarantaduhan ng mga Pidal na iyan, baka magkamali sila ng boto.

  29. Chabeli Chabeli

    Ms. Ellen,

    Bobo, stupido ! Mike Arroyo could not tell “..if the money comes from his own funds or campaign funds” ??? Oh, common !

  30. doy doy

    Baka libelous din ang tanong ni Arias. Mayron kasing libel in form and substance and libel in structure. Baka isa doon.

  31. artsee artsee

    Buti pa ikaw na lang ang abogado ni Baboy. Para kang si Atty. Jesus Santos na bolero at sinungaling. Ang taas na ng retainer fee ng ulol na iyan, may posisyon pa sa gobyerno. Kung libelous ang mga tanong ni Atty. Arias, dapat nagsalita ang Judge. Sa hamon ng suntukan ni Baboy, ni hindi pinagalitan ng Judge ang loko. Sa cross examination, hindi maiwasan ang mga diretsong mga tanong na may kaugnayan sa kaso. Dahil tungkol sa pera ang mga tanong, napikon si Baboy. Akala kasi niya nasa Senate hearing pa siya sa Pidal case na puwede niyang iwasan. Nalusutan niya noon dahil na din sa harang ni Joker Arroyo na Chairman ng Blue Ribbon Committee. Iyan ang gantimpala sa kanya ngayon at isinama sa admin ticket. Ikaw Doy, kung hamunin kita ng suntukan…haharap ka ba sa akin? Sabihin mo lang at magkita tayo kahit saan. Labas na ito sa ET Blog. Personal na natin iyan. Payag ka ba? O wala ka ding yagbols tulad ng amo mo?

  32. doy doy

    The judge role is not to object or stop the lawyer who makes the cross-examination. It would be Arroyo’s counsel’s. The judge would only speak if he/she determines that there’s something to really get at the point; whether the lawyer is making sense or not. Besides, Arroyo is a lawyer and he knows whether Arias was trapping him or not. The rules of court and the doctrine of cross-examining a person concerned provides that there should not be misguidance in digging out the truth. If this rule is not followed, but maliciously, of course it will invite an out of court settlement such as personalizing the case in terms of getting into a fight or maybe out of settlement to preempt further unbearable scandalous acts that are repugnant to the judicial system.

  33. artsee artsee

    Ipagpalagay na natin matalas at may pagka-foul ang mga tanong ni Atty. Arias sa kumpare mong Baboy, tama ba sa isang asawa ng pekeng pangulo at isang abogado na tapos ng Ateneo ang humamon ng suntukan sa loob ng korte? Iyan ang sagutin mo imbes na lumihis ka sa usapan at issue.

  34. chi chi

    Jon M Says:

    February 26th, 2007 at 4:16 pm

    If these mild articles by Makasaet are libelous, what is not?
    ****
    Good question Jon. Tanungin ang bulaklak ng katuray kasi hindi alam ni Fartso!

  35. TonGuE-tWisTeD TonGuE-tWisTeD

    F. Atty. Arroyo? Ah, Fatty Arroyo!

    If you didn’t recognize his language, what he actually meant when he said, “Let’s settle this outside” was: “Aregluhin na lang natin ito, out-of-court settlement. P5 Million is fine, iaatras ko na.” which sounds more like the usual modus operandi in the extortion racket of this shameless pachyderm.

    Tuloy ang laban, Jake, huwag patatakot! Sabi nga sa National Anthem:

    …Lupang Hinirang, duyan ka ng magiting
    Sa manlulu – PIG, di ka pasisiil!

    (Paki-text mo iyan, Ellen, kay Jake, para gumaan ang dinadala.)

  36. Ha hahahahahahah!

    Tongue, love that: “Sa manlulu – PIG, di ka pasisiil!”

    Yessssssssss! That’s another precious quote!

  37. Tongue,

    Just sent your texto to friends including to 2 friends in Pinas military (star ranking):

    Text:

    Advise to Jake Macasaet, Malaya publisher re Mike PigPidal Arroyo libel suit: Lupang Hinirang, duyan ka ng magiting
    Sa manlulu – PIG, di ka pasisiil!

  38. Spartan Spartan

    Ma’m Ellen, question lang po. These two articles that we read above, are they already the full version of it or just excerpts? Kasi po kung iyon lang ang nasulat ni Ginoong Macasaet at nagdemanda na kaagad si Tabang Lamig e talagang balat sibuyas lang o naniniga lamang talaga ang walanghiyang tabatsoy na ito. The title of First Gentleman don’t fits him, he’s more of a First unGentleman.

  39. Tongue T: If you didn’t recognize his language, what he actually meant when he said, “Let’s settle this outside” was: “Aregluhin na lang natin ito, out-of-court settlement.
    ******

    Iyan din ang hinala ko. Funny but this guy seems to love the figure 5M whether in peso, dollar, EU, yen, etc. Bakit kaya? Sinabi ng Feng Shui adviser nila?

    I know the gambling lords give him that every game they play at kapag kailangan niya.

  40. Funny how the courts in the Philippine can waste time entertaining the lawsuits of this fat guy e alam naman nilang it is just a matter of time when this guy and the wife will have the end of their day of merriment! Ngayon lang naman iyan. Someday soon, talbog na rin sila! Si Marcos and Imelda had it for 20 years. Itong mga piggies baka hindi pa umabot hanggang sa isang taon!!!

    Iyong walang sumama sa EDSA celebration nila na para lang makaloko sila ng tao ay nagmukhang loko-loko pa si FVR at iyong mga cabinet members ni Pandak na nagtatalon (for what?) na parang nasiraan ng bait! Unbelievable talaga!

  41. Mrivera Mrivera

    doy, hindi mo na sinagot ang post ko. hirap na hirap na kami dito sa ibayong dagat. napakalungkot ang malayo sa mahal namin sa buhay. meron na bang maibibigay na trabaho ang ninang mo para sa amin?

    baka naman sa call center lang? ‘yun lang yata ang alam na ibigay na trabaho ng ninang gloria mo, huwag na lang!

    gutom lang ang aabutin ng pamilya namin.

  42. Arroyo probably meant — let’s go outside while I hide behind my bodyguards and see if they can kick your A$$…

    Arrogance is too good a word for this man

  43. brad brad

    kakabanas talaga grrrr..mas bagay sa kanya ang FIRST GENTLE-PIG at isulat sa komiks na pugad baboy at itapon sa babuyan island…hehehe nagka baboyan na..

  44. nelbar nelbar

     
    nakakapagtaka rin bakit walang mga kenkoy na komiks na gumagawa dyan kay Jose Pidal.

    noong panahon ni Marcos at Erap ang daming naglabasan.
     
    basta ako dun pa rin ako sa ideya ng Fat Boy Slim Right Here Right Now videos(evolution of doy aka lawyers inda pilipins)
     

  45. Tapang kunwari si pidal parang tunay na lalaki.
    Kaya nga nag-asawa yan ng maliit na babae dahil maliit din ang kargada niyan, sa madaling salita peewee na dyutay pa yung kanya. Sa laki ng katawan niya mapapahiya siya sa babaeng normal ang height kaya pumili siya ng unano para tutugma, ang tutubing karayom niya na don babagay. Sabi nga ni pidal noong honeymoon pa nila, nagulat ka no? huwag ka ng maghanap ng jumbo eh liit ka rin naman dear.

  46. Phil Cruz Phil Cruz

    Settle it outside, eh?

    I’d love to see the day when the big Dumbo and the Midget and their Mafia gang are no longer in power. Boy, oh boy…

    Certainly some settling to be done. And it better be outside. Inside takes too long.

  47. Mrivera Mrivera

    valentin, tutubing karayom? ‘kalaki pa nga ‘yun, ah?! baka naman PINWORM!

  48. Mrivera Mrivera

    doy says: “Baka libelous din ang tanong ni Arias. Mayron kasing libel in form and substance and libel in structure. Baka isa doon.”

    itong isang ito, labas na nga ang kababuyan ipinipilit pa ang baka!

  49. chi chi

    (Dito ako mag-post dahil masyadong mahaba ng lubid sa unahan. Yeeeey!)

    Mr Jake Macasaet in his column said that Malacanang was shocked because their latest survey showed that Alan Peter Cayetano rose to No.4 position from number 21 four months ago.

    In Abante’s own survey via text Alan is #1; Chiz #2 ; Ping #3; and Loren #4.

    (O s’ya, kayo na ang magtuloy magbasa dahil lumigaya na ako. heheh!)

    http://www.abante.com.ph/issue/feb2707/main.htm

  50. Diego K. Guerrero Diego K. Guerrero

    The opposition must keep pounding on Jose Pidal and Gloria Arroyo administration’s tyrant rule, corruption issues, scams, human rights violations and political killings. Keep reminding the Filipino people on the massive cheating in the 2004 presidential election, as exposed in Hello Garci tapes, the P3 Billion fertilizer fund scam, the graft-ridden contracts for North railway, NAIA terminal 3 and Diosdado Macapagal Boulevard, the protection being given to smuggling mafia rings which subvert local industries and imposition of an additional VAT on almost all commodities and services. Malacanang will be shocked if surveys go to eleven opposition candidates plus one independent (12-0). Comelec chief Abalos needs hundreds of Garci clones to another massive electoral fraud. Upakan ang mga raket ni Patso hangang mai-patso.

  51. Chi: In Abante’s own survey via text Alan is #1; Chiz #2 ; Ping #3; and Loren #4.

    *****
    Ang ibig sabihin niyan, Chi, laos na ang mga Pidal. Inuubos na lang ang pera ng bayan para sila magmukhang gustung-gusto pa rin ng mga tao. Walastik ang mga publicity ng mga ungas sa totoo lang. Pero wala na yatang bumibili kaya iyong Pandak ayaw nang nagpapalitrato. Ang pangit ng mukhang lalo na kung nakasimangot!!!

  52. nelbar nelbar

    first asian republic ba ang Pinas?

    noong panahon ni Marcos ay panay ang batikos natin sa mga crony nito.

    matapos na mapatalsik ito ay sandamukal sa mga dyaryo at pahayan na naglabasan(1986-1989) ang mga pangalan ng crony ni marcos.

    kagiliw giliw ba ang pag-a-abugasya kung pag-aaralan natin ang kasaysayan ni Hilario Davide mula sa pagiging Pusyon Bisaya, Concom member hanggang maging nasaan man sya naroroon?

    ang pagkakaalam ko kay legazpi ay isa siyang abogado na may background sa military.

    maituturing lamang natin na republika ang isang bansa kung ito ay may pinagbabatayan na batas na sinusunod.

    ipinagtataka ko lang kung ano at kaninong audiencia tumatalima si davide?

  53. artsee artsee

    Mang Nelbar, ang alam kong First Republic ay ang Republic Supermarket. Naaalala mo pa ba iyan?

Leave a Reply