Skip to content

Esperon on PTI report: I will not confirm

AFP Chief of staff Hermogenes Esperon was asked by Philipppine Daily Inquirer about the unsigned recommendation of the Perreras panel dismissing the charge of mutiny against the 38 officers and recommended court martial only for Conduct Unbecoming of an Officer and Gentleman. His reply: “Whatever it is, it’s still my decision.”

Asked if the JAGO had recommended the dismissal of mutiny charges, Esperon said: “I will not confirm that.”

Sources said the original Oct. 25 findings of the panel headed by Col. Al Perreras was changed upon orders of Esperon.
Sources said the Esperon , upon seeing the original recommendations, expressed his displeasure and “suggested” that the panel take another look at the evidence.

Brig. Gen. Renato Miranda, the epitome of a military commander, welcomed the court martial proceedings, but said his subordinates should have been cleared.

“I was always telling them that the responsibility is mine because I was then commandant and I was hoping that I should be the only one charged and let my staff officers be freed,” he said.

Miranda further said, “If they feel that there is something illegal to what I did and on what I decided then, it was my decision and I can defend myself for that. I am convinced that they did not commit anything wrong. Staff officers, we encourage them to talk, to give options but at the end of the day, the commander decides. If they feel that I made an illegal decision, then I should be the only one be charged.”

Hearing Miranda take the responsibilty, Col. Ariel Querubin said, “That’s the essence of commandership.”

Miranda also denied reports that he was in connivance with former Sen. Gregorio “Gringo” Honasan in plotting to overthrow the Arroyo government.

“I don’t know their meaning of connivance but I haven’t seen Sen. Honasan for the last 15 years… Maybe in the defense of our case, this time we will connive,” he said.

The government is working on the eight officers dropped from the court martial proceedings to witness against fellow oficers. The eight include lieutenant colonels Reynaldo Ocsan and Martin Villasan of the Philippine Marine Corps, Maj. Oriel Pancog, Capt. George Malones and 1st lieutenants Antonio Timbal, Gerald Reyes, Mario Bautista and Michael Quartero, all from the Philippine Army.

Published inFeb '06Military

60 Comments

  1. npongco npongco

    I don’t mind being arrested with my suggestion here: Let’s not wait till GMA is ousted to punish this Esperon. If there’s any hit squad whether it is from the Left or Right, I hope they now eliminate this bastard before he does more harm to the people. People like this AH has no right to live a day longer!

  2. chi chi

    Brig.Gen. Renato Miranda, YOU ARE MY HERO! You are indeed a Commander. Mabuhay ka!

    That Asswipe, coward, traitor, inggetero!!! To the extent, he will let his fake Kumander-in-Cheap, his evil twin, to play and make tiris his 000000. Ma-prostate C ka sana! Hmmmppp!!!

  3. hawaiianguy hawaiianguy

    This Assperon will surely enjoy his life now, and may not even burn in hell after he dies. Judging from the way he licks the ass of his present boss, he may even convince Lucifer of his dogged loyalty to make him his assistant. Kayo na ang maging Assperon, hehehehe!

  4. npongco npongco

    And to my friend in Hawaii, don’t forget Palparan too. There are just too many evil Generals in Arroyo’s government that this space is not enough to mention all their names. Do you know that even this ex-convict Berroyo is now the LTO Chief aside from his position as DOTC Usec.?
    People used to accuse and blame Marcos for giving so much priveleges to his Generals. But as far as I could remember, the names that come to my mind are only Ver, Barangan, Dumpit, Olivas and a few. Today, we can’t count how many are in GMA’s payroll.

  5. npongco npongco

    Excuse me, I meant Berroya not Berroyo. It sounds like Arroyo. Bearroyo?

  6. TonGuE-tWisTeD TonGuE-tWisTeD

    Wala bang gagawing matino yang si HerMujeres Assperon?

    Palsipikador!

  7. hawaiianguy hawaiianguy

    Npongco, “Today, we can’t count how many are in GMA’s payroll. ” I could agree with you no more on that. What happens now is, that hell breaks loose right into our faces or that we make our lives hellish. That’s the political situation I see today, it’s the worst ever.

    Since you have a keener memory on who those generals are, why don’t you help out in cataloguing their names and positions? WWNL just posted a blog on this at a previous thread.

  8. Chabeli Chabeli

    Brig. Gen. Renato Miranda is one of the FEW GOOD MEN. I salute you and commend you for your words of integrity!

    *******************

    Ebdane will be at the helm of the DND and that Lomibao will replace him (Ebdane) in Public Works. How sickening! This move of Gloria spells that she can’t even get a civilian anymore…she has to get people in the police &/or military to serve her. GLORIA IS DESPERATELY CLAWING ON TO POWER! Unbelieveable!

    *******************

    Npongco,
    You commented that “I don’t mind being arrested with my suggestion here: Let’s not wait till GMA is ousted to punish this Esperon. If there’s any hit squad whether it is from the Left or Right, I hope they now eliminate this bastard before he does more harm to the people. People like this AH has no right to live a day longer!” BRAVO! I second your motion!

  9. npongco npongco

    But Chabeli, if I’m arrested, would you bail me out or at least visit me in jail?

  10. luzviminda luzviminda

    Talagang may SUNGAY itong si Esperon ano! Imagine, kunyari pa na may panel na magre-review ng kaso, pero kung ano yung gusto nya yun ang masusunod. Ang LAKI KASI NG TAKOT NITONG DUWAG NA ESPERON NA ITO SA MGA JUNIOR OFFICERS EH! Pero pag dating ng tamang oras LAGOT SIYA! Dahil kasama ang DUGO nya na dadanak sa lupa.

  11. luzviminda luzviminda

    SA SOBRANG DAMI AT LAKI NG KASALANAN NITONG ESPERON SA MGA JUNIOR OFFICERS AT LALO NA SA BAYAN, AY DI MANGINGIMING ITURING NA SIYANG KAAWAY NG ATING MGA MAGIGITING NA SUNDALO. SI ESPERON AY TRAYDOR SA BAYAN!!!

  12. luzviminda luzviminda

    INGGIT kasi itong si Esperon sa ating mga MEDAL OF VALOR AWARDEES eh kaya putok ang butse nya kina Lim, Querubin, Miranda at sa iba pang magigiting sa opisyal dahil siya ay PAGSI-SIPSIP LANG kung kaya siya nalagay sa pwesto niya… At abangan ang mga IMBENTONG EBIDENSIYA AT MGA HARASSED WITNESSES na gagamitin niya laban sa magigiting na patriotic soldiers ng bayan. Ang sarap saluduhan ng bala itong si Esperon!!!

  13. pandawan pandawan

    Walang alipin kung walang magpapaalipin. Walang gago kung walang magpapagago. Walang masusupil kung walang magpapasupil.

    Ang ginawa ni Esperon ay isang paghahamon. Nakakalalaki siya. Sino ngayon ang tatayo upang tugunin siya?

  14. Diego K. Guerrero Diego K. Guerrero

    Bakit pinalusot si Armed Forces ni Pidal (AFP) Chief of Staff General Hermogenes Esperon sa Commission on Appointments? Dapat piniga ng CA ang mga kasalan niya bayan bago kinompirma.

  15. chi chi

    DKG, tama ka, malaki ang pananagutan ng Senado sa kawalanghiyaan na ginagawa ni asswiperon ngayon sa ating mga magigiting na sundalo. Dapat nga ay hindi kinumpirma. Ano kaya ang kapalit ng kumpirmasyon niya?

  16. Sought out by reporters, Perreras simply said, “The panel stands by its recommendation.”

    Intriguing.

  17. The irony of this abominable development: The only two living Medal of Valor awardees in the Marines- Col. Ariel Querubin and Lt. Col. Custodio Parcon – will be court martialled for refusing to be a party to Arroyo’s bogus and corrupt presidency.

  18. Tomorrow, the Norwegian Embassy is showing the movie “Enemy of the People” by Henrik Ibsen at the Carlos P. Romulo Auditorium at the RCBC Center in Makati at 6:30 p.m.

    Ibsen’s scenario is being re-enacted today in this country.

  19. Above site states when accessed:

    Page Not Found
    Error 404

    If the owner is Philippine based and hook up is run by a Philippine provider, please be careful. It can be subject to hacking and some people are likely to pass worms, bugs and viruses through the blogsite. Please be fairly warned to make sure it is accessible and not easy to be hacked if you want the people to know what they should know.

  20. Ellen’s blog has the same problems because of the Internet Brigaders and other Malacanang sipsips monitoring this blog, but at least we know where we stand, and we’re here to stay no matter what to share and help rekindle that spirit of valor, courage and bravery to fight an oppressive regime, especially one that is bogus and should be toppled down by all means possible even by a coup that never was, except the attempt of some angry young men in the military who did not want to be used for cheating by the liars and the cheats in 2003.

    Now, with the 2007 election coming, this Esperon (I’d better use his real name rather than the Assperon that he may say does not refer to him) is trying his best to gain pogi points, and making sure there are no more soldiers likely to incite dissent in the military even when they are used for the kind of cheating in 2004. Charge these officers with rebellion, and they won’t even get a single centavo of the pension they have paid this lousy government that I agree needs to be changed but not with the same people like the bogus president, JdV, et al running it.

    Esperon is actually keeping up with the bogus president to change the AFP even with new recruits that I’m told they are getting from the barangays, especially from Pampanga maybe and why the mayors and barangay captains are pledging full support to their fellow dugong aso in Malacanang, thus, the court martialling of the officers they are slapping with rebellion even when it is not true, and just because they would not cooperate with the Malacanang squatter!

    We may well remember that in February, Querubin was there complaining and shouting about the soldiers being made to lie, cheat, and worst, shoot their fellow Filipinos in peaceful rallies, etc., and similar plots of detonating sophisticated bombs to kill innocent people and blame the NPAs, Abus, and other tulisans for it.

    If that is not terrorism, what is? What they have in the Philippines is in fact a reign of terror, with the bogus president being the terrorist herself. She should be kicked out!

    PATALSIKIN NA, NOW NA!

  21. We may as well remember that this Esperon has been implicated in the cheating in the 2004 election with the vote-rigger Garcillano. Let us not forget the testimonies given by officers like Gudani, et al on this.

  22. we-will-never-learn we-will-never-learn

    Gudani, now there’s a brave man ready to tell the truth, no if’s or but’s. No wonder tha Marine Corp. gave him so much respect.

  23. florry florry

    I can’t understand why this ASSperon can overrule the findings of JAGO, the panel who is in charge of finding if there is sufficient evidence to warrant the filing of cases against those offricers. What’s the purpose of this Jago then if the COS does not recognize its findings and insist his own pre-judged decision? Ano lutong-macaw na naman ba ang kaso, na kung anong gusto niyang mangyari at resulta ay siyang masusunod. Wala na talagang kahihiyan itong Asong ito, pagkatapos mandaya sa election, ang mga ayaw sumama sa kaniya gusto niyang mawala. Wala ng tigil sa kasisipsip sa talampakan ng kaniyang among katulad niyang demonyo. Mukhang naulol na yata ito sa kapangyarihan at gusto niyang ipakita at iparamdam sa lahat na siya ang kanilang panginoon. Hind bale, mamamatay ka rin.

  24. florry florry

    Ellen Says:
    Sought out by reporters, Perreras simply said, “The panel stands by its recommendation.”
    Intriguing.

    Dapat lang, I hope Perreras and company have the balls to stand up against the evil ASSperon.

  25. alitaptap alitaptap

    Gen. Lim and those others facing court martial are the personification of what George Orwell said: In times of universal deceit, telling the truth is revolutionary. Esperon himself should in stockade for his part in rigging the elections.

  26. Florry,

    Like the Melo Commission, the bogus president thought there were no more good men in the AFP because as she has bragged that that has already been taken care of.

    The bogus president has made sure she has insured the loyalty of the generals, et al to her, not to the Philippines or the Filipino people, with all the loots from the national treasury being freely distributed and shared with the crooks in the AFP, Congress, Senate, etc., including even in fact the Catholic Church, where we witness the same split between the paid and the unpaid, not even in fact between the good and the bad!!! Pathetic eh?

    This is not tsismis as a matter of fact. It is an open secret, something everybody knows but lamentably cannot do anything about it, especially a private citizen being given too much immunity just because of his connection with the bogus president, and the right to insist on his privacy right even when there should be a law, written or unwritten, that states that one, who commits a crime, forfeits whatever rights he has under the very law he breaks.

    Everybody knew about how the Pidal brother in fact won in his district in Negros, but no one has dared accuse him of electioneering because of the private militia on government payroll who can kill the less privileged complainant. What an injustice. Nakakakulo ng dugo! PATALSIKIN NA, NOW NA!

  27. This should read: Florry,

    Like the Melo Commission, the bogus president thought SHE COULD MAKE THE JAGO COMMISSION LIE FOR HER AS SHE MUST HAVE ASSUMED THAT there were no more good men in the AFP because, as she has bragged, that has already been taken care of.

  28. So the brave men are facing court martial! So what? All the more reason now why those remaining and wanting to remain as good soldiers should now show the bogus president who should rightfully be sacked. The bogus president should be the first one to go, followed by this cheater, Esperon. Sabi nga, kundi sila makuha sa santong dasalan, siguro kailangan na ang santong paspasan. PATALSIKIN NA, NOW NA!

    Langya ang justice ng Pilipinas! JUST-TIIS NA LANG BA?

  29. norpil norpil

    ellen: i have not seen this movie you are talking about, but it must be quite old. ibsen is a social critic in his time and his plays are deep and challenging. he is considered by many as the father or inspirator of women’s liberation from his play a doll’s house.

  30. norpil norpil

    i agree with npongco that these generals who are enemies of the people ought to be shot.there should be no problem on what to do with their bodies for they can be sold to hospitals as they do in china where their body parts are sold to americans.

  31. Mrivera Mrivera

    “enemy of the people” movie?

    in the philippines, the enemy of the people are those who are fighting for the truth while the “gallant victors” are the oppressors of their own! baliktad, kasi PEKE ang presidenteng siyang role model ng mga duwag!

  32. soleil soleil

    pagin mrivera..how do u feel when u see the assperons of the military having the time of their life while those of your tribe are being prosecuted for the love and passion of them serving their country and their coutrymen?..Gone are the days of dignity in uniform, dignity and pride of serving the country whether you are holding a jungle bolo or a missile…sadly, this admin and this country in general has not even the capacity to defend itself if ever a 9/11 is duplicated(God fordib please!!!..if only in the EK then we will rejoice!!!!)…it will be a known fact the the PNP – Manilas finest and all the f–kin-finest of these kidnappers – will be the first to run to their stations cowering under their tables….for sure it will be the volunteers who will be in the forefront. when one volunteers, it means that all actions come frm the heart, but when they are the assperons and minions of this admin, they will ask how much first and “whats in it for me” before to move!!!

  33. Mrivera Mrivera

    norpil Says: “there should be no problem on what to do with their bodies for they can be sold to hospitals as they do in china where their body parts are sold to americans.”

    sunugin na lang kesa ipagbili pa ang knilang body parts. mamaya mo mag-propagate pa ‘yan ng mas demonyong mga nilalang. hayaan mong sa kanila na matapos ang lahi ng alagad ng kadiliman.

  34. soleil soleil

    mrivera..i smiled when i saw ur comments re lolo issue and when my comments about the threat to Ellen came out…yes. talagang umuusok pati tenga ko..this am we were outside EK…sabi ko sa sarili ko, “kung fanatic lang ako, i will put C4 around me and just run amock inside the compound and blow them all to kingdom come!!!”..really am serious…sukang suka ako sa nakikita ko ngayon…ang mga pinoy, masyadong malilimutin at nauuto, sadly these are the patay-gutom and kapit sa patalim genre..buyt what about the learned and those who can think? ask ko din mrivera, mababa na ba ang moral ng militar?

  35. Mrivera Mrivera

    soleil, mula’ng mamayani ang lantarang panlilinlang at pangungurakot sa iba’t ibang departamento ng pamahalaan (with this questionable administration) particularly sa AFP, hindi lang mababa kundi SAYAD ang morale ng mga combat unit elements natin. lalo na ngayong bale wala na ang pagtuturing sa kagitingan at matapat na paglilingkod sa bayan bunga ng kasibaan sa kapangyarihan ng kasalukuyang CSAFP and chief gloria K9 asoperon.

  36. Mrivera Mrivera

    soleil, pag nakikita ko si asoperon, parang puputok ang pantog ko sa galit!

  37. soleil soleil

    nakakapanlumo nga talaga…nakakangitngit at naaawa ako sa mga sundalong nakikita ko sa fort bonifacio at villamor pagka nadadaan ako sa kanila…looking at their faces, naiisip ko, parang bale wala ang kagitingan kung ang morale ay questionable…assperon, sana ay ma-prostate ka at ng malaman mo kung pano ang essence ng sakit!…sakit na inaagaw ninyo sa sambayanan!

  38. soleil soleil

    sabi ko nga eh, san ba makakahanap ng C4…hehehe

  39. npongco npongco

    Norpil, I don’t think it’s a wise idea to sell the Generals’ bodies to the hospitals. They’re so rotten that the hospitals might refuse to accept them even for free. I was thinking of those Generals who served under the Shah of Iran. After the Shah was ousted, his Generals were hanged and displayed in the streets for all people to see. How I wish to see these Esperon, Palparan, Tolentino, Berroya, Eldane, Bulatong and the rest hanged in Edsa…

  40. Soleil:

    Maghunos dili ka. Not worth to be a criminal like these lipservers of the Bansot. I thought we should have more faith. I don’t think God will allow the Philippines to be totally destroyed unless the Filipinos deserve such!

    Kawawang bansa! Magdasal na muna tayo ng mataimtim!

  41. Just wondering, Ellen, what right under the law of the Philippines does this fool of a lipserver Esperon, who is said to have helped the Bansot cheat in the last election, have to act as judge and executioner to want to kill the chances of the brave members of the AFP for a fair trial. Gosh, ang walanghiya to deprive these bemedalled soldiers of even their pension by recommending their court martial and being dismissed dishonorably! Ano iyan?

    Kawawang Pilipinas! Kawawang mga pilipino! Nabitin sa isang magnanakaw na sinungaling pang bogus president!

  42. TonGuE-tWisTeD TonGuE-tWisTeD

    Jusko, Josephs! Cool ka lang. Pero kung di mo mapigilan, e di sige. Will pray for your soul. Bukas, laman na ng newspapers yan, may death threat si Assperon, maniwala kayo.

  43. Tongue,

    In a way you’re right – no need to give Esperon the slightest excuse to scream “death threat” although Esperon, if he were a real trooper should know that a professional military eats death threats for breakfast. Why do you reckon he has a band of “security guys” detailed to him with “wah hoo, wah hoo, wah hoo” engine screaming when he travels about?

  44. artsee artsee

    Halos lahat ng hospital sa atin may share ako kaya hindi puwedeng tanggapin ang mga mababahong katawan at bangkay ng mga Heneral na iyan.

  45. Mrivera Mrivera

    asoperon is a trained and learned protector of his benefactor, her majesty, the termite queen of the kingdom by the pasig river.

    kita n’yo nga hindi magkaiba ang mga taktika nila. anuman ang rekomendasyon ng panel, bale wala din sapagkat kung gusto nilang idiin ang sinumang nasasangkot na kontra sa kanila, kesehodang ang baluktot ay ituwid at ang deretso ay gawing zigzag, samantalang kung kaalyado ang sasabit, ang puti ay magiging itim at ang itim ay magiging pula. at presto, absuwelto na!

  46. paperdoll paperdoll

    Grabe ka Esperon, pumapayag ka na gamitin ng mga taong huwad ang iyong kapangyarihan,ibinebenta mo ang mga sundalong tapat sa kanilang tumgkulin,,,, mahiya ka naman….

  47. hahahaha! Thanks Tonque-twisted sumangayon ka. Wala atang nakabasa.

    Ellen,
    I’m really sorry. I know that was stupid and it will never happen again.
    josephs

  48. soleil soleil

    yuko..ur ryt….not worth even a single phil centavo sila…lets just kick-ass ryt?

  49. soleil soleil

    ..naputol…i mean kick-ass in our own way..kick ass the minions, the hoodlums in robes, the midgets, the cavern-scented tongressmen, the chicken-pooped faced wanabee trapo super-wh-re…and all the rest of the bogus admn!!!!

  50. artsee artsee

    Alam mo Soleil, mga Kapsiyaw sila. Kapggong.

Leave a Reply