Skip to content

Why hide the Melo Commission report?

Gloria Arroyo always talks about transparency. Read this brilliant piece by Raul Pangalangan, columnist of the Philippine Daily Inquirer

Malacañang created the Melo Commission to inquire into extrajudicial executions, but won’t show the Melo Report to the UN special rapporteur on extrajudicial executions.Executive Secretary Eduardo Ermita declares that President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo supports the UN inquiry “for purposes of transparency, to show them that the [Arroyo] government is doing everything to address [the killings].” But apparently “everything” does not include showing the Melo Report — not to the United Nations, not to the European Union, which has expressed its alarm at the unabated killings, and certainly not to the Filipino people.

The Constitution provides for the “right of the people to information on matters of public concern.” The Melo Report is certainly “of public concern,” yet the Palace has kept it secret from the people it is sworn to serve, all the while proclaiming its fealty to the rule of law and calling upon mutinous soldiers to respect the very Constitution that President Arroyo has sullied time and again. (Recall that the Mayuga Report on military involvement in election cheating remains confidential to this day.)

To the credit of the Palace, it has actually produced a well-scripted excuse. “Why, the Melo Report is not yet complete!” Ermita said. “The Melo Commission could not come up with a comprehensive report because there is no participation — by design, I think — by the leftist organizations.”

President Arroyo then asked the commission members to continue with their work even after they had submitted their fact-finding report. (That should make them “functus officio,” shouldn’t it? But apparen4ly the Palace can resort to extralegal “calibrated preemptive response” when it comes to extrajudicial deaths.)

That the commission members, save one, would all play along confirms, in hindsight, why the bereaved families and comrades boycotted the Melo Commission to start with. Because they did not trust the commission’s ability to be independent. Ermita would now hold them hostage. The administration created a fact-finding commission that lacked credibility, provoking a boycott by the bereaved, and now it would withhold the report unless the widows and orphans joined their show. The Palace will make a virtue out of its own folly.

President Arroyo encourages the leftist groups to testify, by asking the justice secretary to offer them his protection. Yes, Virginia, you read that right: She asked Hannibal Lecter to give protection to the members of the Vegetarian Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Humans.

What will work, Madame President, is if you appoint a fact-finding commission that the victims can trust. The best proof is the visit by the UN Special Rapporteur Philip Alston. The victims’ families — they who have spurned the Melo Commission and Task Force Usig of the Philippine National Police — all showed up in full force to meet with Alston, and have offered their “full participation” in his meetings. (Allow me to disclose that Professor Alston was my faculty adviser for my master’s thesis at Harvard Law School.)

Ermita worries that the Melo Report is thus based on testimony mainly by police and military authorities and might be misinterpreted if “such a one-sided report will be released to the public.”

That simply doesn’t wash. One, despite hearing from only one side, namely, the police and the military, the Melo Commission has actually found that the police and military were involved in most of killings, at least according to public statements made by retired Justice Jose Melo. Indeed, he said — and the Palace has not denied — that they held retired Maj. Gen. Jovito Palparan and other commanders liable under the principle of command responsibility.

Fret not, Secretary Ermita. If it is one-sided against the one side that testified, just imagine if we heard the testimony of the other side that didn’t. The Melo Report might possibly include what the law of evidence calls “admissions against interest,” the most loaded kind of proof.

Two, Ermita’s problem is now remedied by the willingness of the victims’ groups to appear before the UN special rapporteur. In other words, let us make full use of the visit by an international expert to secure the evidence that tainted national bodies cannot.

The “desaparecido” [disappeared] phenomenon (or “salvaging,” as we call it locally) and its latest cruel variants have evolved precisely so that governments can plausibly wash their hands, but the World Court and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights have repeatedly applied the principle of “attribution” of “state responsibility” so that evil leaders cannot use the law to shield them from justice.

We must ask our President: Has she punished any of the military officials implicated in human rights violations? Has she prosecuted them the way she has run after the coup plotters and rebels? Has she promoted or in any way honored any of these officials? Has she given commendations to them, whether in terms of formal military decorations or by praising them more decorously during, say, a State of the Nation Address?

The pattern of the killings is pretty well set. The victims are marked as leftist sympathizers, then this information is publicized during community meetings (sometimes by burning their effigies), and in a few days, motorcycle riding assassins move in. The military have blamed death squads for the actual killing, but it is they who set up the victims for the kill. If the military keeps on marking the victims, they are at best knowing accomplices of the butchers. Their hands are no less stained with innocent blood.

Published inMilitary

64 Comments

  1. Ellen:

    I am not surprised. Anything that this woman does is all for the moment’s show, and that’s the reason why she cannot be consistent. What she says today will be different from what she says tomorrow or what she said yesterday. Ang tawag diyan, schizophrenic. She should be sent to the mental hospital for a check-up!

    What happens now is that the pa-cutie-cutie woman is leaving the affairs of the country to the military generals now retired and doing civilian jobs (kuno). This is definitely very dangerous, more like the SLORC of Burma now called “Myanmar”! I wonder if that was the reason why Forsec Romulo went to Burma recently.

    Frankly, the Philippines has become a killing field. My Japanese friends have told

  2. Oops, naputol. I was saying that the Philippines has become a killing field. My Japanese friends have told me that in Bohol community leaders there opposed to this administration, even when they are not Communists or leftists are tagged as such and their assassination are being even brazenly advertised. Kaya if you are a community leader marked for the killing by these military men, what would you do? Di magtago ka ngayon sa bundok. Then, all the more these military men will tag the escapee as a Communist and a leftist.

    Wala ka namang magawa kundi magngitngit. This is the reason why I wish the group of Escudero, et al would look into this, and have the soldiers confined to their barracks and leave a civilian police commission to solve crimes committed by Filipinos in violation of the laws of the land so prevent this tactical killings that are so barbaric as a matter of fact.

    I should know because I have worked for the Japanese police as an interpreter/translator, and know how effective the police function when it is free from the meddling of politicians, etc. especially one like the bogus president who is a criminal continuously committing crimes against the people of the Republic of the Philippines.

    Let her prove that she has not cheated in the last election. We have kept the proofs here as a matter of fact, and they are binding!

  3. vic vic

    Not surprised at all. The same with Mayuga’s report which was also kept out to the public, Ms. Arroyo made a blunder here by inviting an impartial body headed by Philip Alston, thinking that the Melo commission will tow her line.

    The report should have been simultaneously released to the congress and the Supreme court as the co-equals of the Executives.

    Some will not accept that there are some advantage of having a Parliamentary System, but this is the one where a parliament being an executive and legislative bodies, a report like the Melo Commission’s should go the Parliament instead of the PM, whereby tranparency is guaranteed.

    Despite it is still incumbent for the administration to be transparent and make the report available as the basis of the Observers own investigations. These groups are not amateurs. They will look at the report objectively, and may or may not even depend on it entirely but jus as a base to start their own impartial reports.

    I believe Ms. Arroyo this time is to make a choice to deliver the goods or cover the asses of the people that will propel her candidates this coming election and pay them back handsomely instead. Or she may have to cover those who covered her own for a long time…

  4. Ellen,

    Just to let you know, there are a lot many foreigners going there and finding proofs to present even to the PPT in the Hague. Our Japanese who have met with members of the Japanese Diet have actually databased the victims now counting over 700. When we meet with the Diet members, there were just over 600 as a matter of fact.

    Amnesty International has also made a good “cataloging” of these killings blamed on the military that Palparan himself even bragged about. Akala ba nila nakaloko na sila even when they have not presented the U. N. representatives with the Melo Report and try hard to deny these killings.

    It is no longer internal affairs as a matter of fact when the families, kin and relatives of these victims seek justice elsewhere for justice that they cannot get in their own country, and all because the country is now run by hoodlums and criminals dressed in gold!!!

    We’ll send a note to Senator Enrile to please stay aside and stop babbling nonsense! Sayang siya na mamamatay siya and remembered for his blunders!!! He should not be an accomplice to the crimes being committed against the Filipinos if he wants to be remembered as a great statesman even just for once!

  5. Jon M Jon M

    This is just another veil taken away from the many Gloria is using to hide the truth. But the truth always finds a way to reveal itself.

    Hopefully the day that Gloria is unmasked for all her sins will come sooner.

  6. manuelbuencamino manuelbuencamino

    Gloria is trying to convince some members of the Melo panel to speak up about the report, emphasizing those points that agree with her party line. Those statements will be presented as the substitute for releasing the Melo Report. The big headache right now is how to do it, destroying Melo’s credibility, without totally alienating him and forcing him to speak the truth.

  7. MB:

    We should not worry. The UN people know what they are talking about. If the Midget thinks she has convinced them with her lies, she is wrong. They are actually just trying to see what kind of lies she has prepared.

    Now, the reason why she cannot present the Melo Report is that probably the Melo Commission has found the complaints to be true and decided to stop investigating and leave the Midget and her generals to find a way out of their own mess. In other words, the Melo Report is blank!

  8. ellen, can you make an assessment kung sino sa mga party list na ito ang aligned kay arroyo, at kung sino ang boboto para sa impeachment niya. at kung sino ang neutral? para alam namin kung sino ang iboboto namin.

    i forgot, how many party list can we vote ba? 1 or 2?

    • Bayan Muna
    • Association of Philippine Electric Cooperatives (APEC)
    • Akbayan! Citizen’s Action Party (AKBAYAN)
    • Luzon Farmers Party (BUTIL)
    • Citizens Battle Against Corruption (CIBAC)
    • Buhay Hayaan Yumabong (BUHAY)
    • Anak Mindanao (AMIN)
    • Partido ng Mangagawa (PM)
    • COCOFED-Philippine Coconut Producers Federation, Inc. (COCOFED)
    • Sanlakas
    • Abanse! Pinay
    • Alagad
    • Gabriela Women’s Party (GABRIELA)
    • Migrante Sectoral Party of Overseas Filipinos
    and Their Families (MIGRANTE)
    • Samahan ng Mga Mangangalakal Para Sa Ikauunlad ng Lokal Na Ekonomiya (SMILE)
    • Assalam Bangsamoro People’s Party (ASSALAM)
    • Bahandi Sa Kaumahan Ug Kadagatan (BAHANDI)
    • Bagong Tao Movement (BTM)
    • The True Marcos Loyalist (Marcos Loyalist)
    • Alyansang Bayanihan Ng Magsasaka, Mangagawang • Bukid at Mangingisda – Adhikain at Kilusan Ng • Ordinaryong Tao (ABA-AKO)
    • Kabataan (KABATAAN)
    • Ang Labang ng Indiginong Filipino (ALIF)
    • Aging Pilipino Organization, Inc. (AGING PINOY)
    • Veterans Freedom Party (VFP)
    • Ahonbayan
    • Suara Bangsamoro (SUARA)
    • Alab Katipunan (AK)
    • Alliance of Volunteer Educators (AVE)
    • Advocates and Adherents of Social Justice for School • Teachers and Allied Workers (AASJS)
    • Alyansa Ng Sambayanan Para Sa Pagbabago (ASAP)
    • An Waray
    • Cooperative-Natco Network Party (COOP-NATCCO)
    • Bigkis Pinoy Movement (BIGKIS)
    • Anak Pawis
    • Alliance for Nationalism and Democracy (ANAD)
    • People’s Movement Against Poverty (PMAP)
    • Philippine Confederation of Drivers Organization and • Alliance of Concerned Transport Operators (PCDO- ACTO)
    • Confederation of Grains Retailers Association of the • Philippines (GRECON)
    • Alyansa ng May Kapansanang Pinoy (AKAPIN)
    • Philippine Guardians Brotherhood Inc. (PGBI)
    • Novelty Entrepreneurship and Livelihood for Food, Inc. (NELFFI)
    • Seaman’s Party Inc. (SPI)
    • Aksyon Sambayan (AKSA)
    • Anak Mahirap Learning Center, Inc. (ANAK MAHIRAP)

  9. As I have stated, AI has catalogued the victims complete with pictures, affidavits, etc. Over in Japan, we have also reports from Japanese NGOs who have gone to the Philippines to investigate and make their own conclusions that they have also published in Japanese newspapers and magazines. Kaya panay ang patawag kay Siason ng aming Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Dito sirang-sira na si Pandak, and reason why her PR agency here that I understand is supervised by the Fatso has closed shoped. Nakulitan siguro sila sa mga journalists na hapon na hindi sila titigilan in fact when they want to know the truth!

  10. John Marzan,

    You can check on Bayan Muna, Gabriela, etc. from their reps in Hong Kong. Definitely, Bayan Muna, Gabriela and the partylist of Ka Bel are not affiliated with the Bansot. Akbayan, too, despite Etta’s reported hobnobbing with Malacanang is not affiliated with the Bansot because of Risa, Aguja, et al. As for the rest, except perhaps for the partylist of JIL or Eddie Villanueva, questionable lahat!

    We are concentrating on these four partylists over in Japan. The rest manigas sila.

  11. how many party list groups ba can one voter select ba? one, two or three? i forgot na kasi eh.

  12. sino pa ba ang mga iban party lists ang bumoto sa 2nd impeachment ni arroyo? CIBAC? anak mindanaw with hataman?

  13. here are the 32 senators who voted for impeachment. party list members with asterisk.

    1. Rep. Henedina Abad
    2. Rep. Nereus Acosta
    3. Rep. Benjamin Agarao
    4. Rep. Mario Aguja * AKBAYAN
    5. Rep. Juan Edgardo Angara
    6. Rep. Darlene Antonino-Custodio
    7. Rep. Agapito Aquino
    8. Rep. Benigno Aquino III
    9. Rep. Teddy Casiño * Bayan Muna
    10. Rep. Alan Peter Cayetano
    11. Rep. Justin Marc Chipeco
    12. Rep. Francis Escudero
    13. Rep. Roilo Golez
    14. Rep. Teofisto Guingona III
    15. Rep. Mujiv Hataman * Anak Mindanao
    16. Rep. Ana Theresia Hontiveros-Baraquel * AKBAYAN
    17. Rep. Ruy Elias Lopez
    18. Rep. Renato Magtubo * Partido ng Manggagawa.
    19. Rep. Manuel Mamba
    20. Rep. Imee Marcos
    21. Rep. Rafael Mariano
    22. Rep. Liza Maza * GABRIELA
    23. Rep. Florencio Noel
    24. Rep. Saturnino Ocampo * BAYAN MUNA
    25. Rep. Rodolfo Plaza
    26. Rep. Gilbert Remulla
    27. Rep. Etta Rosales * AKBAYAN
    28. Rep. Rolex Suplico
    29. Rep. Lorenzo Tañada III
    30. Rep. Joel Villanueva * CIBAC
    31. Rep. Joel Virador * BAYAN MUNA
    32. Rep. Ronaldo Zamora

    am i missing something?

  14. BLACK KNIGHT BLACK KNIGHT

    Ellen,

    How about the atrocities/killings made by the NPAs towards the Army Engineers who are building development projects for the people in far-flung/depressed areas?

    How about the killings perpetrated by the NPAs in Aurora of a number of intelligence operatives infront of their families inside their houses during the period 2002 to 2004?

    How about the abduction and killing of some soldiers who were enjoying their R & R with their families in the provinces of Bataan and Zambales in 2001 to 2003?

    How about the exhumed skeletal remains of a missing priest in Nueva Ecija reported by a former NPA member to have been killed by the NPAs in 2004?

    These are only few of the many atrocities perpetrated by the NPAs. But, nobody is tagging the NPA as “human rights violators” and as always, the soldiers are being branded as “human rights violators”. Kawawa naman ang mga sundalo. Mababa na ang sweldo, dehado pa sa tingin ng mga tao.

  15. When I was at UP, I did not join the KM because I did not like the leader, who was feeling high about knowing by heart the ideology of Mao Tse Tung. I did not understand likewise what my professor wouble babble about Communism either. I joined instead the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. One thing I did shared though with the new generation of communists was not really dislike for the Americans but that I did not think I should worship them the way majority of Filipinos did even when the Americans in Manila would be as discriminating toward their Filipino hosts as they were in their own country.

    It was in fact when I came to Japan or when I was in UK that I started fraternizing with these Americans, black and white and in between! Otherwise, I treat them as any other mortals as there are on this earth.

    It was in UK in fact that I became a Socialist, which is far from being a Communist. Then when I settled in the Land of the Rising Sun, I decided I would join the Socialist Party in our community. I am no leftist, mind you. I consider myself in fact as very rightist as I adhere to the rule of law! At least, over here we have a healthy participation in our government. Not even the Communists are called “subversives” over in this country. One can be a leftist, rightist and in between, and that is what is called “freedom”! No one can label anybody as a criminal by being so unless he violates the laws of the land that have been promulgated and pass for the benefit of all unlike in the Philippines where only the moneyed has a privilege to obey or disobey the law!

    I love Japan, because I don’t have to be prejudiced against the Communists here nor do I need to eat propaganda originating from the great ole McArthyist USA.

    Communism is dead. China, for example, has become a capitalist country. What you have there in the Philippines are “tulisans” parading as NPA! But I don’t agree that the AFP has the right to wipe them out. Tao din ang mga iyan. They should be brought to justice and allowed to defend themselves even under the law that they have defiled!

    For me, wala naman silang pinagkaiba doon sa mga nakaupo ngayon sa Malacanang, Kongreso, Senado, Korte at higit sa lahat, AFP! Pare-pareho lang silang burot!!! 😛

    Gosh, it’s really good to be free, even to be free to choose and seek the true God!!! Wala niyan sa Pilipinas. Lahat sinasaklawan ng lagim!!! 😛

  16. Spy Spy

    Melo report, mayuga report and PTI report will never be made public because those will surely confirm that the govt is lying all the way.

    It’s a fact that some if not all political abductions and killings were perpetuated by the military. In Gen Palparan’s case, he organized a special ops group composed of officers and soldier mainly from 24IB wherein he was the former battalion commander. The mission is abduction and liquidation.

    There are a handful of abductees who were earlier released (napagkamalan lang daw) and are now under the ‘care’ of isafp as directed by gen esperon. (i can even name names to prove my contention)

    The victims’ families were really threatened. They’re too scared to complain and testify.

    Kung seryoso ang AFP na linisin ang pangalan ng organization, dapat gumawa ito ng aksyon na maging ligtas ang mga prospective witnesses
    sa pamamamgitan ng pag transfer ng mga units at sundalo ng 69ib at 24ib. Itong mga units na ito ang aktibo sa special operations.

  17. JohnMarzan: arroyo seemed happy back then consorting with commies to oust erap.

    You can bet your bottom dollar, sising-sisi sina Satur Ocampo sa pagpapaloko sa kaniya. Kabalen sila as a matter of fact. BTW, Satur has become subdued, and a useful citizen after years of hiding in the mountains. Burgis na sila ngayon. The Bansot has no right to send them back to the mountains to hide. Siya ang dapat na mamundok!!!

    Over in Japan, the Communists prove themselves useful by keeping the balance of power intact. Filipinos should try to do that! Make good citizens of these NPAs, except the die-hard criminals/tulisans/mandarambong!!! Mas matino pa sila siguro kesa doon sa mga sundalong kanin comrades of BK!

  18. Spy,

    OK then ang input mo. I notice hindi nga naggo-golf! Anong difference ninyo ni BK? Just curious.

  19. Oops, this should read: I notice hindi KA naggo-golf even when I know you love to go to the movies, too! 😛

  20. BK,

    “How about the atrocities/killings made by the NPAs towards the Army Engineers who are building development projects for the people in far-flung/depressed areas?”

    Goddammit! Black Knight, are you a frigging sponge?

    If you know the people who are perpetuating those atrocities, then go get em – capture them, take them to justice and make sure they are imprisoned!

    Shit! If officers and their men in the AFP can’t even perform that mission, then they have no business being in the AFP at all!

    Damn shallow mind.

    What did I tell you Ellen, our AFP are led by shitheads who have no notion of how to go about doing their job. It’s like getting blood out of stone!

    If civilians now have to think and supply them with a step-by-step approach on how to perform their jobs, officers of the AFP ought to be stripped of their uniforms, commands, or sent back to training camp.

  21. Obviously there are crimes on human rights on both sides of the table here. But, you have to realize, that no government should stoop to the level of extremists when they deem it necessary to quiet the so called “insurgency”.

    This is a cycle that the Government has to stop and start leading on. Killing of political opponents, extremists, and even those in the media is still being connected to the military and the Government must prosecute equally without being swayed by who the suspects are.

    As with any type of long standing battle within a nation, military means is but one of many tactics that should be on the table, but is not the only option. A political option in this case is still possible, and in my opinion, the only solution. The extremists are empowered by such acts by the military and only gives them support for their cause. This is why evidence of military involvement is disturbing and not good for our democracy.

    But, democracy is neither in the mind nor in the vocabulary of Arroyo.

  22. chi chi

    They’re hiding the Melon report kasi Dirty Mama Glueria’s ugly face is all over it!

    She was asking EU to help Pinas solve the killings, tapos ang takot naman ng patulan! GGGRRRR! Coward!

  23. I wonder if Colonel Ric Morales of the PMA Corps of Professors is still with PMA (he was a PCG officer under the PN but was so disgusted he resigned from PN to join PMA.)

    Morales was one of the rare officers of the AFP who has integrity and knows what the mission of the AFP is.

    That guy ought to be at least a Usec DND chief in a new govt!

  24. Chi,

    Sabi ko nga, paalembong lang yan ni Tiyanak – invite-invite niya kunyari ang EU coz she’s buying time.

    Dapat diyan sa tiyanak na yan itali sa Melo Report and then thrown in the Celebes sea!

  25. Re: “Dapat diyan sa tiyanak na yan itali sa Melo Report and then thrown in the Celebes sea!”

    And to make sure, Tiyanak remains at the bottom of the sea, pasagasaan sa isang Malaysian submarine plying that route.

  26. Chi: They’re hiding the Melon report kasi Dirty Mama Glueria’s ugly face is all over it!

    She was asking EU to help Pinas solve the killings, tapos ang takot naman ng patulan! GGGRRRR! Coward!
    *****
    No, Chi, hindi niya akalain na hindi pala niya maloloko itong mga EU at UNCHR. Akala niya tamad ang mga ito kasi hindi naman nangyari sa Europe o USA ang krimeng ginawa nila. Sabi kasi siguro ni Uncle Johnny, “Don’t worry we will insist that this is internal affair that foreigners should not meddle in.” Pero kapag Kano, puede! Anak ng tipaklong talaga!

    Rebolusyon na! BTW, over here, something that NCO, Ka Mentong and whachahisname wrote cannot be taken as sedition. Kahit nga sabihin nilang magrebolusyon unless there is the actual taking of arms kasi alam ng mga hapon na maraming version ang “revolution” that can even mean progress. Diyan mo ngayon makikita ang kabobohan ni Bansot at noong mga ina-appoint niya!

    Removing her by force surely will be progress!!!

  27. May pinatay na namang student leader sa Bikol. O baka sabihin na namang ng mga bobo, Communist kasi dapat lang patayin. Stupid! Hindi makakila ng talagang komunista sa isang tulisan! Bobo!

    IBASURA ANG ADMINISTRASYON! IBOTO ANG OPOSISYON!!!
    STOP GUTOM! STOP KURAKOT! VOTE UNO VERSUS UNANO!

  28. BTW, over in Japan, the Communist Party is legal. Malaki ang silbi niya para hindi makakurakot ang mga politiko namin. Mga lawyers dito na magagaling karamihan ay komunista! Bakit hindi iyan magaya ng mga pilipino? Tapos magmamalaking matalino daw sila! Puwit nila!

    Kawawang bansa! IBASURA ANG ADMINISTRASYON! IBOTO ANG OPOSISYON!!! STOP GUTOM! STOP KURAKOT! VOTE UNO VERSUS UNANO!

  29. Chabeli Chabeli

    Gloria is a master in hiding the truth !

    You cannot expect much from someone who has lost all credibility ! In fact, even if she shouts “Fire !” from the top of her lungs, no one will believe her.

    The UN & the EU should just do us a favour & slap the b*tch !

  30. Ellen, Yuko, friends,

    Re MELLOW REPORT

    On second thought, I think it’s a good thing that tiyanak refuses to give a copy of the MELLOW report to the EU official.

    That act will be seen here in Europe as evidence that Tiyanak is hiding something – EU perception of Gloria’s killing machine resulting unresolved extra-judicial killings will be reinforced.

    Good! In that case any person who may find himself/herself in a precarious legal situation in Pinas could actually apply for POLITICAL ASYLUM in the EU.

    The moment that happens – FILIPINOS APPLYING FOR POLITICAL ASYLUM here, GLORIA’s GOVT WILL BE AUTOMATICALLY CLASSIFIED ALONGSIDE President Robert Mugabe of Zimbabwe.

    (Joma and his friends in the Netherlands were the last batch of POLITICAL REFUGEES recognized as such circa 1970s.)

  31. One thing sure is she can’t seek asylum in Japan. Most likely, she will fly to the US unless she wants to be caught in Europe and tried in the international court there for crimes against humanity!

    The PPT trial in March will proceed. The UN and the AI may just as well rely on the evidences, affidavits, etc. to be presented there to castigate the Bansot later.

    IBASURA ANG ADMINISTRASYON! IBOTO ANG OPOSISYON!!!
    STOP GUTOM! STOP KURAKOT! VOTE UNO VERSUS UNANO!

  32. Diego K. Guerrero Diego K. Guerrero

    Gloriang Tiyanak and her inept government are not cooperating with European Union and the United Nations to stop political killings. As usual pathological liar Gloria says something and doing the opposite. Gloria Arroyo lacks transparency and dignity in dealing with human rights violations in the country. The government wants to conceal the truth. Evasive alibi, deception and half-truths will give an impression to the international community that the Arroyo government is guilty as charged.

  33. Ren Ren

    This is very sad, until we learn to respect the sanctity of the human life we will never get out of the rut that we are in. No one has the right to play god deciding whether one lives or die based on having a belief that does not conform to the “establishments” view of their rotten corrupted institutional order or disorder judging from how low we have retrogressed.

    In these modern times of highly sophisticated well informed humanity it is just so unthinkable that there are still people whose mindset still belong to the dark ages. What kind of animal are these leaders who allow killers to sow terror on its own people? How can they without shame or conscience refuse to disclose the MELO findings only shows their utter lack of respect for their constituents they are sworn to protect.

  34. artsee artsee

    Over in China (pahiram lang mula kay Japayuko), legal ang partido Komunista. Bakit legal? Dahil bansang Komunista ang Tsina. Ewan ko ba kay Mang Juan (Enrile) kung bakit pinagalitan ang Human Rights representatives mula ibang bansa imbes na suportahan. Palibhasa kasi siya ang isa sa mga human rights violator noon panahon ni Marcos. Tapos, kakampi pa ni tiyanak ngayon.

  35. Frankly, comparing the Filipinos who call themselves “communists” with the Japanese communists, I dare say the only real communist among them is Joma Sison although a lot of his friends and ex-friends in Netherlands call him now as burgis! One woman who was a fixture of the KM in the late 60’s and tagged as a communist, whom I recognized to be a classmate in some English class, denied that she was ever a Communist. She prefers to call herself now as a nationalist. I understand that she was a founding member of the GABRIELA. So, to the question if GABRIELA is leftist, that to Filipinos mean being communist, I say it is not! It is more a nationalist group!!!

    I met Lisa Masa of GABRIELA in the 90’s when I was asked to interpret for her during the height of the campaign against the deployment of Japayukis to Japan. My impression was I was more radical in my thinking than her, and wondered if she was really as leftist/communist as the AFP would tag her and her members.

    In short, STOP THE POLITICAL KILLINGS IN THE PHILIPPINES! STOP CALLING THESE CONCERNED CITIZENS OF THE PHILIPPINES WHO ARE DOING THEIR BEST FOR THEIR COUNTRY AS COMMUNISTS!

    IBASURA ANG ADMINISTRASYON! IBOTO ANG OPOSISYON!

  36. chi chi

    Grabe itong si Unano, pakendeng-kendeng palagi naman natatapilok!

  37. Ren,

    A Japanese friend coordinating with AI has gathered leaflets that were being distributed by the military in the provinces with pictures of local community leaders marked for execution by the Philippine military. The AI and the UN commission asking for the Melo Report have copies of them so they know what they are talking about contrary to what the Bansot is trying to project.

    That was indeed horribly unbelievable. Meanwhile, we are raising funds to help bring those witnesses to the witness stand at the Hague. Problema iniipit sa airport ng mga salbahe. Even the members of international organizations helping the victims of these atrocities are being included in the list of undesirable aliens and terrorists.

    Mas grabe ito kesa noong panahon ni Marcos sa totoo lang.

  38. Apparently, the distribution of those leaflets is aimed at creating a reign of terror and an atmosphere of fear that they want to blame on the NPA/CPP by implementing an anti-terror law that is ironically sowing terror on the Filipinos!

  39. artsee artsee

    Si Kongresista Lisa Masa ay maka-masa kaya tinaguriang maka-kaliwa. Laos na ang Komunista ngayon. Ang bago ngayon ay “terorista” na ang mga Kano din ang nagbinyag. Kaya okay na tawagin ang isa na Komunista pero kung terorista ay lagot siya. Ngayon pa man, napakalawak ang salitang “terorista”. Ano ba talaga ang “terorista”. Sa Amerika, basta kaaway nila ay terorista. Sa Pilipinas, kapag kaaway ni tiyanak ay terorista din.

  40. “Why hide the Melo Commission report?”
    How can she possibly produce the Melo report to the EU & UN and be transparent when this evil wonderwoman will be shown to be a liar, cheat & thief may be on a killing spree also.
    These investigators from this part of the world, Europe, are transparent, the sort of people who not so long ago criticised Queen Elizabeth II for failing to pay her taxes and having too many employees in her household. This genuine Queen in London automatically volunteered to pay her taxes and reduced her employees in her household, no discussion, no If’s or But’s.
    But they the investigators see this Fake President, and during their visit, in Manila likewise criticised by the Philippine press only to be joined by her prostituted judiciary to slap unlawful charges of the newspaper editor and staff, in an attempt to stop the justified criticism. The gall of it.
    There’s an example of your 1st class world -v- 3rd class world. Does she get it, Nope! because her little legs are still in the gutter with her friends in this evil judiciary, who are devoid of all pride lawyers are thought to have.
    The stupidity of this wonderwoman is that she, remember she, invited the EU & UN representatives to visit the Philippines to investigate these killings. Then true to form refused to produce to them the Melo report to assist them.
    They may consider her actions as that of a liar & cheat or as some sort of mental breakdown on her part or all three! But one things for sure, these investigators won’t go away and forget about it.
    By her taking on the EU & UN could be the start of this evil wonderwoman’s downfall, with her evil supporters. All of a sudden a former President and military man pops out of the woodwork to defend the wonderwoman against the EU & UN, why is this, are there some skeletons rattling in a closet somewhere! Maybe there’s a part of recent history that needs to be kept hidden also.
    COMMENT: For sure the world will see this as evidence that the President of the Philippine Republic is a Liar, Thief,
    Cheat and Mentaly unstable, Unfortunately this is also what will be the view towards the Filipino National when abroad.
    Enough is Enough, get rid of her anyway possible, she is now seen to be surrounded by candidates who will turn themselves over to the highest bidder.
    Are we crazy or what, we are sinking fast!

  41. Changes are possible in the May elections. The solution is with you the voter, just don’t vote for any candidate connected to this evil wonderwoman, thats the start to a fresh start. Then guard the vote with your lives.
    Enough is Enough.

  42. Chabeli Chabeli

    In its headline today, The Philippine Daily Inquirer reports that “GMA orders Melo report released”, however the media will not have access to the document.

    The report says that the EU, as well as the UN’S “special rapporteur may expect to receive on Monday copies of the Melo Commission’s report on the estrajudicial killings, Natinal Seecurity Adviser Norberto Gonzles said yesterday.”

    Why the sudden accommodation ?

    Interestingly, I read in another blog, Uniffors, that “Justice Melo, head of the commission extra-judicial killings said, “INSOFAR AS OUR REPORT IS CONCERNED, THAT IS ALREADY COMPLETE…we have briefed Mr. Alston (United Nations Commission on Human Rights special rapporteur) . We had furnished him of our briefing report. Now, we will brief the EU group, some 15 ambassadors are here, together with other visitors from the international community.””

    Doesn’t this sudden accommodation from Gloria now become irrelevant w/ Justice Melo’s briefing ?

  43. Chabeli:
    Thanks for that up-date of the headline in the Philippine Daily Inquirer. Leaves me thinking that maybe she’s playing around for when her time comes to plead insanity to all charges against her. The charges are certain to happen, its just a question of time! Melo looks as if he’s ready to jump ship!

  44. Chabeli:

    Bakit Monday pa? Para may time to tamper with that report? Bakit akala niya makakaloko siya e mas valid ang hawak ng UN & EU reps kasi mga written affidavits with pictures, etc. including the leaflets, etc. that I was talking about gathered by NGOs who did their investigations in the Philippines unnoticed by the hustlers of the AFP and PNP!

    Halatang may itinatago ang bruha! Ipit na nakunkunwari pa!

    Anyway, if you are interested to know more about the PPT, here’s the home page http://www.tribunal-on-the-philippines.org

    All the needed info is there. Hindi naman stupid ang mga kausap ng mga ungas na iyan sa totoo lang. Mga matitinong tao sila na hindi kakagat sa kabulastugan ni Bansot!

  45. parasabayan parasabayan

    Yuko and PV, I felt the same way towards BK. For all we know, he may me one of the hemmorhoids or one of their alalays. These bodyguards unfortunately just know one thing, to guard the tiyanak with their lives! Afterall they are the beneficiaries of the billions of pesos for the AFP “modernization” kuno. So, all these s*it heads know is how so sip sip to her and to cater to all her wishes including eliminating all her opponents by killing them or putting them in jail! Other citizens have to be second fiddles!

    BK says that the mlitary also has casualties. It is different to have a targetted prey from a casualty by accident( because they are in the cross fire).

    Artsee, kaya nga nakakatakot itong pinirmahan ng congress na “anti terror bill” kasi lahat ng kalaban ni tiyanak ay branded na “terrorist”. Lagot na sila!

    WWNL, yes this May election is hopefully the turning point of our very bartardized politics! I agree, let us guard our votes with our lives!

  46. apoy apoy

    Hindi pa raw final ang mga findings ng Melon kumisyon kaya hindi pa ito maaring ilabas sa pablik.Dahil dito,isa pang kumisyon (Melon Pa)ang binubuo para masusing pag-aralan at timbangin ang report ni Melo. Ha?

  47. Mrivera Mrivera

    spy says: “In Gen Palparan’s case, he organized a special ops group composed of officers and soldier mainly from 24IB wherein he was the former battalion commander. The mission is abduction and liquidation.”

    spy, paki-clarify lang kung kailan ang sinasabi mong period naging battalion commander si gen palparan when he organized special ops group whose main msiion is ABDUCTION AND LIQUIDATION. paki lang.

  48. Chabeli Chabeli

    We-will-never-learn,

    First, you’re welcome for the INQ update.

    Based on your comments (February 17th, 2007 at 11:10 am), I really HOPE that Justice Melo is “ready to jump ship!”

    Let this woman fry in her husband’s lard !

  49. Chabeli Chabeli

    Ystakei,

    I agree w/ your comments (February 17th, 2007 at 12:36 pm) ! Talagang “halatang may itinatago ang bruha! Ipit na nakunkunwari pa!”

    I read about the PPT. Verrrrrrry interesting & promising ! For sure the B*tch will wiggle herself out of that. Let’s see..Ibang playing field na ito.

    By the way, someone whispered to me there’s a “demoralization problem” in Team DisUnity because of the choice of Cesar Montano. May nagsabi na choosing Montano demeaned the Team. Just to show you how out of touch these IDIOTS are ! In the first place, wala naman kredibilidad yung Leader ng Team nila diba ? Credibility is like a mirror. When it cracks, no amount of gluing can make it look the same. Yun na yun. It seems to me na this Team DisUnity is going to implode.

  50. Chabeli
    I would like to think that in the first place I would not find myself in the same situation as Justice Melo, but base my thoughts on that if I were in his position at this moment, I myself would be eager to jump ship.
    Who wants to spend their retirement in jail eh! So, there’s no doubt in my mind that when he met with Philip Alston he, Melo, immediately came clean with him and revealed all there was to know. Thats why this bonehead Arroyo released the report to the UN & EU but not the Philippine press.

  51. Elvira Sahara Elvira Sahara

    Hik, hik hik! Talagang takot si Unano sa Phil. Press! This only means one thing…Very CREDIBLE ang Press natin! Hindi masuhulan ni Unano! Kaya ingat na ingat siya!
    Sa sinabi ni Joeseg na, Ganyan naman si GMA eh, noong una ayaw na ayaw nila ng artista, pero ngayon sa artista pa rin ang lagpak nila or something to that effect.
    Joeseg, di ba si Unano, kilala na natin Na mahilig magpakawala ng mga salita, na at the end, she can’t avoid, but lamunin din naman niya! Kasi WALANG TOTOO sa mga sinasabi niya! GET LOST na lang siya!!!

  52. Mrivera Mrivera

    Lt. Col. Ariel Querubin, Philippine Marine Corps

    MUSINGS

    Ronald Roy

    02/16/2007
    It was Mrs. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo herself who pinned the Medal For Valor, more popularly known as Medal of Valor (MoV), on Lt. Col. Ariel Querubin of the Philippine Marine Corps. She was so proud of him, always addressing him “my hero” and, with a ring of fondness, called him by his first name every time they met. In fact, she never failed to abide by the tradition of saluting first a soldier if he was an MoV awardee. For your information, a soldier always salutes the President first, per force of law. The only exception is if the soldier is an MoV recipient, in which case the Commander-in-Chief is the first to salute, per force of tradition.

    In the entire history of Philippine soldiery, Ariel Querubin became one of only a handful of MoV awardees. He officially received this recognition for acts of conspicuous courage, gallantry and intrepidity above and beyond the call of duty as Commanding Officer, Marine Battalion Landing Team-1, Philippine Marine Corps, Philippine Navy during a 24-hour firefight against an estimated 800 fully armed men belonging to the separatist Moro Islamic Liberation Front at Barangay Inudaran, Kauswagan, Lanao del Norte from March 18 to 19, 2000.

    Tasked to capture the formidable MILF Camp John Mack (Abdullatef), Headquarters of the 303rd Brigade, 3rd Field Division of the MILF, commanded by the notorious Abdul Rahman Macapaar, alias Commander Bravo, Ariel Querubin spearheaded the 1st MBLT composed of 117 officers and men in this hazardous mission against the enemy, superior in numbers, with a familiarity with the terrain, and believed responsible for the spate of bombings in Central Mindanao and the siege of, and hostage-taking at, Kauswagan, Lanao del Norte. On or about 181815H March 2000, while en route to their objective, he and his men were subjected to heavy volume of fire by rebels from their well-entrenched dugouts, bunkers and trenches.

    Unable to maneuver due to darkness and intense devastating fire from both heavy and light machine guns, B-40 rockets, mortar and snipers, he nevertheless ordered his men to hold the line and directed the Special Operations Squad to close in on the enemy camp and pinpoint its location to the Marines’ battalion artillery supporting flanks, and the V-300 and V-150 armored vehicles to dislodge the enemy from their heavily fortified bunkers.

    Unmindful of his own safety, Ariel Querubin continuously moved from one forward position to another, thus drawing enemy fire to his own location, purposely to pinpoint enemy targets for their artillery support flanks. The battle, which had raged continuously until the following day, did not deter him from rallying his men in repulsing wave after wave of enemy reinforcements and unrelenting assaults in their attempt to encircle his unit.

    Despite dwindling ammunition and increasing casualties on their side, Colonel Querubin never lost his aggressive spirit as he continued to move around while urging and inspiring his men, including the wounded, to continue holding their ground. Bunker to bunker, he personally led the assault until the enemy’s line of defense started to crumble. Under his inspiring leadership, his men fought ferociously, forcing the enemy’s last line of defense to collapse and sending them scampering in different directions, along with their dead and wounded, and leaving behind their vaunted rocket launchers and high-powered firearms, as well as documents of high intelligence value.

    The capture of Camp John Mack resulted in the neutralization of the MILF’s most strategic staging area for operations and, more importantly, liberated the residents along the coastal municipalities of Lanao del Norte from the oppressive MILF revolutionary tax collection estimated at P38 million annually. By this gallant deed, Col. Ariel Querubin distinguished himself in combat in the finest tradition of Filipino soldiery.
    The foregoing narration is based on the official files of the Armed Forces of the Philippines.

    But then, times have changed. Mrs. Arroyo now views him as an “enemy of the State” because he has become a threat to her political and personal survival. She egotistically imagines herself as the personification of the State, even if she is but a speck, like a kutong lupa, of the body politic who rules with a purloined mandate. The reward system has been perverted, because rewards are now given to those who kowtow to the whims of the repressive tyrant, while those fully deserving of all the honors accorded by law for their bravery, gallantry and intrepidity, above and beyond the call of duty, are denied those honors.

    Ariel Querubin is one such military rara avis who continues to languish in his undeserved confinement — he who almost perished for love of country with a bullet ripping through his pancreas, intestines and liver — and who, left for dead, most certainly would have been a goner if his left hand with a PMA bullring had not twinged in the morgue — he whose every request must await approval by high authority, such as for a priest or a medical specialist, the emergency’s nature notwithstanding — and he whose seven children often complain to their lovely mother, “Mommy, when will Daddy start coming home at least for breakfast? And why don’t some of our classmates want to play with us anymore?”

    And the eyes of “Pong,” to whom Ariel is “Babes,” can only well with tears, not knowing when they can be one happy family again, and not knowing if her Babes will ever joyously see the dawn of freedom, for which he says he has been trained to offer his life. And the most degrading part of his story is, of course: To this day, his trial remains indefinitely suspended because, per records of the pre-trial investigation, the investigators refuse to change their finding, despite tremendous pressure, that there is no probable cause against Colonel Querubin and other co-accused. There are other detainees, MoV or not, with similar gut-wrenching stories. It is so unfair to all of them, their families and the country they love.

    Five percent of the entire Armed Forces of the Philippines, i.e., from the lowest-ranked foot soldier to the Chief of Staff, are said to be under GMA’s evil money spell. The rest, out of fear, just can’t get organized to bring down her evil regime. In a real sense, therefore, the 93 percent of the AFP are under her voodoo spell, with the remaining 2 percent are fence-sitters. And yet, there seems to be nothing much to hope for, what with GMA’s dirty tricks already in full swing at the start of the campaign.

    ———————————————————-

    nagtatayuan pati balahibo ko sa ilong nang mabasa ko ang write up na ito ng kabayanihan ni col querubin. gusto kong umiyak. gusto kong durugin sa suntok kung maaari lang ang konkretong dingding ng aking opisina sa nadaramang galit sa pisting yawang buang na piking prisidinti.

    yaaaaaahhhhh! ahhhhh! bayan ko, bakit? #@$%$^&*%$#@!

  53. Chabeli:

    The prosecutors, judges and lawyers representing both the victims and the accused in the Permanent People’s Tribunal for the Philippines are professionals, not pipitsugin abogago de calembang de sorbetero who knows only how to “yabang.”

    The idiots were actually saying that this cannot be done, but it sure is being done. Rwandans guilty of ethnic genocide have been tried through this kind of process as a matter of fact. I’m actually looking forward to the day when this pretender to the throne will face her executioner together with her accomplices in committing these crimes against the people of the Republic of the Philippines, a lot many of whom I guess do not even know that it can be done.

    Let’s cross our fingers that all these criminals will be brought to justice, prosecuted and punished as they deserve to be punished.

  54. Mrivera Mrivera

    boom tarat tarat. kasalukuyang sikat na novelty song na bagamat napakababaw ng mensahe ay kinaaaliwan ng balanang humahanap ng pagbabalingan ng atensiyon upang kahit sandali’y malimutan ang pagkalam ng sikmurang (maaaring) bihira nang malamanan ng pagkain dulot ng pagdarahop at kawalan ng hanapbuhay at umaasang sa pagpila sa programang wowowee ay makakasumpong ng iglap na kayamanan. kasabay sa pag-indak sa tugtuging ito ay ang pagkalimot sa katotohanang hindi lahat ay magkakatulad ang kapalaran. subalit, hindi bale na, basta’t puno ng saya, limot na rin ang problema.

    at ganito rin ang laman ng mga bahaw na ulo ng mga kaalyado ng huwad at mandarayang magnanakaw na nagpupumilit maging pangulo ng bansa gayung salat sa kakayahan at walang karapatang mamalagi kahit isang saglit sa loob ng malakanyang. iniisip nilang dahil sa kasikatan ng naturang awitin ay matatabunan nito ang katotohanang sila ang promotor ng nabuwag na pagpupursigeng maisulong nang panakaw ang cha cha na magbubuwag sa mataas na kapulungan ng kongreso tungo sa habambuhay na pananatili sa kapangyarihan ng angkan ng mga gahaman . tila nakakalimutang sa bawat pagharap nila (lalo na ang mga sipsip na bunye, ermita, defensor, claudio, gonzalez at gonzales) sa taong bayan ay parang multong nagbabangon sa kinahihimlayan ang mga katiwaliang kanilang kinasasangkutan na siyang dahilan ng pagtatagal sa poder ng walang kahihiyang babaeng baliw na mukhang daga sa malakanyang na nagsusumiksik sa kanyang umaalingasaw na lungga.

    sino ba ang makakalimot sa iskandalo’t pandarayang tinutukoy sa “hello garci”? sino ang makakalimot sa mga kautusang sumusupil sa karapatan ng bawat isang sandaling namayani sa katulad na pagkakataon noong isang taon, ang pagpapairal ng state of emergency dahil kuno sa pagtatangkang agawin ang kapangyarihan na siyang pinagdurusahan ng mga tunay na magigiting na opisyal ng hukbong sumasalungat sa bulok na pamamalakad? paanong mawawaglit sa gunita ng bawat isang mamamayan kung paano bombahin ng mataas na presyon ng tubig at animo’y hayup na habulin at hinahalibas ng hataw ang mga taong naglalabas lamang ng kanilang mga karaingan laban sa pang-aabuso ng abusadong huwad na pangulo at kanyang mga nakaunipormeng tulisan?

    napakaikli ng memoryang magsasadlak sa kanila sa mabahong pusalian kung saan sila nababagay!

  55. On US reluctance on giving the UN and EU the Melo Report. Playing safe ang kano kasi akala siguro nila kasama iyong kaso ni Smith sa reklamo ng mga leftist daw who demanded for these investigations by the Melo Commission even when Karapatan, the main complainant, is headed by some church-connected individuals.

    Besides, if the US will give credence to the complaints in the Melo Report, it will make their claim on Joma’s group as a terrorist one as an excuse used by the Unano, et al to run after her critics and send them 6 feet underground, as null and void.

    US reluctance to give the Melo Report to the UN may likewise reveal how much role the US has in these extrajudicial killings not really for the sake of the Unano but for keeping US control of the Philippines.

    Surprised? Not at all!

  56. Here’s an addition info from Rod Kapunan of Tribune:

    It was Secretary of Foreign Affairs Alberto Romulo who asked the ambassadors of Britain, Finland, Norway, Spain, Sweden and the EU to assist the Melo Commission on its inquiry. This now explains the EU representation to secure a copy of the report. Its double-dealing tactic to invite the EU to help it window-dress its outrageous human rights records simply did not work because the EU turned out to be an unwilling conduit. Neither can it have a disclaimer since there is no official policy or for it to insist the extra-judicial killings as mere aberrations committed by bloodthirsty elements in the AFP. More than that, Mrs. Arroyo knows the commission she created would, after the inquiry and hearing the testimony of witnesses, make a report that will be made public.

    *****
    Madame Boba-ry will have a lot of explaining to do with a student shot in another case of extrajudicial killing in the midst of the EU and UN factfinding mission.

Leave a Reply