Skip to content

With early 8-2-2 count, massive cheating feared

by Dennis Gadil
Malaya

The Genuine Opposition Opposition, despite an early 8-2-2 lead in the senatorial race, last night shifted its focus to Visayas and Mindanao on reports that administration cheating operators were set to unload at least five million filled-up ballots during municipal, district and provincial canvassing.

Sen. Serge Osmeña III, GO campaign manager, said the opposition had been prepared to concede 600,000 to 1 million “dagdag bawas” votes, primarily in the Autonomous Region for Muslim Mindanao, but was not expecting cheating on the reported massive scale.

“It’s hard to counter the cheating there. It’s a given,” Osmeña said in a press briefing at the GO Makati headquarters.

The cheating would be in the form of vote buying or “dagdag-bawas (vote padding and vote shaving),” he said.

Mindanao has a voting population of 11 million voters, with 1.5 million in ARMM alone.

Osmeña declined to give details of the planned cheating in Visayas and Mindanao that was uncovered by opposition intelligence, expressing confidence it could still be thwarted by a vigilant citizenry.

Other sources said the other provinces to watch are the Zamboanga peninsula, Bukidnon, the Lanao provinces, the Davao provinces, Cotabato, and Maguindanao.

They said even the Misamis provinces, which are not usually considered cheating areas, have experienced a suspicious surge of 83 percent in the number of registered voters.

They said Cebu province registered a 56 percent jump in registered voters.

Osmeña said GO has a sufficient number of poll watchers to counter the cheating attempts.

Osmeña said they were taking it easy on the first day of the elections because, he said, cheating takes place two or three days after the polls.

“The cheating will start tomorrow (Tuesday). We just have to wait and watch. Retail pa ang cheating,” he said.

Osmeña also said even if a million votes go to TU candidates due to cheating, GO team will still have seven winning candidates based on pre-election surveys.

“You know, the surveys already reflect one-half of the dayaan,” Osmeña said.

He said at least three more GO candidates could be considered “dark horses,” including detained Magdalo leader Antonio Trillanes IV. “Trillanes is improving 10 points a week. He’s rising very fast,” he said.

Osmeña declined to name the other two.

He said the TU will have a maximum of six winners factoring in the cheating.

“Pag sumobra pa diyan, garapalan na yun. But you know, nothing will stop them,” he said.

Sources said that in the Zamboanga peninsula, Bukidnon, Lanao provinces, Davao, Cotabato, ARMM, and Maguindanao, a total of 5 million votes have already been readied.

The sources said these were placed in closed ballot boxes since Sunday.

Osmeña said it would be the TU candidates who are in the ninth to 14th slots who will slug it out in the final tally.

“Sila-sila din ang magdadayaan,” he said.

Osmeña said fake Liberal Party (LP) volunteers have also taken the sixth copy of election returns (ERs) from polling precincts in Batangas, Zamboanga del Sur and Lanao del Norte. The LP as the dominant minority party is entitled to the sixth copy of the election returns.

Osmeña said the bogus volunteers are from the campaign teams of Lakas-Kampi, who showed fake LP identification cards and fake authorization from the LP main office.

“These are the dirty tricks that they’re doing. Pero medyo retail pa ang dayaan,” he said.

Missing names

Trillanes and fellow GO candidate Alan Peter Cayetano have started to lose votes as precincts closed.

Trillanes’ name “disappeared” from the official roster of candidates in some precincts.

Election inspectors declared as stray ballots containing only the last name of Rep. Alan Cayetano.

Lawyer Reynaldo Robles of the Trillanes for Senator Movement said his client’s name was missing in Precinct 2-B in Siniloan town in Laguna, Precinct 38-G in Rizal, and a polling precinct in Barangay San Felipe in Padre Garcia town, Batangas.

He said the name of Trillanes was also not included in the list of candidates in some polling precincts in Pasay City and in Precinct 1 in Barangay Pulang Lupa, Las Piñas City.

Election watchdog Halalang Marangal of former senator Wigberto Tañada and retired Marine Brig. Gen. Francisco Gudani reported similar incidents.

Sabotage

Party list groups decried what they said were “massive coordinated efforts” of the government to sabotage their victory.

The efforts range from forwarded text messages calling them “terrorists” to their non-inclusion in the list of candidates in the polling precincts.

Through a nerve center set up at the office of the umbrella organization Bagong Alyansang Makabayan (Bayan) in Quezon City, allied party list groups Anakpawis, Bayan Muna, Gabriela, Kabataan and Suara Bangsamoro received reports on how government allegedly tried to disenfranchise and employ black propaganda against them on election day.

Wilfredo Marbella, Anakpawis party list nominee and internal deputy secretary general of the Kilusang Magbubukid ng Pilipinas, said a black propaganda text message has been circulating since Sunday in Southern Tagalog, specifically in the provinces of Laguna, Mindoro Quezon and Rizal.

The text message said: “Paalala sa sambayanan: Bayan Muna, Gabriela at Anakpawis ay party list ng teroristang CPP-NPA. Please pass. From Gen. Jovito Palparan Jr., AFP.”

Palparan, who retired in September last year, has been waging a war against what he said were party list groups fronting for the communist movement.

He is first nominee of the party list group Bantay which is seeking a congressional seat in this election.

In Metro Manila, local leaders of Bayan Muna who had been vocal against the deployment of soldiers in urban poor communities were not included in the voters’ list.

They were identified as Luz Solayao of Tondo and Romeo Luneta of Barangay Concepcion in Quezon City, both described as residents and registered voters in these areas for a long time.

Campaigning Soldiers

Marbella said that since last Saturday they have been receiving reports of troop buildup in militant bailiwicks and that “soldiers were actively campaigning against us,”.

Marbella pointed to the 28th, 67th and 72 Infantry Battalions in Davao as the units “involved in black propaganda and terrorizing the people not to vote for Anakpawis, Bayan Muna and Suara Bangsamoro.”

Marbella said there also soldiers threatening farmers against voting for Anakpawis in Eastern Visayas.

Poll Irregularities

Halalang Marangal and another poll watchdog, Kontra Daya, said they received reports of election irregularities, particularly disenfranchisement and vote buying.

Among the reports are:

· The name of Romeo Luneta, a member of human rights group Karapatan, was missing from the list of registered voters in his precinct at the Immaculate Concepcion Parish School, Barangay Concepcion, District IV, Quezon City.

· The names of leaders of Bayan Muna were missing in the voters’ list in Barangay 20 in Tondo, Manila. Reports said even the official list of the Parish Pastoral Council for Responsible Voting (PPCRV) does not include Barangay 20. This barangay covers Isla Puting Bato, where there is large concentration of voters.

· Mayoralty candidates in Valenzuela, Zamboanga City and Sapang Dalaga in Misamis Occidental were giving away groceries, five liters of gasoline and P500 to P700 per person in exchange for votes.

· Supporters of a mayoralty candidate in Manila were giving stickers and P20, and as much as P1,000 in barangay 649, Tondo, Manila.

· In Pasay City, a barangay captain supporting a mayoralty candidate was reported giving P200 per person.

· Pagcor chairman Ephraim Genuino was seen going in and out of precincts in Pembo Elementary School, accompanied by armed bodyguards at around 5 p.m. Genuino’s son, Erwin, is running for a congressional seat in the second district of Makati.

Blatant Violations

Despite stern warnings from the Commission on Elections (Comelec), last-minute campaigning and sample ballot distribution were rampant in Manila and Pasay cities on election day.

Several men were seen posting campaign materials at the walls of the Del Pilar Elementary School and Jose Rizal Elementary School in Tondo.

The men, aboard a mini-van of a city councilor bet, evaded arresting authorities.

In Pasay, minutes before polling precincts opened at 7 a.m., election materials were seen being posted along the streets of barangay 66/

Poll Watchers Caught

Makati Mayor Jejomar Binay arrested seven poll watchers of the administration party Kampi at the San Antonio National High School at Mayapis Kamagong sts. in barangay San Antonio.

Binay said the watchers, who were inside polling precincts, were violating the Omnibus Election Code by wearing shirts with the word “Kampi.”

Police identified the watchers as Shaumi Juanillio, Janel Sotto, Myraquel Domingo, Alicia Santiago, Jean Paul Sologuasta, Rudy Avenido and Gino Domingo. They said they were unaware of the election rules prohibiting the wearing of such shirts.

Juanillo and Domingo said they were watchers of Anthony Genuino who is running as councilor in the city’s first district.

Marvin Masangkay, who said he was a lawyer representing the seven arrested, said no rule was violated because “there were no words to the effect saying vote for Kampi.”

Binay said he is filing charges against the Lakas-Kampi candidates.

In the city’s second district, Binay said they have photographs and video showing poll watchers wearing red shirts with “Lakas” and “Lakas Media” printed on them.

Red is the campaign color of Erwin Genuino, who is the Lakas candidate for Congress.

Binay’s opponent, Sen. Lito Lapid, said if he does not win, he will run again in 2010 when Binay’s last term ends.

More Incidents

In Quezon City, Gloria Licad Lanot, 89, who is physically handicapped and wheelchair-bound, was unable to completely fill out her ballot because her daughter was not permitted to assist her, in violation of a provision of the Omnibus Election Code that an “assistor” may fill out the ballot of an illiterate or a physically challenged person if his or her condition is readily obvious.

This happened in precinct 4564-A for Barangay South Triangle at the Kamuning Elementary School.

In Parañaque, mayoralty candidate Pablo Olivarez was accused of vote-buying when some 4,000 voters at the Kuliglig Compound were allegedly asked to vote for Olivarez in exchange for rice and canned goods.

Olivarez is running against Mayor Florencio Bernabe.

Free rides

In Barangay CAA, which has the biggest voting population with 43,909 voters, several PU jeepneys were seen ferrying voters to the CAA Elementary School for free as early as 6 a.m.

The voters said they did not know who sponsored their ride.

Barangay officials detailed at the public school said they had “orders” to allow provide transportation to make it easier for voters to make it to their precincts. They declined to say who gave the order.

In Caloocan, two supporters of congressional candidate Edgar Erice were arrested for distributing rice along Macabalo street on the eve of elections.

The supporters, identified as Ana Urbano and Fe Esperet, said the rice was for Erice’s poll watchers.

Election materials, like sample ballots with the names of local and senatorial candidates, were being distributed to voters at the Caloocan High School on election day.

Failure of Elections

Comelec declared failure of elections in 10 towns in Lanao del Sur after members of the Board of Election Inspectors (BEIs) refused to serve in their assigned polling precincts.

Commissioner Rene Sarmiento, commissioner in charge for ARMM, said the BEI members feared for their lives after shooting incidents yesterday between rival political camps.

“It is for this reason that we are declaring failure of elections,” he said.

Comelec chair Benjamin Abalos said special election will be held in 30 days in the towns of Bayang, Lumbatan, Madalum, Binidayan, Puales, Sultan Dumalondong, Lumba-Bayabao, Masiu, Kapai and Lumbayanague.

“Around 60-70,000 voters are involved here. The result of the special elections that will be held within 30 days might become a factor in case of a close race for the Senate,” he said.

The Comelec also decided to postpone elections in Pantar town, Lanao del Norte after discovering that around 2,000 registrants have not been approved by the poll body.

The poll exercise will be held in the next 30 days.

Polls Postponed

Elections were also postponed in Barangays Litawan and Basak in Zamboanga del Norte after members of the military secured all polling precincts due to reported presence of the Abu Sayyaf terror group.

In Pantao Ragat town in Lanao del Norte, around 3,702 official ballots were missing after these were received by the municipal treasurer.

The town, which has about 10,000 voters, pushed through with the elections after replacement ballots were sent by the Comelec.

The Comelec has invalidated the serial numbers of the missing ballots.

Abalos said there was a report of a ballot snatching incident in Abra while a barangay captain was shot dead by members of private armed groups in Bucay, also in Abra.

Everybody Confused

Abalos said yesterday’s exercise was marred by confusion with voters having a hard time finding their precincts.

Asked if the commission has met the projected 80-90 percent voter turn-out, Abalos said they are looking at an initial report of at least 75 percent voter turnout.

In the 2004 presidential elections, 77 percent of the 43 million registered voters exercised their right to vote.

In Pampanga, there were reports of power outages and vote buying.

Gubernatorial candidate Fr. Ed Panlilio brushed off a last-ditch effort of some quarters to destroy his reputation.

Black Prop

Copies were circulated of a supposed one-page, May 12 issue of a newspaper bearing the masthead of the local daily Sun.Star-Pampanga. The newspaper contained malicious articles about the priest-candidate.

The banner story, written in Filipino, featured Panlilio’s supposed admission about having wives and children while another story featured the alleged withdrawal of support of the Pampanga Chamber of Commerce and Industry for the priest’s candidacy.

The stories were attributed to Sun.star-Pampanga reporters Raymond B. Garcia and Albert B. Lacanlale.

The paper also featured a huge photo of Panlilio with a caption saying that his vitiligo, a chronic skin condition that causes loss of pigment resulting in irregular pale patches of skin, as “an indication of HIV-AIDS virus infection.”

Sun.Star-Pampanga editor-in-chief Ria de Fiesta disowned the publication, saying the paper does not publish in Tagalog.

Garcia denied writing the report. – With JP Lopez, Ashzel Hachero, Reinir Padua, Gerard Naval, Evangeline de Vera, Czeriza Valencia and Jojo Due

Published inElection 2007

25 Comments

  1. Being the eternal optimist that I am living on Mindanao it is difficult to stay positive in attitude surrounded by extreemly corrupt public servants. Most of these public servants got their positions through family connections and have never competed for employment let alone have any qualifications to perform the function.
    Are we really surprised that failure of elections is a factor that remains constant over the years. We constanly compare ourselves with the united states or europe, even invite their observers here to watch over the elections but we don’t seem to be embarrassed when these visiting observers witness the political killings (murder in its best form) and the blatent cheating and planned corruption by the top officials in the land overseen by the comelec which is the biggest culprit. Make no mistake these observers are shocked at what they see, moreover they are just as concerned that we the people don’t seem to face the facts that corruption is widespread. The solution is that of a similar problem, alcoholism! Before an alcoholic can correct his problem, he has to admit he has a problem and is a alcoholic. Like wise the problem of corruption, first we have to admit we have become corrupt as a nation and that we want to stop being corrupt!
    We need to call a spade a spade, that is acknowledge the fact that part of our problem is culture and the pecking order that has been adopted in family and social lives whilst the rest of the world compete fairly for employment and positions of authority.
    Make no mistake, our problem in Mindanao, if not challenged and checked by our present law enforcers, will quickly spread to the whole country. Whoever becomes our new Senate members I just hope and pray that they have the courage to correct the mess we are in.

  2. nelbar nelbar

    WWNL:
    Hindi pa handa ang Mindanao.
    Hindi pa akma ang salitang Federalism para sa kanila.
    Sa ipinapakita ng mga lokal na eleksyon sa Mindanao ang kanilang pagkiling sa political dynasty, isa lang ang patutunguhan ng MINDANAO! – ang sistemang piyudalismo!

  3. As a foot note:
    Why even bother to challenge the vast numbers of public servants of corruptio, when we just missed the chance of curbing corruption by terminating every member of this present comelec and recruiting people who have already prooved to be honest enough to do a good job.
    If comelec did their job properly, honestly, independently without fear of favour then the corrupt leaders of this land couln’t commit their plans to steal votes from the people. Abalos should be made an example of as a start for failing miserably to police the peoples vote. This man is an insult to members of the Bar but they have no backbone to challenge him, another example of ‘pecking order’ even by lawyers.
    Maybe there’s time to send a signal to the top officials by terminating all members of the comelec NOW! no if’s no but’s just do it NOW! Its the first step of sending a message to the administration officials that corruption has to stop.

  4. Some say that there is a divide between the folk in or around Manila and Mindanao. Should that be true, then I would like to stress that the problems of Mindanao wont stop at the shores of Mindanao Island, because these folk on Midanao are actually filipino, with filipino passports the same as all filipino. The problem will spread all over the Philippines. make no mistake.
    Maybe you need time to think and understand what I am saying.

  5. rose rose

    Magtatandrum si Gloria kaya dadaya ng husto ang kanyang mga sundalo. Hindi titigil yan hanggang sa hindi niya makuha ang gusto niya. A massive cheating indeed is forth coming.
    In his article (Manila Bulletin) R. Pefianco from Antique and a good friend wrote that vote buying and selling is rampant. If somebody else said this I won’t believe it but since I know him it must be true. Nakakalungkot.

  6. zen2 zen2

    GOOD NEWS, first, this time:

    latest partial results based on ANC Halalan 2007, as of 8:19 hrs, May 15, 2007.

    1.) Escudero, Chiz — 1,461,220
    2.) Legarda —-1,392,659
    3.) Lacson —-1,275,935
    4.) AqquinoIII —-1,244,220
    5.) Villar —- 1,214,813
    6.) Pangilinan, Kiko– 1,204,600
    7.) Cayetano, Alan —1,044,057
    8.) Arroyo — 959,783
    9.) Trillanes — 950,987
    10.) Honasan — 932,014
    11.) Angara — 918,074
    12.) Pimentel — 917,074
    13.) Recto — 820,180
    ……..
    16.) Defensor — 731,113
    ……..
    19.) Sotto — 556,856
    20.) Coseteng — 487,164

    Explanation:

    a.) results are based on Nationwide stats; part of the 10% voting population pre-determined survey sampling covering the whole archipelago, and ALL economic classes.

    b.) Comelec accredited watchgroups like Namfrel, PPCRV, LENTE, bundled together as one, are conducting their own unofficial count. Results are strikingly similar to that of ANC’s.

    c.) Exit polls, (by ABS-CBN & Pulse-Asia) too resulted in similar standings, reported above.

    Am holding off personal assesment on Cayetano’s very strong standing since them BASTARDS are actually monitoring this blog. If friends care to remember, my report that progressive youths, etc. were campaigning for Trillanes ? later on the day, Ebdane, Ermita and gang are pinning down Trillanes, connecting him to the underground Left.

    saka na lang, when smoke clears a little.

  7. zen2 zen2

    additional good news:

    * Fr. Ed Panlilio, the dark horse in Pampanga’s gubernatorial race, leads Pineda (jueteng lord Bong Pineda’s wife) and Mark Lapid.

    * Darlene Custudio leads Manny Pakyaw by at least 40%, in GenSantos City, Congressional race.

    * Mabulos and Dato Arroyo tiff in Camarines Sur is deafeningly silent. will follow-up.

  8. chi chi

    More good news for the opposition sana!

    Hindi sana makasingit ang cheating machine ng mga Pidals!

  9. chi chi

    More good news: SURENDER NA SI GARCI!
    ****

    Garci concedes defeat in Bukidnon

    Congressional candidate Virgilio Garcillano on Tuesday conceded defeat in the congressional race of Bukidnon’s 1st District a day after polling precincts closed in the province.

    Garcillano blamed a smear campaign by his rivals for his failed congressional bid after he received reports from his own monitoring teams that he was losing the count to Liberal Party candidate Malou Acosta.

    http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/storypage.aspx?StoryID=77241

  10. chi chi

    Malakas pala ang endorsement ni Mrs. Poe kay Malou Acosta!

  11. jojovelas2005 jojovelas2005

    I’m happy so far…
    “Reelectionist Darlene Antonino Custodio is ahead of world boxing champion Manny Pacquiao in the congressional contest in General Santos, according to a report on GMA Network.

    Quoting from the partial unofficial AMA count, the report said Custodio has garnered 14,060 votes while Pacquiao has 6, 790 votes.”

    “Congressional candidate Virgilio Garcillano on Tuesday conceded defeat in the congressional race of Bukidnon’s 1st District a day after polling precincts closed in the province. ”

    Chavit Singson kulelat sa botohan..

    And of course, Trillanes #9 in tally.

  12. chi chi

    Someone knows what’s happening in Pangasinan between Joe dV. and Benjie Lim?

  13. chi chi

    Mabait muna ako ngayon para pahinga muna sila sa pagmonitor! I’ll also comment after na lang.

    Sige, Trillanes. Up, up and up pa!

  14. nelbar nelbar

    Kung tatawasin ang demokrasya sa Pilipinas, narito ang aking napansin sa mga nakaraang eleksyon buhat noong 1986.

    Cory’s Magic : 1987 election and 1995 midterm election

    FVR assumption to power : 1992 election and 2001 election.

    Erap Masa appeal : 1998 and 2007 election

    2004 election : Garcified election result and elitist electoral exercise.

  15. expect the pro-arroyos to like bong austero, “non-partisan” organizations like NAMFREL and CBCP to pooh pooh the reports of election cheating and irregularities, and declare the elections “relatively” clean and credible.

    And yes, the foreign observers, who doesn’t know that dagdag bawas usually happens after the elections, DONE BY ELECTION AND MILITARY OFFICIALS, will declare the elections violent free and orderly. they declared the last 2004 election credible too, didn’t they? lol.

  16. parasabayan parasabayan

    Sayang, sana sa lahat ng distrito ay mayroong nakalagay na representative ang oposisyon. Di sana panalo silang lahat. Kulang lang ng paniniwala nung iba sa opposisyon. Talagang galit na galit na ang mga tao kay tiyanak. Sana hindi makakasingit ang cheating brigade ni tiyanak. Dapat maghalinhinan ang mga tao ng pagbabantay ng mga ballot boxes. Bantayan ang lahat ng mga pintuan! Mahirap ng malingat kahit na isang segundo lang. Matitinik ang mga kalaban!

  17. jojovelas2005 jojovelas2005

    I agree Ms. Susan Roces is a big endorser for Chiz and Malou Acosta…actually muntik na nga akong mapaiyak ng na interview siya ng GMA7. “NGAYON MAGISA NA LANG AKO”…bale may na karma naman diyan dati #1 sa Senado ngayon nasa #19.

  18. cocoy cocoy

    Sana hindi na madaya at okey na ang mga nasa magic 12,Si Recto ay idi-divorce na ni Vilma kasi pangit pala siyang lalaki pag hindi Senator.

  19. cocoy cocoy

    Si Garci noon pang hindi pa nag pa file ng candidacy niya,naisulat ko na dito na hindi talaga siya mananalo,mismong si Gloria ang maglalaglag sa kanya.Pag napunta si Garci sa Congresso ay ayaw ng mga tuta ni Gloria dahil araw-arawin siya ng mga opposisyon hanggang sa kumanta siya.Ang mga kriminal ay hindi nila ibinabandera ang kasangkot nila sa krimen,pinapatahimik para hindi na magpahamak.Yabang kasi ang nangingibabaw kay Garci.

  20. Mrivera Mrivera

    ano’ng malay natin na sinunod lamang ng mga pulis at kawal ng utos sa kanila ng mga heneral na pulpol na iboto ang lahat ng kandidatong TUtae (baho!), pero pinagbilinan ang mga kamag-anak nila’t kaibigan na gawing ZERO as in BOKYA ang boto para sa mga basura ni gloria?

    puwede rin, di ba?

  21. parasabayan parasabayan

    Tumpak Magno! Sa sama ng loob ng mga napilitang sundalong bumoto sa mga TUtae, tinawagan nila ang kanilang mga kamaganak at mga kaibigan, ang resulta panalo tuloy ang GO! Matalino man ang matsin, napaglalamangan din. Kaya lang, smooth operators ang mga iyan. Pag tulog ang lahat ng tao, magmimilagro sila sa mga ballot boxes. They will plant the five million TUtae votes. Lagot na naman ang labanan! Kaya huwag tayong matutulog! Bantayan natin ang mga ballot boxes. Mahirap ng maisahan ng smooth operator tiyanak!

  22. chi chi

    Tama, Cocoy. Dahil problema nang malaki ang ibinibigay ni Garci sa mga Pidal! Tagpas na ang leeg niya. Garci has no more leverage!

  23. dzandueta dzandueta

    Someone knows what’s happening in Pangasinan between Joe dV. and Benjie Lim?

    Mukhang panalo si JDV kung totoo ito:

    newsinfo.inquirer.net/breakingnews/metro/view_article.php?article_id=66209

    Golez congratulated Speaker Jose de Venecia, who also won by a landslide in the fourth district of Pangasinan over Dagupan City Mayor Benjamin Lim.

Leave a Reply