Skip to content

SC orders Smith placed under RP custody

Constitutionality of VFA affirmed

by Tetch Torres
Inquirer.net, Agence France-Presse

The Supreme Court has ruled that custody over convicted rapist Lance Corporal Daniel Smith should be transferred from US to Philippine authorities and ordered the Department of Foreign Affairs to negotiate the move.

While affirming the constitutionality of the Visiting Forces Agreement (VFA) that governs the military exercises between the two countries, the high court said the subsequent accord which Foreign Affairs Secretary Alberto Romulo and US Ambassador to the Philippines Kristie Kenney signed and which granted the US custody over Smith was “in violation of the VFA.”


The court said that under the VFA, US servicemen convicted of crimes in this country should be held by Philippine authorities.

In the same ruling, the court has ordered the Department of Foreign Affairs to “negotiate with the US representatives for the appropriate agreement on detention facilities under Philippine authorities.”

The high tribunal decision stemmed from a petition filed by Senate President Jovito Salonga and former Senator Wigberto Tañada that questioned the continued detention of Smith by the US embassy here.

The Salonga group said the transfer of Smith in December 2006 from the custody of a local court to the US Embassy showed that the VFA had virtually amended the Philippines’ rules on criminal procedure on arrest, bail, arraignment, and plea.

“Said provision of the VFA, in immediately vesting custody of any US personnel over whom the Philippines is to exercise jurisdiction, to the US military authorities, if they so request, from the commission of the offense until completion of all judicial proceedings, effectively violates and impinges on the power of Philippine court to acquire custody over the US personnel,” they said.

They said the issue of custody should remain a matter of court decision.

A court official, who asked not be identified, said the high tribunal had decided that Smith should be detained in a facility under the Philippine government’s control and that the US embassy did not qualify as such a place.

Smith was sentenced to 40 years in jail in 2006 for raping a Filipina after military exercises north of Manila in 2005.

He was initially detained at a local jail pending an appeal, but was later transferred to a detention facility inside the US embassy.

Smith’s conviction prompted Washington to threaten to call off large-scale exercises with Manila until Smith was transferred to the detention center within the sprawling embassy compound on Manila Bay.

The rape case has outraged nationalist and leftist groups, who are demanding that Smith be held in a local jail.

Despite two years in detention at the US embassy Smith is still waiting for his appeal to be heard.

Published inForeign Affairs

84 Comments

  1. Patton Patton

    Much as I will fight for the country’s sovereignty, I have misgivings about this case because I still can’t accept that it was rape.

    Smith met the woman in a bar, drunk. Why would she be there if she were not looking to hook someone.

    I feel for Daniel Smith. His future is ruined because of one mistake.

  2. Tilamsik Tilamsik

    Iniisnab kasi ni Obama si Gloria, hayan gumanti ang reyna!

  3. skip skip

    A woman can say NO at any stage. That she is in a bar, drunk and appears hot to trot doesn’t mean anything at all if she decided not to have sex at the last moment.

  4. parasabayan parasabayan

    Off topic: Paule is at the St Luke’s now. Tomorrow, the pig and Joc-joc will go for their “regular” check up. Pustahan tayo!

  5. SULBATZ SULBATZ

    Patty…..”I feel for Daniel Smith. His future is ruined because of one mistake.”

    You feel for Smith but you don’t feel for our kababayan whose future was ruined too. You said it was a mistake, then it was one costly PAKEN mistake.

  6. My reading of the incident was a consensual amorous encounter between two adults which was transformed into rape by force of public emotions. Call me an old-fashioned prude, but I firmly believe that a female who goes to a bar, gets tipsy enough to turn randy and chases a willing male deserves to be screwed.
    The SC decision will have wide-ranging impact on U.S.-Philippine relations starting with the VFA with nationalistic fervor probably prevailing over reason. Nicole’s lawyer Ursua has fired the first salvo and initiated the move to abolish the VFA, the link to the military assistance goodies the AFP takes for granted. Worse, as when the Yanks abandoned Subic and Clark, we risk losing the protective umbrella of security of the U.S. Navy (although a remote possibility as this would break the chain of mutual security arrangements with nations surrounding China.) But with a protectionist President Obama, who can tell for sure?

  7. Isagani Isagani

    Bakit ngayon lang yan, ano? Palagay ko tama si Tilamsik: pakulo ni Gloria yan para mapansin siya.

    I bet na sa huli, pabida si GMA kay Obama at gagawin niya ang gusto ng mga Amerikano.

    Sana iwidraw na ng America ang mga bigay-libreng tulong sa Pinas na sa bulsa lang ni FG at ng minions niya napupunta.

  8. SULBATZ SULBATZ

    Neonate,

    If you had a daughter similarly situated as Nicole’s, will you swallow your nationalistic fervor in lieu of the expediency of US’s “protective security” cover and good relations? I think what is misplaced is NOT our nationalistic fervor, but the misplaced priorities we impose upon ourselves and by countries whose interests are not ours.

    Think about what U.S. could have done if it were a Filipino soldier who did the same act in US territory. What would you say?….”suits him well?”

  9. atty36252 atty36252

    All that effort for a twerp who sullied his uniform. Consensual? The judge who had all the evidence before him disagreed.

    Meanwhile, many come home maimed after a stint in Iraq, and are shabbily treated by the Armed Forces they served.

    http://articles.latimes.com/2007/mar/21/local/me-disabled21

    Semper fi young man. But your US legislators are more semper fi to corporate interests than to you.

  10. IIRC, Nicole’s family operated a canteen inside the US Marine camp in Zambo. And in fact she was engaged to marry another US Serviceman – explains her fondness of American soldiers because she feels safe with them. Turned out she was wrong.

    Kung Pinoy yung boyfriend baka kinatay na yung si Smith. Swerte pa siya.

  11. bitchevil bitchevil

    Finally…it’s long over due. Let’s see how Washington would react to this. SC under Puno is not hopeless after all.

  12. balweg balweg

    RE: You said it was a mistake, then it was one costly PAKEN mistake?

    Reporting Sir Sulbatz!

    Kundi sa PAKEN libog ng Kanoteng yan, e wala sanang problema? Sa totoo lang e parausan ng mga Kanoteng yan ang Pinas, bokya itong si Smith kasi nga e si Maria Clara ng makabagong panahon ang tinuhog niya so bagsak siya sa kalaboso.

    Either guilty siya or not, dapat yong pagiging manyakis niya e pagbayaran at bigyan ng leksyon ng matuto…kung may bitay pa e silya elektrika ang dapat diyan ng di pamarisan ng mga gahaman sa laman.

  13. Tedanz Tedanz

    SULBATZ .. hindi na kasi kapani-paniwala ang mga nangyayari sa atin dahil sa Pekeng Glorya. Ako hindi ako boto na buksan ang kaso na yan sa ngayong nagpapapansin ang Pesteng Glorya na yan. Binibisto pa ng Amerika kung gaano kagahaman ang mga nasa administrasyong kasalukuyan lalo na ang pamilyang Arroyo. Kung ito ay isang paraan para mapahiya o di kaya mapa-alis ang mga peste sa buhay natin huwag na tayong kumampi pa kahit galing sa SC ang desisyon. Sino sino ba ang mga Justices na bumuto para dito?

    Sana wag na natin bigyan ng importansiya ang balitang ito. Para lang kinakampihan natin yang kagustuhan ni Peke at Pesteng Glorya na yan.

  14. bitchevil bitchevil

    That could also be a retaliation to the Bitch’s failure to meet Obama.

  15. Tedanz Tedanz

    Pagtu-unan pansin na lang natin ang mga kaso na kinakasangkutan ng mga Arroyo at ang kanilang mga TUTA’s. Mukhang binabago na naman nila ang isyu. Ang isyu talaga ay SILA!!!!!!!! Puweeeeee!!!!!

  16. Tedanz Tedanz

    Ang gagaling talaga ang mga Tuta ni Glorya … pinahiya lang ng Amerika yong unano nilang Prinsesa at yong Baboy nilang Prinsepe ….. gumanti sila agad …. sa isang Private Smith lang. Ay naku ano pa ang ginagawa natin mga kababayan ko kumilos na tayo … wala na tayong mukhang iharap pa sa buong mundo …. sinira na lahat ng mga Arroyo.

  17. Sarap ng buhay ng convicted rapist. Nasa air-conditioned na container van, merong laptop, at cellphone pa.

  18. Tedanz Tedanz

    Blacklisted fa yong asawa sa u es of ah ….. heheheheheeheh …. kaya

  19. Tedanz Tedanz

    Gusto ipatanggal sa listahan kaya ganun …. hihihihihi

  20. Tedanz Tedanz

    Si Praybeyt Smith ang kapalit …… OH Noooooooooooooooooo!!!!!

  21. chi chi

    My guess is that Obama will not even look at Smith’s case. Sa laki ng kanyang problema sa domestic front, hindi na nga siya makangiti. Besides, magagalit sa kanya ang feminists, heheh.

    Gawa-gawa lang yan ni Gloria and her best friend Kenny who also worked hard for the US State Department to get Gloria an appointment with Hillary. Nabigla yata si Hillary na bumulaga sa kanya ang putang babae. Sa video nila ay pilit na pilit ang pagharap ni Hillary sa pekeng presidente ng Pinas. Baka yung appointment clerk lang ang nagsingit kay Gloria, o bina-blackmail na sya ng klasmeyt kuno ni Bill.

    If there’s one diplomat Barack should replace, it’s Kenny. There’s already a strong bond/attachment between Kenny and Korap Gloria. Nakurap na rin ni Glue e!

  22. Sobra ang takot ni Smith na ma poke in his dear arse. He would have learned in the city jail what is like to be gang raped. He would be the favorite princess in the jail block. Ha ha.

  23. bitchevil bitchevil

    Not at all. The US would demand that Smith be given a separate cell citing security as reason. As usual, VIP treatment would be given.

  24. deanr deanr

    ang point d2 sa kaso na ito ay iba. alam ko na it doesn’t matter kung ano ang point ko.:)
    It should be at least pareho silang may kasalanan. Si babae ay nankukso ng isang puti at ang puti ay nag pa tukso. Hindi naman pwedeng landiin ng isang babae ang isang lalake and then sasabihin mo na stop pag nandoon na kayo sa point na mag tatalik. Parehong buhay nila ang nasira dahil sa dalawang pag kakamali nila. Kung talagang ikakasal sya sa bf nyang puti. bakit sya nasa bar at nanlalandi ng iba?
    sorry at wag kayo magagalit at ito lang ang tingin ko sa nangyari….thanks!

  25. Diego K. Guerrero Diego K. Guerrero

    Daniel Smith’s custody issue is a test case on Pres. Obama’s foreign policy. Anyways, Uncle Sam won’t allow his boy/s to be sodomized inside Bilibid prisons. Gloria Arroyo will try to sell herself again as a willing partner to take out so-called terrorists in exchange for Smith’s US Embassy custody and continued US support on her bogus presidency.

  26. Mike Mike

    This reminds me of the the case of Michael Fay who as an 18 year old living in Singapore then was sentenced to 6 strokes of caning for vandalizing several cars in the Lion City. Several high US gov’t officials including then Pres. Bill Clinton tried to pressure the Singaporean gov’t not to push thru with the caning. The Singapore gov’t stands it’s ground by not giving in to pressure although the caning was later reduced to 4 strokes.

    My question is, can the gov’t of gloria resist pressure from the US just like what Singapore did back then? Or is she hoping that, finally, Barack will call her up to discuss the case of Smith after being snubbed by the US Pres. 3 times?

    Link on Michael Fay’s story below:

    http://www.corpun.com/awfay9405.htm

  27. Mike Mike

    Sinong kawawa? Hindi lang si Smith o si Nicole ang kawawa dito. Tayo rin kawawa, Siguradong ibebenta nanaman tayo ng palugi ng reynang bulok na si gloria para lang makakuha ng konting puntos mula sa mga kano at makausap sana si Pareng Barako.

  28. chi chi

    deanr,

    I like your points, simple. It takes two to tango, ‘ika nga. Who knows what really went on, di ba?

  29. chi chi

    Gloria Arroyo will try to sell herself again as a willing partner to take out so-called terrorists in exchange for Smith’s US Embassy custody and continued US support on her bogus presidency. – DKG

    Ka Diego,

    Paano yan, e hindi na basta binibili ni Barack ang isyu ng terorismo. Paktaylo na rin ang paglalandi ni Gloria sa isyung iyan pagdating sa kasalukuyang foreign policy ng admin ni Obama.

  30. Dapat lang, mga unggoy, na ibalik si Smith sa kulungan—Muntinlupa na dahil convicted na ang animal. Why should the Filipinos allow the Americans to insult their intelligence? Ano sila umaamin na bobo sila? Gagoooo!

    Dito nga sa Japan, kahit magreklamo ang mga kanong nakakulong sa preso dito, hindi makahirit ang mga kano kasi sa totoo lang, mas maayos naman ang kulungan namin dito kasi. Ang katwiran kapag nagreklamo halimbawa sa pinapakain sa kanila, “When in Rome, do as the Romans do.” Kung magrereklamo sila, di dapat sila gumawa ng krimen. Kung gusto nilang ibang pagkain, sariling bayad nila. No special privilege komo kano sila.

    Ganyan dapat para hindi mukhang uto-uto ang mga pilipino. Problema kasi sa mga kulungan sa Pilipinas, parang babuyan na isang katutak ang preso sa isang kuwarto, wala pang kuwenta ang mga tulugan, kainan, etc. Salaula kasi. Nakakadiri sa totoo lang. Yuck!

  31. E ano naman kung lumandi iyong babae. Di naman niya sinabing, rape-in siya. Ang kaso ni-rape siya nang lasing na siya. At kundi pa dumating iyong patrol, baka na-gang rape siya.

    Buti na lang dumating ang patrol, at buti na lang di siya bumagsak head on sa kalsada, kundi baka napatay pa siya nang itulak siya ng mga kano mula doon sa van na pinangyarihan ng krimen. Rape is rape, kahit pagbaligtarin ang mundo, rape pa rin, meaning isa lang ang nasarapan! 😛

    Sa mga anak na babae ninyo kaya nangyari iyan? Ano kaya ang magiging damdamin ninyo?

  32. Puede ba tigilan na ni Gloria Unano iyong pag-i-stalk niya kay Obama.

    Walang panahon ang bagong presidente ng USA na makipaglandian sa kay Gloria sa totoo lang. Gurang na siya (pangit ng mukha nang tumabi kay Hilary!) at higit sa lahat, sinabi naman ni Obama na hindi siya interesadong makipagkaibigan sa mga kurakot na pinuno ng kung anumang bansa, kaaway man o ally ng America. Basta kurakot, burado sa listahan niya.

    I’m glad that at least he is standing on what he has said in his inaugural speech. Hail to Obama!!!

  33. deanr deanr

    yung kay mayor sanchez ang tawag ay rape. yung kay jalosjos ang tawag rape. Yung k smith at sa pinay may question mark.:) kung manyari sa anak ko yon? sasama ang loob ko. pero kung mabuti akong magulang wala doon ang anak ko at maglalasing at manglalandi ng mga kano. anak mo na engaged to be married na sa isan puti din. sya ang humukay ng sarili nyang for her being there at para humiwalay sya sa pinsan nya na kasama nya…sorry pare at ito lang ang point ko talaga..:)

  34. deanr deanr

    ay sorry at hindi ko alam kung pare o mare:)

  35. kitamokitako kitamokitako

    Ano ba naman kayo! Napatunayan na sa korte na rape, baket may duda pa kayo? Nabasa ninyo ba o alam ba ninyo ang buong kaso?

  36. deanr deanr

    kung ano lang nababasa namin sa dyaryo ang naging batayan ko. may duda kasi ako sa justice system natin noon pa. Nakita ko yan growing up. Abogado ang tatay ko at ninong ko ang isang sikat na judge dati( yon nga lang patay na sya).
    kitamokitako, sensya na at opinion ko lang ito. wag ka magalit pls…kwentuhan lang:) thanks!

  37. xman xman

    Alam mo kitamo, kitako, at kitang kita ng sambayanang pilipino na wala ng kridibilidad ang korte suprema at lahat ng korte sa ilalim ng con artist fake president arroyo.

    Para sa akin ay rape ang ginawa ni puti. Mag sasampa ba ng kaso yong pinay kung gusto nyang ma rape ng puti. Anong motivation nya para idemanda yong puti? dahil ba sa pera? Kung dahil lang sa pera ang gusto ng pinay eh matagal ng tapos ang kaso. Malaking kahihiyan yong nangyari sa pinay pero lumaban pa rin sya para ma idepensa ang karangalan nya.

  38. xman xman

    “Smith was sentenced to 40 years in jail in 2006 for raping a Filipina after military exercises north of Manila in 2005.

    Smith’s conviction prompted Washington to threaten to call off large-scale exercises with Manila until Smith was transferred to the detention center within the sprawling embassy compound on Manila Bay.”

    Noong 2006 ay takot na takot si pekpek president kay Bush dahil tinanggal ni pekpek yong Filipino troops sa Iraq. Kaya para hindi magalit ng husto si Bush kay pekpek ay pinayagan ng pekpek court na ikulong muna si puti sa custody ng US embassy.

    Ngayong wala na si Bush at hindi sya pinapansin ni Obama at ito pang WB kurakot exposures ay pede ng sundin muna ang batas ng pilipinas na kailangan nasa custody ng Philippine government si puti.

  39. hKofw hKofw

    Let’s keep targeting the Ganid Family and their cronies. They are the real and present danger to our country. Ang issue kay Smith ay gabutil lamang sa laki ng bundok ng problema ng Pilipinas dulot ni Ganid. Ang bayan natin ay parang babaing paulit-ulit na niluluray at lugmok na hirap dulot ng Pamilya Pidal. Lantaran pa ang ginagawa nilang mga kawalanghiyaan. Araw-araw walang palya ang mga balita ukol sa mga katiwalian ng pekeng gobyerno. Wala na silang takot sa batas at Diyos. Walang batas-batas, walang diyos-diyos sa kanila. Gagawin nila ang gusto nilang gawin ng walang pakundangan. Mga husgado, pulis, militar, kongreso, senado, simbahan – halos lahat ng inaasahan na magtatanggol sa ating demokrasya’t konstitusyon ay nabusalan na ng kuwartang nakaw ng mga Pidal. Ang alam ko, maraming tao, individual man o organisasyon na hindi nila nabili, ay puwedeng lumaban sa kanila, pero nasaan na sila? Maglabasan na kayo! PATALSIKIN na si Gloria Ganid!

  40. Inilaglag na ng Tate si Gloria. WB and ADB are syndicating a big loan package for Indonesia. The ADB is conducting its meetings directly in Indonesia and not in its ADB-Manila Headquarters.

    In times when foreign credit is very hard to come by, the lenders make it known who deserves to be helped or not. In our case, it is worse – the WB statements and suspensions are very much like bible passages that warns all institutions that lending to the Philippines will be considered a mortal sin.

    Who will we turn to? China Eximbank – whose only purpose is to promote Chinese contractors and suppliers? Or JBIC – exclusively for Japanese contractors with local partners where 7 of 10 projects are overpriced and incomplete?

    The EU will not touch base with Manila because of its human rights record and the French are still sour over my friend Hubert D’Aboville’s dressing down in the Senate. Being a very influential member of the EU, France will use that influence to highlight human rights abuses in its Brussels meetings.

    Canada? Not either. It goes where the US goes.

  41. BTW, Lavalin of Canada has backed out of its earlier commitment to finance the LRT1 extension from Baclaran to Cavite leaving the entire project in limbo.

    But guess what? US$81M worth of trains have already been purchased by LRTA under separate JBIC funding!

    These trains might have wings!

  42. chi chi

    Inilaglag na ng Tate si Gloria. WB and ADB are syndicating a big loan package for Indonesia. The ADB is conducting its meetings directly in Indonesia and not in its ADB-Manila Headquarters. – Tongue

    Indonesia, hindi yan pababayaan ni Obama. Kaya pala kasama kaagad sa itinerary ni Hillary.

    Bastan nandyan ang China, walang problema si Gloria sa korapan. Ang problema lang niya ay kung hanggang kailan siya tatagal sa nakaw na trono.

  43. chi: “Indonesia, hindi yan pababayaan ni Obama. Kaya pala kasama kaagad sa itinerary ni Hillary.

    Oo nga pala, hehehe. Maigsi na yata ang ruler ko a.

    That being said, major financial institutions are actually heading towards Indonesia and totally avoiding countries that are “on the wrong side of history”. You just can’t imagine the power of mere words when spoken by a US president.

    Gloria will try for the last time – in the next APEC meeting in Thailand. Boy, is she in for a major disappointment!

  44. Inquirer:
    US Ambassador Kristie Kenney on Tuesday said Manila could no longer fit in Clinton’s schedule.

    Hillary of course wouldn’t want to be on the “wrong side”!

  45. Chi,

    Re: “Indonesia, hindi yan pababayaan ni Obama. Kaya pala kasama kaagad sa itinerary ni Hillary.”

    If you examine US foreign policy pertaining to South East Asia, you will find that even under Bill Clinton (and even those before him, and maybe even under Dubya Bush but of course we don’t know how well or badly Dubya did things since, as we all know, the guy was clueless), Indonesia was always on top of the US agenda — Indonesia is the country that has the largest Muslim population in the world.

    Back in 1998 or 1999 (or was it in 2000?) when Anwar was put in jail by Mahathir, did you know how often Madeleine Albright went to Indonesia? 3 times in a span of a few months. That was a lot!!!

    Not even the Philippines, so-called major non-NATO ally of the US had that privilege but Indonesia had the constant attention of Washingtn; although RP was lucky to be visited by a deputy secretary of State in the person of Cristopher Hill (at the height of Gloria’s state of emergency nonsense).

    Matter of fact, one week after the jailing of Anwar, Albright went to Jakarta right away; the US needed and still needs a friendly Muslim nation in that region of the world or the US was banking on Anwar following in the footsteps of Mahathir (contrary to popular belief, Anwar was an Am Boy while Mahathir was detested by the US). But Anwar was jailed by Mahathir (following intelligence reports that he was at the beck and call of the CIA) so the US needed to immediately set up some kind of foothold in the region, hence Indonesia became one of the favourite diplomatic watering holes of Sec of State Albright.

    Obama, and of course, Hillary, will keep the diplomatic lines of communication open with Indonesia, not only because Obama’s younger formative years took place there but because geopolitics dictate so — if there’s one potent Muslim nation that could erupt in that part of the world, it’s Indonesia.

  46. And of course when Cristopher Hill went to Manila at the height of Gloria’s nonsense, he went para pagalitan ang duwendeng walang moral!

  47. Of course, kasama ang Indonesia, Malaki ang oil reserves and refinery niyan aside from the fact na second country ni Obama iyan. Diyan siya lumaki. Pero dahhil sa problema ng Tate, di niya kayang iwanan ang bansa niya ngayon. Hindi katulad noong tangnanay na kriminal na pasyal ng pasyal kasi gustung masabing most traveled president of the Philippines siya gaya noong tatay niya na naging the first president of the Philippines who visited Africa during his term as president. O loko di hindi na siya binoto ng mga pilipino ulit kasi gutom na nga ang pilipino noon, namasyal pa ang ungas. Worse, nagbigay pa ng inutang sa Aemrica, etc. doon sa gobyerno ng Madagascar. Sinabi pa yata ng may tupak din sa ulo na doon nanggaling ang mga ninuno niya. 😛

  48. chi chi

    Anna and Tongue,

    Ang gagaling talaga ninyong magtuloy ng aking short two liners. 🙂

  49. syria syria

    Ang tunog ng fart ni Smith bago ikulong sa Pinas – PIIIIIIT
    Pagkalabas niya, ang ang tunog ay – BOHH

  50. jose miguel jose miguel

    We were already born as a nation, a beautiful independent and republican nation in 1898. We were experiencing how it is to develop our own system thru our own efforts and creativity. We were organizing our defense system into an organic, creative, independent and effective system. We were consolidating our national education. From the “Pedagogy: Teaching Practices of American Colonial Educators in the Philippines”, Isabelo Pefianco Martin noted that we had a flourishing literature in the late 1890s and they were not in English.

    However, in 1899, the Americans invaded our infant nation. They raped our newborn sovereingty. The researches from http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Crete/9782/ and from E. San Juan in his, “U.S. Genocide in the Philippines A Case of Guilt, Shame, or Amnesia?” provide us with the following information:

    In several of our provinces, the American Forces conducted scorched-earth tactics, hamletting or “reconcentration”, pillaging of our homes, raping of our women, mass torture such as dismemberment, the water cure and the rope torture, disease, and mass starvation to flash out or capture those among us who were resisting their invasion. Zinn wrote in “A People’s History of the United States” of 300,000 of us Filipinos killed by the Americans in Batangas alone. William Pomeroy wrote in “American Neo-Colonialism of 600,000 of us Filipinos died in Luzon alone. A total of 1.4 million of us Filipinos died within the period from 1899 to 1905 of the American invasion. The thousands of Filipino Muslims among us who also died in that invasion is not yet included in that total casualty figure.

    When our physical resistance was already weak, the Americans transmitted a developmental virus- heritage injuring virus into our systems so that it would be corrupted into dependency and submissiveness to them. They reprogrammed our military to recognize them as our superiors and our brother Filipinos resisting their invasion as THE ENEMY. We became willing to be perpetually inferior and dependent.

    From the “Pedagogy: Teaching Practices of American Colonial Educators in the Philippines”, Isabelo Pefianco Martin said that during the American invasion of the 1900s, Philippine Literature and other media that were not English in our schools were removed by the invaders. They rammed into our throats the English Language. The education that they transmitted to an entire formative generation corrupted us from our original character with particular reference points, national identity, what it means to be beautiful, great, good, to have life, to be superior. We were transformed into an inferior submissive and willing national rape victim because of our race, to a superior and savior rapist because of their white race.

    They developed an entire generation of our governing system to be composed of only alienated to our heritage and submissive and collaborative of foreign invaders.
    This heritage injuring virus has been replicated for generations. This is the reason why our dignity is being continously raped by either foreigners or foreign collaborators like GMA and we accept it as just a legitimate political exercise.

    Are we going to continue to allow this replication of raping by the Americans?

  51. Tilamsik Tilamsik

    jose miguel Says:
    February 12th, 2009 at 12:21 pm
    We were already born as a nation, a beautiful independent….
    *************************

    Good one..!

  52. Tilamsik Tilamsik

    Para mapansin sya ni Obama, dapat si Gloria ang mag pa-rape kay Daniel Smith…!!

  53. MPRivera MPRivera

    our justice system had long lost its credibility.

    what remained and is prevailing now is their criminality!

  54. patria adorada patria adorada

    Tama ka Jose Miguel.”Water cure”ang ginamit ng mga kano to extract info sa mga Filipinos.Ang sniper na sundalong Filipino,isang beses lang iputok at dapat tatama sa target dahil once naiputok na niya ang usok mula sa baril ang magtuturo sa kanyang position.Yong kaban ng bayan worth billions mula sa galleon trade ninakaw pa nila maliban sa mga ginto.
    Sayang natalo tayo.But one thing i’m sure,mas matatapang ang Filipinos noon kaysa ngayon.

  55. balweg balweg

    Exactly MPRivera! Our injustice system e pinamumugaran ng mga hoodlums in uniform, kaya dapat matuto na ang taong-bayan at kailangan tapusin na ang kamandag ng mga salot sa ating lipunan.

    Ang taong-bayan ang magpapasaya ng lahat or else magtiis tayong lahat sa kawalanghiyaan nila!

  56. MPRivera MPRivera

    patria adoracion,

    kung tapang din lamang naman, eh parehas pa rin ang mga pinoy noon at pinoy ngayon.

    mas medyo may pagkahinahon lamang ang mga kababayan natin ngayon.

    ang problema madali silang nauto ng mga merong dinoktor daw na degree at minaster na kasinungalingan kaya ang labas, tinatalo ng gutom at pagdarahop ang tapang.

    ‘ayun tuloy, parang mga bakang may tali sa ilong!

    kung saan hilahin, doon haharap at kahit hagupitin ay buong amo pa ring tinatanggap.

    gutom nga, eh!

    sabi ng mga gagong walang matinong katwiran – WALA DAW PUWEDENG PUMALIT o maaaring ipalit sa sinungaling na magnanakaw upang mamuno sa ating bansa!

    @#!$%$#%^&%^**()_+”?>!@!!!!

  57. jose miguel jose miguel

    Hindi sayang natalo tayo patria adorada. Hindi rin mas matapang tayong Filipinos noon que sa atin nayon. Hindi lang alam nang marami sa atin ang nangyari noon. Hindi lang alam nang marami sa atin kung saan ang ating inuuwian at kung gano ka precious itong atin na kinuha nitong mga invaders at tinago sa atin.

    Ang totoo, itong ating resistance contra sa mga invaders ay hindi pa tapos. Ang kailangan lang ay malaman nang cada isa sa ating Filipinos ang nangyari noon. Ito ay para maintindihan natin kung ano ang dahilan nang nangyayari sa atin nayon. Kung naiintindihan natin ang dahilan, puede natin ma identify ang problema. Kung alam natin ang problema, puede natin makita ang solusion.

    Kaya ito ang atin puede magawa sa ating bayan. In fact, ito ang isa sa akin tingin ang pinaka importante para gumalaw tayo mga Filipinos na parang isang katawan at espiritu lang. This is the key kapatid! Let us spread this knowledge to all of us Filipinos as best we can within our capacity and sphere of influence.

    Bukas, makauwi na rin tayo sa ating sariling bahay!

  58. chi chi

    Nakakaiyak naman ang poste mo, Jose.

  59. balweg balweg

    RE: Ang totoo, itong ating resistance contra sa mga invaders ay hindi pa tapos?

    Paanong matatapos ito JM…kung mismo tayong mga Pinoy ay watak-watak at may kanya-kanyang nilalandas sa buhay?

    Remember the 8 rays in our Flag… ito ang mga probinsiyang nakibaka labang sa mapang-aping dayuhan? Isinalang dito ang mga bayaning nagbuwis ng buhay alang-alang sa Inang Bayan.

    Alam mo sa aking bayang sinilangan isinilang ang unang republika na nagahayag ng pagtutol sa mga ilustradong mananakop at pinagyaman ito mga mga kinikilala nating mga bayani na pumukaw sa damdamin nang mga nakararaming Pinoy upang ipaglaban ang kasarinlan ng Pilipinas laban sa mananakop na banyaga.

    Nangyari ang pinangarap nang ating mga ninuno na makamtan ang kasarinlan ng bayan, datapwa’t ang bilis nakalimot ng mga susunod na saling lahing Pinoy.

    Isinilang dito ang mga ilustrado ng matutong magbasa ng ABCD at sila ang naging simula upang muling gawing busabos ang kapwa-Pinoy kaya muling isinilang ang mga MAKAPILI upang tutulan at tuligsain ang mga naghaharing-uri sa ating lipunan.

    After na makamit natin ang panibagong pag-asa e sinaklot naman ng mga mapagsamantalang elitista sa ating lipunan ang karapatan ng mga nakakaraming Pinoy.

    Dito muling umusbong ang pingkian ng lakas at talino upang wasakin ang pagkakaisa ng sambayanang Pinoy at ngayon na nga e nararamdaman nating ang epekto nito.

    Pinoy against Pinoy sa tulong ng mga pwersang banyaga na may personal na interest sa ating bayan. Winindang ng kayabangan ang pag-unlad ng bayan at pinulbos ng dusa ang kawalang hustisya na ngayon ang siyang nagpapahirap sa ating lahat.

  60. Tangnanay ni Gloria, binaboy na talaga ang hustisya. Ipinapakita pa ng lantaran ang incompetence ng justice department, court and prison authorities ng Pilipinas.

    Never heard sa ibang bansa ang pagbaboy ng gobyerno ng Pilipinas sa mismong bansa, institution, etc. nila. Bastoooooos!

    Dapat sulatan si Obama tungkol diyan. Ipatalsik iyong kenny-ng burimong ambassadress nila. Dami sigurong natatanggap na pabuyang galing sa nakaw ang demonyang iyan mula doon sa pinakademonyang Gloria Magnanakaw.

  61. bitchevil bitchevil

    Do you see the pattern? Just when the WB scandal investigation started, here comes the Smith case. Did the SC decision come up to cover up the WB scandal? Scandal after scandal. Cover up after cover up. We shall be seeing this cycle until 2010. Wanna bet?

  62. Para mapansin sya ni Obama, dapat si Gloria ang mag pa-rape kay Daniel Smith…!! – Tilamsik

    Ang sentensiya kay Smith, prison mayor. Pag ni-rape niya si Pandak, instant death sentence yon.

  63. Just wondering what kind of provision is there in that VFA when the US servicemen misbehave and try raping all the women they meet on the streets, bars, etc. during their unconstitutional military exercises in the Philippines. May bagong executive order ba si Gloria Bogli na dadaan sa kaniya bago ibigay sa US Embassy? At saka for how much?

    Tangnanay nila. Kung gusto nilang umalma sa kabastusan ng mga kano, puede naman nilang gawin.

    Bakit dito sa Japan, kahit meron US-Japan military pact, pag gumawa ng krimen ang mga bastos na malilibog pang mga sundalong kano, kalaboso sila complete with the same treatment as any incarcerated criminal in Japan, walang special privilege gaya ng ibinigay kay bogli Smith.

    Alam ko kasi madalas akong makapag-interpret sa mga unggoy sa korte sa Japan. Iyong taga-legal office nila, hindi kumikibo. Nag-o-observe lang.

  64. chi chi

    Para mapansin sya ni Obama, dapat si Gloria ang mag pa-rape kay Daniel Smith…!! – Tilamsik

    Ang sentensiya kay Smith, prison mayor. Pag ni-rape niya si Pandak, instant death sentence yon. -Tongue

    Hahaha! Sabi marahil ni Smith ay pasa-Munti na kahit maging dark and blue ang kanyang wetpu. Grabe talaga ang virus ni Gloria, instant death.

  65. Idadagdag ko sana, iyong Amerikanong legal officer sa US base, hindi nakikialam sa legal process ng korte dito. Nag-o-observe lang.

    At saka iyong US ambassador, kahit pa dating VP siya ng Amerika, etc., hindi nagdidikta kung ano ang dapat gawin ng korte at preso sa Japan o makiusap na pakawalan ang mga inarestong mga bastos na sundalo nila Maingat sila kasi baka mag-riot ang mga tao dito at magkagulo. Nakikisama ang mga kano para maganda ang image nila sa Japan.

    Sa Pilipinas, wow, wala silang kiber kung masira o hindi ang tiwala ng mga pilipino kasi kahit anong kabastusan ang gawin nila, nakahalik ang mga pilipino sa mabahong puwit nila! Tapos ngayon itong si Gloria Stalker, panay pa ang stalking doon sa bagong presidente ng Tate. Gusto pa yatang makatikim ng maitim na putahe!!! Ngeeeeeeeek!

  66. JM: Isabelo Pefianco Martin noted that we had a flourishing literature in the late 1890s and they were not in English.
    *****
    Pero nakasulat sa Spanish kahit iyong “Florante at Laura”! Iyong lang mga instructions sa mga katipunero ang nakasulat sa tagalog para basahin ng pinuno nila dahil karamihan naman hindi nakakabasa!

    One of Rizal’s apprehension in fact regarding granting of independence to the Filipinos by Spain was the lack of education of Filipinos. Rizal was advocating first for Spaniards to educate Filipinos before they are granted independence. He was right as a matter of fact. Look what’s happened to the Philippines now. Mga pilipino alipin ng kapwa nila pilipino (mostly mestiso—mestisong kano, mestisong kastila, mestisong intsik, mestisong bombay, mestisong hapon, mestisong koreano, etc.)

    JM:

  67. JM: However, in 1899, the Americans invaded our infant nation.
    *****

    The timeline, JM, was 1898. Aguinaldo in fact made a pact with Dewey who probably promised him a meaty position in case the US would succeed in driving out the Spaniards, who were apparently by the getting weary of the sporadic attacks of the natives, who were first organized by Bonifacio. I understand the Spaniards did not want to surrender to the KKK, so the US and Spain staged the mock battle of Manila while Aguinaldo was declaring independence at Kawit. That was 1898 not 1899.

    The treaty of Paris that granted US full ownership of the Philippines was dated 1898. And the US probably was able to run the country without interruption in 1899 after capturing Aguinaldo and his men in Isabela although Sakay and the other Katipuneros continued the fight as they refused to be under US rule.

    The Sakdalistas, in fact, continued the fight for Philippine independence, and became the foundation of the MAKAPILI before the movement was contaminated by the dugong aso of Macabebe when their leaders, including Ricarte, escaped to Japan prior to WWII.

    At least, now we hear of these massacres committed by Americans in the Philippines with articles written by patriotic historians like Constantino, et al. Hindi na puede iyong history books written by people glorifying Americans in the Philippines, and based only on the random reports done by H. O. Beyer for the Taft Commission prior to Philippine occupation by the US in 1898.

  68. Ginagago ang karamihan sa mga pilipino kasi walang mga pinag-aralan. Kaya nothing is done to improve education in the Philippines sa totoo lang. Mga kabisote pa kung nakapag-aral para madali silang utuin.

    Kawawang Pilipinas! Lalong nasadlak sa dusa!!!

  69. balweg balweg

    Exactly Grizzy…sige upakan mo pa ang mga pesteng yan, makaganti man lang tayo kahit na sa pamamamgitan ng pluma at WWW.

    Dapat ipadlak na ang UP/PMA/ATENEO…bakit ka mo, ganito yon…di ba ang halus sa mga insurektos e graduate sa mga school na ito? Look, ang tongresso/senando/malacanang/afp-pnp e pinamumugaran yang ng mga dating aktibista na nakibaka laban sa mga pasista pero ng maluklok sa poder ng kapangyarihan e mas lalong naging mabangis ang kanilang ka ek-ekan sa pagdusta sa karapatang pang-tao at ibinugaw ang Pinas sa mga dayuhan.

    Recycled issues ang pinagtatalunan ngayon, karamihan sa mga pasaway na yan e sila noon ang maingay sa kalye at walang habas sa pagkotra ng mga nakaraang rehime.

    Sige wag mong tigilan ng pagpuna tutal libre naman ito at kahit papaano e makabawi man lang tayo sa puyat at sama ng loob.

    Keep the good shot!

  70. Tangnanay nila. Parang “she loves me, she loves me not!” itong ginagawa ng SC. One moment ipinababalik si Smith sa preso ng Pilipinas, next moment OK na rin daw doon siya sa embahada nila. Ano iyan? Lokohan? Bastusan na lang ba?

  71. Balweg:

    Graduate ako ng UP. Sabi nga, “those were the days.” Si Gloria nga di nakapasok sa UP noon dahil ayaw pumayag ni President Cinco na pumasok doon ang ungas na hindi kompleto ang curriculum at hindi puede iyong hindi siya kukuha ng entrance exam. Galit na galit si Dadong. Laking issue iyan noon.

    I don’t know how UP is now. Daming mga kuratong ang lumabas later on gaya noong balitang kabit daw ni Gloria na si Mike Defensor. Pati iyong Manny Villar, Cayetano, Escudero, et al. kuratong din kasi galing sa mga parochial school abg nga unggoy na iyan.

    You bet, ipasara na iyong Ateneo, etc. Wala namang itinuturong mabuti sa mga mag-aaral nila! Useless!!!

    Salamat na lang may iba pa akong pinasukan university na puedeng ipagmalaki!

  72. syria syria

    Ibagsak ang imperyalistang kano. Sigaw ng mga estudyanteng rallyista noon. Nang mauhaw, may mga umorder ng Pepsi at yung iba Coke. Natawa na lang si Uncle Sam.

  73. Tama ka, Syria. Isang kilalang aktibista na komunista daw ngayon US citizen na. Hindi na raw siya komunista, burgis na raw siya. Yuck!

  74. norpil norpil

    naguguluhan ako dito sa mag papa rape daw si gma sa sundaling puti. di ba ang rape ay kung ayaw? kung gusto naman niya ay hindi na rape iyon, baligtad na, siya na ang mang re rape dahil ayaw ni puti pero gusto niya. instant death na nga ni puti kung ganoon.

  75. norpil norpil

    galing talaga ni toungue, pareho ang conclusion kahit iba ang starting point.

  76. bitchevil bitchevil

    The FBI is keeping a confidential report about the Evil Bitch raping Bill Clinton when they were still students. Recently, the US Secret Service found out that the Bitch wanted to rape Obama. Since she had diplomatic immunity, she was not arrested. However, the Secret Service has decided not to allow her to get near to Obama.

  77. balweg balweg

    syria,

    Ang siste nito eh nang mauhaw ka mo sa sobrang katatalak sa rally e pepsi at coke ika mo ang pamatid uhaw, biglang may naalala opppssss tingin sa relos yaks Timex pala ang suot ng pobre…US of America brand pero gawang Pinas o kaya assembled sa China.

    Kita mo naman ang mga ka ek-ekan ng mga damuho e kontra dito, kotra doon kung beberipikahin natin ang mga suot na burloloy sa katawan e made in USA pala (akala nila naka okray na sila e peke pala dahil nakodiko ng mga instik sa Tsina o Taiwan isama na natin ang Hongkong).

    Yan ang hirap sa mga nagdudunong-dunungang pulitiko at tropang Pidalismo Federal gov’t. kunyari pa sila na ke kontra kay Uncle Sam pero sa totoo lang doon naman sila nagsusumiksik at karamihan may green card pa ang kapamilya.

    Mga utak lipya at gungoongsalez, kailangan pinapasadahan ito paminsan-minsan nang matinag ang kumag.

  78. bitchevil bitchevil

    Hilary Clinton departs Sunday for Japan, Indonesia, South Korea and China, her tour is a symbolic gesture aimed at reassuring friends and allies of their standing and impressing the Chinese with early engagement.

    …Isn’t the Philippines America’s friend and ally? The last time I heard of a US State Secretary visiting Indonesia was quite a while. It appears Indonesia is now more important than RP. Well, this could be Obama’s foreign policy towards the Philippines as long as the Evil Bitch is in power.

  79. MPRivera MPRivera

    basahin natin si bernard taguinod:

    Pinoy laging dehado
    Bernard Taguinod

    Kahit saang panig ng mundo, mukhang laging dehado ang mga Filipino dahil kapag mayroon tayong mga kababayan na nakakasuhan ay inaaaresto at ikinukulong agad ng host countries.
    Tulad nitong kaso ni dating Police Supt. Michael Ray Aquino, agad inaresto ng US authorities nang masabit ang pangalan sa kasong pang-eespiya, pero may nagawa ba ang Philippine Embassy sa Amerika, tulad ng ginagawa ng US Embassy sa Manila sa kaso ni Lance Cpl. Daniel Smith?
    Walang nagawa ang Philippine Embassy pero itong si Smith, hindi man lamang nakatikim ng pagkakulong sa kulungan ng Pilipinas kahit nasentensyahan na sa kasong panggagahasa kay Nicole.

    http://www.abante-tonite.com/issue/feb1509/opinions_bernard.htm

Leave a Reply