Skip to content

Judge Lorredo to Defensor: drop case vs Lozada if you don’t want to get sick like Mike Arroyo

Updated: Dehydrated Lozada rushed to hospital.

Update: Justice Secretary Raul Gonzalez said Lorredo’s remarks are “extraneous” and that he should stick to the merits of the case. Malaya has the report.

I love Judge Jorge Emmanuel Lorredo. Read his order in the perjury case filed by Mike Defensor against Jun Lozada to find out why. You’ll have the best laugh of your life.

Click here. VERA Files printed it in full.

Here’s the downloadable copy:
lorredo-order-4may09

Published inNBN/ZTEVera Files

133 Comments

  1. Hahahahahah!

    For me, sige continue para ma-swine flu siya.

  2. He is sooo funny. Di ba?

  3. Oh my! I just read the file!

    Just incredibly brave! Wow, bravery/courage/sense of what is just/ is contagious rin pala…

    Yeeehaw for Judge Lorredo! I’ll campaign and vote you for president Judge if you decide to run…

  4. bravery… (gosh even my spelling is getting excited!)

  5. To think that we thought, he was a coward by going on leave the day the arrest warrant was served.

    A friend thinks he wants to be disqualified from the case for bias, that’s why he wrote that order.

    He is sooo funny. I was laughing and laughing while reading it.

  6. Valli Valli

    This is a classic! I think I will have it framed! Thank God for sane judges!

  7. Ellen,

    Judge Lorredo’s order had me flummoxed!

    Puwede ba yon? I mean, it’s so not very like legal orders we read…

    […] “Furthermore, I say that it may be very bad for his health and his family as well. If he gets sick like Mike Arroyo, would not that be bad for him and his family?

    The Presidents that I have known are only Presidents Marcos, Aquino, Ramos, Estrada and Arroyo.

    My observation is that of all the presidential spouses, Atty. Mike Arroyo is the one who is very sickly. He has a serious heart disease. He even tries to make us believe that he is in no condition to attend Senate probes.

    Imelda was strong during Marcos’ incumbency. Aquino, of course, was a widow during her term. Ming was so healthy and strong during Fidel’s time; and even after Fidel’s term, she was even the president of the Philippine Badminton Association. Dra. Loi was also very strong during Erap’s rather abruptly ended service.

    There are those who say that the serious heart disease is some kind of punishment for Atty. Mike Arroyo. I do not know if this is true, for I do not really know how our Lord works, for He does works in mysterious ways. But what I do know is that Lozada is being protected by the Church, by the priests and nuns. That must mean something. Defensor, take note: that must mean something.

    …/…

    Now, why are all these so important for Defensor to ponder on. Simple: if it is true that Mike Arroyo is being punished, Defensor may also be punished with some serious disease. I am sure his loved ones do not want that to happen to him.”[…]

    I’m just a bit surprised by the wordings but mind you, I like it and boy, this judge is one hell of a judge, c’est un vrai justicier!

  8. Valli Faith E. Bibit Valli Faith E. Bibit

    This is a classic! I think I will have it framed! Thank God for sane judges!

  9. Ellen,

    Is that so? He would like to be disqualified, reason for the wordings?

    Ngeeek!

  10. Only in the Philippines would you have a judge issue an order like this.

    With people like Judge Lorredo, there is hope for this country.

    As you said Anna, courage is contagious.

  11. What do you think? I was thinking, with what he wrote, I’m sure Defensor’s lawyer will ask that Lorredo inhibit himself from the case for bias.

    But at least he has already said his piece. What an explosive piece!

    I’m wondering what Mike Arroyo would say to this.

  12. Ellen,

    That piece is explosive indeed! Anyway, what can Mike Pidal Arroyo do? He’s not a member of govt, he only happens to be the spouse of a wannabe president, and so if we are to be technical about it, he can fulminate all he wants but Lorredo is a member of a so-called “independent” body, hence, Arroyo shouldn’t use government powers to intimidate Lorredo.

    And I am just soooooo tickled pink. Wow, parang blogger!

  13. I also like this part:

    Please pray also for me, so that I may always be a good, humble, God fearing and very wise Judge to those who seek justice in my courtroom; and so that I may be elevated from a Judge to a Justice (even though I do not have any political backers) for that would surely make my late father, Jorge Lorredo, Jr. (who is now with Jesus in heaven watching me with a smile on his face) and my mother, Mary Lorredo, very proud of their only child.

    I think I know his father. Raul Manglapus media adviser was Jorge Lorredo. He served as head of DFA’s press office for a while.

  14. This is just U-N-B-E-L-I-E-V-A-B-L-Y GOOD!

  15. Ellen,

    I am giggling here! I can’t believe it … just incredible!

    “and so that I may be elevated from a Judge to a Justice (even though I do not have any political backers)”

    Gosh… puwede ba yan in a legal document issued no less than by a judge?

  16. Only in the Philippines!

    I’ve re-read the order 3 times and I’m ROFLING here.

  17. mabilis tatalab ang karma sa kanila.

  18. jojovelas2005 jojovelas2005

    Naku po! pagnabasa yan ni DOJ chief malamang suspended na si Lorredo..grabe totoo ba ito? Siguro talagang natatawa na lang yun judge sa kaso ni Lozado.

  19. Elgraciosa Elgraciosa

    Ellen,
    I still didn’t believe it came from Judge Lorredo if not for his signature!

    Judge Lorredo….WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN HIDING???

    …You’re the ONE…the MISSING CHIEF JUSTICE…the Philippines should have had but never FOUND!!! It’s NOT too late yet!

  20. Elgraciosa Elgraciosa

    I believe in K_A_R_M_A! Sana …masama man..but the Lord understands!

    GO! GO! GO! Judge Lorredo! I’m thanking God for you…specially in my prayers today!

    Am copying his Order and send it to friends in the Phils.!

    Yes, Anna….it’s UNBELIEVABLE!!!

  21. Luga Luga

    Bakit wala man ni isang daily newspaper ang naka-pagbalita niyan Ellen …. totot ba to!!!!

  22. Rose Rose

    Is this for real? classic order…if he is Jorge’s son he is young…

  23. Elgraciosa Elgraciosa

    ELLEN,

    Ain’t Judge Lorredo a God-sent for us? HE is sending us a lighted CANDLE…just when everything starts to dim for a great guy who’s name is Jun Lozada!
    (It’s almost 10:30 pm, our time here in Central Europe. Am supposed to sleep early. Psst… My beloved son is getting married tomorrow!!! What am I doing here? Better force myself to sleep despite all the excitements around me!

  24. chi chi

    Ha!ha!ha! Buti at nakapasok ako ngayon.

    Best laugh ever!

    I love this Judge Lorredo. Way to go, Judge L!

    Meron na ring swine flu si Little Mike, matagal na buhat ng s’ya ay maging palamunin ng kanyang Dirty Mama Gloria!

  25. atty36252 atty36252

    In the Louie Beltran case, Dean Antonio Coronel had the supreme satisfaction of being the only lawyer to ever cross-examine a president. Ramon Makasiar was the only judge to have presided over a case where the witness was the president.

    Baka yan ang gustong mangyari ni Lorredo.

    Whoever is defending Lozada, I envy him/her this opportunity.

  26. myrna myrna

    i hope this judge does not get the brunt of sipsip-to-gma justices in the supreme court that may warrant his suspension or any disciplinary measure.

    hehehhehe…at least mayroon isang judge na may balls na makapagsabi ng sinabi niya. i tried to access the full court order, hindi ko mabuksan waaa.

    anyway, thanks ellen for this valuable information. hay sana, tuloy-tuloy na ito….

  27. chi chi

    Wow! Taong-tao si Judge Lorredo!

    Tiyak ay may bwelta sa kanya ang carrier ng swine flu na si Mike Arroyo.

  28. Whaaat? Again, whaaat? Maniniwala pa siguro ako kung si chi o si Anna o si grizzy ang sumulat. Pero, yung judge?

    Are you absolutely sure this is true? Hindi koryente?

    OMG, natapon yung kape ko sa kakatawa, nagising lahat ng tao dito akala sira na ang ulo ko (tama sila) sa lakas at haba ng tawa ko.

  29. Dito tumapon yung kape ko:

    Now, why are all these so important for Defensor to ponder on. Simple: if it is true that Mike Arroyo is being punished, Defensor may also be punished with some serious disease. I am sure his loved ones do not want that to happen to him.

    But has Defensor not already been punished in some ways? He lost in the last senatorial race because he was perceived to be protecting the first couple during the NBN ZTE deal hearings; because he was perceived to be trying his best to make Lozada stop talking. He used to be presidential chief of staff, now he just has old, dilapidated, rusty trains to play with. At least some of the trains still run.

    BWAHAHAHAHA!

  30. xman xman

    Gawing Supreme Court Chief Justice yang si Lorredo pag wala na yang mga pidal.

  31. I agree, there will be a motion for inhibition or disqualification…for the reason of insanity.

    But let’s analyze this, why did the judge act this way? My ESQ…er..ESP tells me he is suffering from the extreme pressure being exerted by the evil bitch’ camp, maybe threatened, too, that this is his way of getting back at them.

    No judge in his right mind will ever write an order in such tenor. I feel sorry for the guy, I think he has lost it. I’m sure the other camp is preparing to retaliate.

    People have to rally behind the judge.

    Seriously.

  32. Dati si Ma. Teresa Pangilinan na isang estudyante lang ang bumanat ng hayagan kay Gloria, ngayon judge na!

    We’ve come a long way! 90 million cowards minus one!

  33. Tongue,

    You think he’s under severe pressure from the Evil Bitch?

    If so, the judge gave it all he got sort of nothing to lose anymore… that’s why he’s virtually telling what the defence ought to do:

    “Why this case is not to the best interest of the first couple—

    “Since Defensor is not a trial lawyer, he apparently has not seen the very explosive potential of this case: the first couple (Gloria and Mike Arroyo) may validly and legally be dragged into the proceedings by Lozada’s defense team. All that the defense team has to do is invoke certain provisions of the Rules of Court. As a fair and impartial judge, I shall have no reason not to grant such request.

    “It is true that evil, cruel and vindictive regimes can use the law to make their enemies suffer, but it is that very same set of laws that can enable the oppressed (to) fight back. Such is the beauty of the law: that is why many have fallen in love with the law and have become lawyers or judges. As a child, I have dreamed of one day becoming a judge, to apply the law not to destroy lives, but to make lives better. Now, I am in that position, with the help of God. I dispense justice everyday with the aid and guidance I always seek from our Lord.

    “When this case goes to trial, I will of course allow the prosecution every opportunity to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.”

    But as you say, this sort of “order” is a recipe for disqualification.

    In the same token, I agree with you: “People have to rally behind the judge.” before GunGong Gonzales wakes up and drinks his coffee (I hope he scalds his mouth drinking it!)

  34. I believe the Judge when he said he would not hesitate to subpoena even the Malacanang crooks if necessary. With the inevitable departure of the Evil Bitch, those who chose to be silent for so long out of fear or personal reason would now come out to do what is right. This is the best opportunity for them either to show what guts they have or redeem themselves. So, be ready for some other judges, government officials, politicians allied with Malacanang to change clothes or jump ship for their own political or personal survival. And if I were Manny Pacquiao, I would distant himself from Malacanang if he indeed desires to run for Congress. Who knows, he might still change tune upon the advice of his political friends.

  35. parasabayan parasabayan

    How many judges would stand up like Lorredo under the pandak’s EK? NONE! At least openly. Maybe he is so fed up with the corrupted system that he really does not care if he is under fire! Kudos to him!

    May this be a signal for the other judges to stand up and be counted!

  36. Humorous but, unbelievable.Hehehe!
    Hindi ako makapaniwala na susulatin ng huwes ang ganito,pero kumbinsado na ako.Kung naala-ala pa ninyo na may isang huwes na kumukunsulta sa mga duwende bago siya mag decision.Siguro mag ka classmate itong dalawa sa law school.

    Isinama na raw si Jun Lozada sa mga halang ang bituka sa bilanguan,baka sa mga oras na ito ay pinipintahan na ni Da Vinsi ang dibdib niya ng larawan ni “Nunalisa”,Sa parting balikat ay larawan naman ni Bingot.Paglabas niya ng karsel baka bagong Jun Lozada na ang labas niya,pati pisngi niya ay baka magkaroon ng nunal.

  37. parasabayan parasabayan

    BE, Manny is already forming his own party. If he does not distance himself from the pandak, sabit swingson and all the other corrupt admin allies, he will still be perceived as pandak’s annointed no matter how much he shows that he is independent. Manny has his own weight and being a topnotch boxer may have an impact on the masa!

  38. Parasabayan,

    Matalino na ang mga tao ngayon.Pang boksing lang si Pacquiao.Wala naman masama kung kakandidato siya,pero hangang sa Tongressman lang.Pag mangarap pa siya ng mas mataas pa riyan ay bokya na siya.

    Isa pa pag naging Tongressman na iyan,hindi na magdidiwang ang Pinoy dahil hindi na siya mag boboksing.

    Hanga ngayon ay may Pacman fever pa ang mga tao,lahat ng umpukan,kapihan,barbershop at grocery ay siya ang usapan.Galit sila pati na rin ako dahil hindi nasulit ang ibinayad sa HBO PPV.Naiinis din ang lahat ng nag co-comment bakit daw umakyat na naman ng stage si Singson.Natigil daw ang hiyawan at palakpakan ng nag-appear si Chavit.Lahat ng naka-usap ko ay against sila kay Pacman para pasukin ang pulitika.Kung ano ang reaction ng mga Pinoy dito sa Merica tungkol kay Pacquaio na pasukin ang pulitika,palagay ko ganoon din ang reaction ng tao sa Pinas.In scale from 1-10 dehado si Pacquiao dalawa lang ang favor na pasukin niya ang pulitika na parehong high school drop-outs ang nagsabi ayun sa aming survey ni Tata Ingo.

  39. Baka gustong maging senator ni judge kaya niya sinulat ito.Hehehehe!

  40. parasabayan parasabayan

    Hey, if the Judge wants to be a senator, he can become a damn good one as he is not afraid of the Goliaths!

  41. Catherine Catherine

    adebrux, yes the judge can do whatever he wants to say in a legal document for it is the Holy Spirit that is guiding him. Ch-e -e -e-r-r-r-s to Judge Emmnanuel Lord I mean Lorredo

  42. parasabayan parasabayan

    Lozada’s case may be what the pandak is waiting for her next plan in case the Cha-cha does not run as she anticipated. Hinay hinay lang mga kapatid. Alam na ng mga “brains” ni pandak ang mga moves nila. Lozada, may just be a justification for whatever next plans the EK has.

  43. Valdemar Valdemar

    I feel the judge’s head is next to roll. There will be many reasons for that. It could even be for invoking religion in a non-sectarian job. Mind you, supporters of Defensor are gened from the gods.

  44. Catherine Catherine

    Judge E. Lorredo this is for you. Lord, send out your light and truth they shall be my guide to lead me to your holy mountain to the place where you dwell. (Ps 43.3)
    You are in our prayers everyday.

  45. Parasabayan,

    Wala ng extension iyan si Gloria sa Malacanang.Lame Duck na siya ngayon.Unti-unti ng nag re-reform ang mga die hard followers niya.Pagtiyagaan na lang siguro siya hangang sa mag-alsa balutan siya sa palasyo sa june 2010 kesa kagatin pa ang mga ipinapain niya sa tao na magkagulo.Malamig na rin ang tao sa kaso ni Jun Lozada,Frozen Delight na siya sabi ng isang commenter doon sa blog ko.

    Tinutulayan lang siya ng mga kandidato for publicity na akala nila ay malakas pa ang hatak niya.Kapag nag Obladi-Oblada si Lozada ay finish na talaga siya,itatapon na siya ng tao na parang basahan.Parang si Hatton,ng pumasok sa ring ay an daming alalay,ng na nak-out dalawa na lang ang nagbuhat sa kanya,tumalikod na ang mga handler niya.Sana kay Pacquiao na nangyari iyun,baka mag-isa lang si Singson na magbalatay kay Pakman.

  46. I posted here the PDF copy of the order which I got from Jun Lozada’s camp. It was given to them as their copy.

    They also couldn’t believe it. A friend called me up as she was leaving the MPD excited about it. I only got it later in the night as they had to scan it to able to send me.

    Yvonne Chua had to type it out to be able to post the text.

    Take note of the time that we were able to post it.Tawa talaga kami ng tawa.

  47. Schumey Schumey

    Hehehe…let’s see if Defensor’s lawyer would ask for his inhibition. I doubt it very much. Lorredo just got Mike by the balls. He would have no other option but to make “peace” with Lozada.

  48. srcitizen2000 srcitizen2000

    I salute judge Lorredo for his courage and wit. Sana nga we have more judges like him at least kahit man lang sa judiciary pwede tayong magkaroon ng kahit konting pagasa sa buhay!!!

  49. Pacman’s forming his own party could be Malacanang’s advice. Since the Administration is having a hard time uniting Lakas and Kampi, forming another one is a good one. Also, the crooks may be taking advantage of Pacman’s billions.

  50. parasabayan parasabayan

    Cocoy, I would like to believe you na lame duck na si pandak but she can mutate through other people. What is Villar doing in Spain? To meet the queen? Sa dami ng nakaw niyang pera, she can very well pay prostitutes to do things for her. Flipinos do not have the political maturity yet like what first world countries have. Filipinos sell their allegiances even for a pack of noodles, a kilo of rice and a can of sardines.

  51. saxnviolins saxnviolins

    Get a load of the following. Baka gusto ni Tongue na tugtugin ang base part of the composition.

    “A.M. No. 06-5-159-MeTC.- Re: Request of Judge Jorge Emmanuel M. Lorredo, Metropolitan Trial Court, Branch 26, Manila, for Permission to Sell His Original Musical Composition and to Perform or Promote His Songs in Public Places, on Television or on Radio.- The Court Resolved to

    (a) NOTE the 1st Indorsement dated May 5, 2006 of Chief Justice Artemio V. Panganiban, referring the Memorandum dated April 25, 2006 of Deputy Court Administrator Zenaida N. Elepaño relative to the request of Judge Jorge Emmanuel M. Lorredo, Metropolitan Trial Court, Branch 26, Manila, for permission to sell his original musical compositions and to perform or promote his songs in public places, on television or on radio;

    (b) NOTE the aforesaid Memorandum of DCA Zenaida N. Elepaño; and

    (c) APPROVE the request of Judge Lorredo for permission to sell his original musical compositions, but DENY his request to perform or promote his songs in public places or appear in television or radio after office hours or during days when he is on official leave.” Ynares-Santiago, J., on leave.

  52. Villar went to Spain as an excuse to meet the Evil Bitch. When his ally Alan Cayetano was asked about this, he replied saying that since Villar is Independent, he could meet Erap and GMA. Now Villar’s camp is saying he’s Independent while in the past he claimed to be an opposition. Politicians’ true colors are showing as 2010 election approaches. I’m not only disappointed with Alan but most especially Nene Pimentel who’s now Villar’s most avid defender. Nothing wrong with helping a colleague as long as there’s no monetary consideration. But if Villar is indeed guilty of the C-5 Road anomaly, then let him speaks and defends himself. As it is now, he’s avoiding the Senate and leaving the matter to his allies to fight for him.

  53. fenix fenix

    WOW! Assuming this is not an urban legend, talk about dauntless audacity. The magistrate outlined the defense strategy in such simple, crystal clear terms, DOJ chief Gonzalez must be squirming in his dunce chair searching for an opening to charge Lorredo (no relation to Lozada) with sedition (aka siding with the enemies of the State).
    Just when we thought the justice system is moribund and gasping its last, the judge gives it a refreshing breathe, and does it with unprecedented humour.
    Unintended consequence of Defensor’s obstinate move is a Lozada-for-senator groundswell.

  54. chi chi

    Please pray also for me, so that I may always be a good, humble, God fearing and very wise Judge to those who seek justice in my courtroom; and so that I may be elevated from a Judge to a Justice (even though I do not have any political backers) for that would surely make my late father, Jorge Lorredo, Jr. (who is now with Jesus in heaven watching me with a smile on his face) and my mother, Mary Lorredo, very proud of their only child. – Judge Larredo

    I surely will, every night before bed. 🙂

    “Wow, parang blogger” talaga!

    Yes, Tongue, ‘kala ko e isa sa atin…hehehe!!!

  55. Prayer should come from the heart…not repetitious…and acceptable to God.

  56. Thank you for posting, Ellen

    We were quite surprised when it was delivered to Jun yesterday morning, we thought Judge Lorredo was still on leave. A friend read it aloud to all of us in Jun’s cramped detention room and you can just imagine our reactions. It was the only light moment we had all day. We needed to laugh, Jun especially, in preparation for what happened after (his move to jail). Chel Diokno, Jun’s lawyer, thinks that Judge Lorredo wants to be removed from the case, or that he really believes in Jun’s innocence and just couldn’t stop himself. What a guy! In response to his invitation, the religious will be attending flag ceremony along with all the rest of us.

    Let us remember that Jun has the “goods” on the Southrail deal, and will be a major witness at planned senate hearings. Defensor is head of PNR, and may be defending his turf.

  57. ofel beltran balleta ofel beltran balleta

    Hi, ellen!
    Katulad ng ilan sa mga nakabasa ng resolution ni Judge Lorredo, natawa din ako.. it’s a resolution cum opinion/invitation to all! Naalala ko ang kasong Inciting to Sedition ng father ko, si Ka Bel at Rebellion Case ng Batasan 6. Kung si Judge Lorredo ang humawak ng kaso ng father ko sa Inciting to Sedition hindi na siguro iaakyat pa sa Rebellion… hindi na rin siguro siya tatagal ng 1 taon at kalahati na nakakulong/confined sa Phil. Heart Center. Samantalahin ko na pagkakataon, on May 20, 1 yr death anniv ni Ka Bel. Sana, you can write something about him in your column. Thanks.

  58. LU ROQUE LU ROQUE

    I am very glad to read the order of Judge Lorredo. I just don’t find it funny but very versatile. In this stage of the case, during inquest, he already presented the nature of the future battle between the two parties and presented the worst case scenario for Mike Defensor.

    Judge Lorredo exhausted the mechanism and mandate bestowed upon judges to settle things amicably between warring parties. We find this move unusual especially for a highly political issue like this one. And his advice was comprehensive enough to guide the next possible move of both parties and how the court will logically respond to respective motions.

    Kudos to this kind of intelligent, objective and true public servant like Judge Lorredo. May his tribe increase!
    He belongs to the genre of SC Justice Renato Puno and other independent minded justices.

    Kung ganito lang lahat ng ating mga hurado at mga magiging hurado, pati na rin mga manananggol, ang korte ay magiging isang respetado at kapaki-pakinabang na institusyon sa ating lipunan!

    Mabuhay ang lahat ng nagtataguyod ng tunay na hustisya!
    Wakasan ang mga kasong ang layunin ay patahimikin ang tagapagsiwalat ng katiwalian!
    Itigil ang pagsampa ng mga kasong ang layon ay upang patayin ang katotohanan!

    Kudos to your intellligent column!

    Ms. Lu Roque
    ANAKPAWIS National Office
    cp:0915-9049401
    tel/fax:426-9442

  59. I re-read the ORDER for the 4th time and I’m still laughing here…

    Gosh, if Lorredo stands by his order, he will be a hero to many.

    Thing is this ORDER has got to be circulated NATIONWIDE, REGION WIDE, WORLDWIDE and PINOYWIDE so Lorredo gets support before the Malacanang alipores begin maneuvering against him for reasons of whatever.

  60. juan juan

    hahaha ok to ah. this is the truth. ewan ko lang sa http://donavictorina.blogspot.com/ parang ang sakit sa mata magbasa dun. ang linis ng tingin nila kay tol mike defensor. inaapi pa nila si ellen at jun.

  61. saxnviolins saxnviolins

    I need not search hard nor should I wait long, for Manila Mayor Lim and the many senators who wish to take Lozada into their custody may move that they be deputized. Some of these people are lawyers, some of them have extensive police experience, like Mayor Fred Lim and Senator Ping Lacson. They can arrest, handcuff and put behind bars any fugitive.

    They are no match against the PSG, the Presidential Security Group? What if Sen. Trillanes and his comrades join the mission to arrest? Get the picture, Mr. Railroadman Defensor?

    Diyos ko po. Can you see how explosive this will be? He has just shown how to release Trillanes.

    Railroadman Defensor? Is that a double entendre there? Marami ngang ni-railroad ang gagong yan.

    Even if the judge did this only to get himself inhibited, this is a mere mortal shaking his fist at the heavens.

    Kung balls ang pag-uusapan, this guy has elephantiasis.

  62. Rose Rose

    Judge Lorredo: I will certain keep you in my daily prayers..the mention of who your father was brought back memories of my years with Work A Year With the People..your dad was the President of the group and I was the secretary..we used to hold our meetings at Raul Manglapus Senate Office where your father worked or at the Ateneo de Manila in Padre Faura..anak ka talaga ng tatay mo..and I am sure he is proud of you.
    Judge Lorredo is young and a lot of years ahead of him to really be one day a Justice…baka he is on his 50’s.. Raul Manglapus MARIA-WAY was active in the early sixties…
    Mabuhay ka!

  63. Rose Rose

    Mukhang na (h)ipit si putot sa kaso..kung alisin nila si Judge Lorredo..I am sure maraming magagalit..pero takot rin siya at baka ipatawag sila na witness…nadali din ang mga baboy ito ang malaking swine flu mg mga baboy sa Malacanang…ano kaya..may bayag si Defensor na iurong niya ang kaso at mag peace na lang sila ni Lozada..kung gagawin niya yon ma pissed off si putot at ang kanyang baboy…
    ..ma didisbar ba ni siraulo si Judge Lorredo..gagawa yon ng paraan to save his queen..
    ..very interesting and very entertaining..ito ang boxing na gusto ko!

  64. Catherine Catherine

    Rose, our prayer group is so amazing. I strongly believe in the power of prayer for there are so many miracles that happened in our family.

    Congrats! Judge Emmanuel Lorredo for your courage. We hope there will be more judges like you.

  65. nahnah nahnah

    May sinasabi si Banayo sa column niya ngayon na may presidentiable (hindi niya binanggit kung sino) ang makikipagusap sa Queen Nunal somewhere sa Syria. sino pa, eh di si Villar na nasa bakasyon daw sa Spain. Itong si Villar ang the Great Pretender, dahil kung sino ang ‘in’, duon siya. Mga tanga lang ang boboto sa kanya. Si Alan Cayetano naman, dios ko, the guile of this guy! Kahon kahon na ebidensya against sa German bank account ni Pidal, kailan bubuhayin? Kay Pimentel, sorry, pero question mark siya sa akin. Bakit iyong anak niya na gustong senador ay hindi nanalo duon the region/province niya nuong tumakbo siya duon.

    Tungkol dito kay Judge Lloredo, kaabang abang kung ano ang reaksyon ng kampo ni Defensor at Nunal. Hahanapan ngayon siya ng kasalanan pihado.

  66. saxnviolins saxnviolins

    Talaga palang maanghang and dila ni Judge; parang Haydee Yorac. Siya mismo, nademanda ng libel, for telling a prosecutor

    Effectively immediately, you are not allowed to smoke inside our room 319 and to us it as a venue in fixing cases, even in my absence.

    Read the Court of Appeals decision upholding Judge Lorredo’s acquittal here:

    http://ca.judiciary.gov.ph/cardis/SP72029.pdf

  67. Catherine Catherine

    Thank you, Ellen. I got the copy of Judge Emmanuel Lorredo’s order to Mike Defenseless. Let us all be patient for this Defenseless coward will be humbled by the Almighty Lord in His time.

  68. Lani Lani

    Thank you Ms. Ellen for this article. Nakaka enlighten. Napakatalino ni Judge, mantakin mo naisip nya yon? Sayang, nasa ibang bansa na yung kakilala ko sa Manila Trial Court, i would have asked her to introduce me to Judge Lorredo para magpa autograph, he is an idol! Btw, I have copied and pasted this to my different e-groups, i hope u won’t mind, pero syempre i stated your site as the source. Again, maraming salamat…

  69. ocayvalle ocayvalle

    good judge..!! i hope he be true to his word.. God sent for justice for the oppressed filipino people.. i hope this judge is the wterloo of the evil couple.. GMA and FG and their cabals of evil minions behind them.. mabuhay po kayo judge lorredo..!! the country need you and the filipino people..!!

  70. TruBlue TruBlue

    As usual, it will be SEARCH and DESTROY from the Gluerilla Regime. Wish RD will send his DDS and eliminate those who needs to be eliminated.

    CJ Puno, Lorredo, Robredo, Roque, Duterte, Atty Colminares are the ones who should be running the show, just my take!

  71. ocayvalle ocayvalle

    waterloo po.. their downfall..

  72. kabute kabute

    It will be good to check past case decisions and orders made by Judge Lorredo. As if some kind of spirit was implanted into the Judge’s brain and heart to write such an order. The wonderment is it puts into a bind all of GMA’s men and more. Lozada has again successfully served as a catalyst and tool by the good spirit. By Jlozada’s sacrifice, Tol Defensor, GMA’s gofer, and their evil plans are now helter-skelter. HARHARHARHAR!

  73. eduardo a. olarte eduardo a. olarte

    gawin natin chief justice ng supreme court si judge lorredo para bumalik ang tiwala ng mga tao sa justice system ng pilipinas

  74. eduardo a. olarte eduardo a. olarte

    let us unite and campaign for judge lorredo to be the next CHIEF JUSTICE of the supreme court. palitan na ang mga walang magawang chief justice sa bulok na sistema ng hustisya sa bansa.

  75. Diego K. Guerrero Diego K. Guerrero

    Judge Jorge Emmanuel Lorredo is probably eyeing for Supreme Court magistrate or Ombudsman after the end of Arroyo regime. Our Inang Bayan needs him to reform the judiciary.

  76. I forgot to say that before the spanish came the kapampangan elite(dugong bughaw) were the kings in Luzon and was known in the archipelago including mindanao like that of Rajah Gambang and Lakandula,but later on some of them are obviously tagalog like Solaiman.

    Ayoko talaga kay Gloria nasusuka ako sa kanya,Palayain na si Jun Lozada.

  77. pugong_gala0101 pugong_gala0101

    Judge to Defensor: Lozada case may lead to arrest order vs First Couple

    ………….Get the picture, Mr. Railroadman Defensor?” Lorredo asked. “Defensor, just imagine how powerful a message that would for our people and for the whole world. And just imagine how that would affect the first couple.”

    http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/nation/05/05/09/judge-defensor-lozada-case-may-lead-arrest-order-vs-first-couple

    Lagot si judge! Baka mademanda na naman siya ng leverage to person niyan, eh. Libel pala.

    Biruin ninyong gawin niyang employee ng PNR si Bingotilyong Miyak?

  78. patria adorada patria adorada

    thanks God there’s a judge that injected a sane thing in our society.akala ko bulok na lahat.
    sana matuloy ang arrest order.

  79. Bilib ako sa balls ni judge. Pwedeng ilaban dun sa globe sa harap ng Mall of Asia.

  80. juan juan

    lumutang na lang na parang lobo mga corrupt parang kita-kita hahahaha

  81. jose miguel jose miguel

    The action of Judge Lorredo is a signal for the Supreme Court justices. May the officers of the AFP also able to pick it up.

    May Jun Lozada and party able to fully appreciate the consequent corresponding scenarios of entering into an amicable settlement as well as refusing an amicable settlement should somebody broker it or so young and so … Defensor initiate it.

  82. pugong_gala0101 pugong_gala0101

    Hindi niya maipapaaresto ang mag-asawang salot habang nariyan ang kanilang brilliant sickretary of injustice na kulang na lang ang isang pirma ng bulateng hikain ay kung bakit hindi pa matuluyan, eh!

  83. pugong_gala0101 pugong_gala0101

    Judge, ingat ka lang.

    Siguradong binabalak na nilang “burahin” ka sa mundo nang tuluyan!

  84. Rose Rose

    I would love to see Gloria and her husband Mike stand before the court of Judge Lorredo (kahit) be a witness lang…baka ma heart attack si Piggy Bsnk at matuluyan. (lagot ka Judge..maglulupasay si putot at dedemanda ka) lagot din si Defensor, kung hindi dahil sa demanda niya kay Lozada wala ito..ang sabi nga ni Judge..”God works in mysterious ways”. baka sa pangyayaring ito..maghahalo ang balat at ang tinalupan..hala bira Judge Lorredo.

  85. Rose Rose

    Ang second name pala niya ay Emmauel..hindi ba Emmanuel means savior? And that is why we refer to Jesus as Emmanuel?.. a sign of a savior for the Phil para maituwid ang justice and truth sa atin? I wonder…

  86. Rose Rose

    Hala Bira Judge!

  87. chi chi

    Rose,

    Tuwang-tuwa ka sa anak ng iyong friend a! Ako rin, tuwang-tuwa sa kanya, ang sarap pisilin ng pagmamahal ang magkabilang pisngi, hehehe.

    Wala pa bang sagot si Mr. Railroadman Defensor?

  88. The best thing that can happen after Judge Lorredo’s irreverent and insolent but funny ORDER to Mike “worm” Defensor is for Jose Pidal Arroyo to hit back at the gutsy judge by filing a libel case, an administration case, a whatever case against him.

    If Pidal does that, then the entire “laban”, boxing match (between judiciary and executive branches), slugging contest between Pidal and his minion, etc will be out in the open. What better way is there for the whole thing to become really EXPLOSIVE than for Pidal to sue Lorredo? An “open” fight between Pidal and Lorredo will surely rally public support for the good judge!

    I do hope that Lorredo is serious about doing things right and that this ORDER of his is not a kind of “Come on! Make me an offer I cannot refuse” call to the Malacanang squatters!

  89. Dada Dada

    Hahaha!!!!..for sure high blood na c DOJ Secretary and I’m sure ang sasabihin nanaman nya “there’s no proof, puro paninira lang yan”…or worse suspendido si judge lorredo..suntok ata sa buwan ung mapapunta sa court ang first couple lam naman naten kung gano kakapal ang mga mukha nyan at sanay na sila sa galit ng mga tao

  90. atty36252 atty36252

    Nagpantasya ako ng konti.

    What if the defense calls Pidal, and of course, he would give his usual excuse. Ganito sana ang gawing order ni Judge.

    It appearing that the witness is feigning grave illness to evade submission to a court of the Republic of the Philippines, his arrest is hereby ordered. Mayor Fred Lim, Retired General Miranda, General Lim and Senator Trillanes are hereby deputized to effect this order of arrest. They may take as many men from the Scout Rangers as they deem necessary, to effect this order of arrest, and to ensure that any attempt by the PSG to thwart the will of the court will be repelled.

    SO ORDERED.

  91. Luga Luga

    Hanggang ngayon ay hinahanap ko pa itong balitang ito sa mga pahayagan. Bakit wala ni isa man lang sa mga pahayagan ang nagbalita nito. Maski Abante man lang. Mukhang tayo lang dito ang nakaka-alam.

  92. Lorredo’s calling Pidal Arroyo’s bogey man “Mr Railroadman Defensor” is spot on — he was trying to describe Defensor as a “con artist”, a fast and loose individual, which is almost synonimous to “to railroad something”.

    How very appropriate!

  93. Rose Rose

    Chi: May crush kasi ako noon kay Raul Manglapus kaya lahat ng programa niya sinalihan ko..Fiesta for Progress, Work A Year With the People etc. Jorge worked for Raul Manglapus and I think they are related…kaya laging buntot ako sa lakad..meetings, etc.
    With people like this Judge..there is hope for the Phil..I am sure there are a lot more of people like him..a man of God..God fearing people..

  94. Atty,

    “They may take as many men from the Scout Rangers as they deem necessary, to effect this order of arrest, and to ensure that any attempt by the PSG to thwart the will of the court will be repelled.”

    Sayang!

  95. Rose Rose

    Today is May 5..ang trial is on the 7th abangan natin ang boxing..Defensor vs. Lozada..the Heavy Weight Defensor vs. the probinsiyanong intsik..and the referee. Judge Jorge Emanuel Loredo..Defensor’s coach and manager Piggy Bank Arroyo.. Lozada’s coach..Sr. Manalansan…Managers and supporters ni Lozada lahat na para sa truth and Justice..sana ma televise ang laban..May 7. history in the making..

  96. Hindi ako makaniwala sa nabasa kong order ni Judge Lorredo. Para kong nakita ang aking sarili writing it with funny lines in order to easily reach my website visitors. But going over it not once but twice, it’s really something not seen or heard in our legal jurisprudence with such high profile personalities being pilloried at the outset.

    Gimme 5, Judge Lorredo!

  97. This is the most amusing court order ever!

    Right on, Judge Lorredo!

  98. chi chi

    Kung ganito pala ka-‘jeproks’ ang topic ay hindi ka makatiis na hindi magposte ‘no, joeseg? Nakakatuwa at nakakabuhay ng loob na meron pang natitirang matitino at marurunong sa Pinas court.

  99. habib habib

    Who is this JoeSeg?

    A predator? A commentator? A devastator? Or an incubator?

    Aaaahhh! I know the guy. He is the son of his father.

    Mr. Joe, welcome (back).

    You are like a virus. Once scratched, you peep out. But I know I had read you before. Just re-collecting back my memories, eh?

  100. Sana makarma SI Defensor.

    @Grizzy
    Regarding your past post the real reason why Luzon Kingdom was conquered by the spanish is because of the people with dugong aso mentality.

  101. atty36252 atty36252

    Justice Secretary Raul Gonzalez said Lorredo should simply decide on the merits of the case.

    “He should give his order based on the Rules of Court. These are completely extraneous issues. Why should the judge inject something that isn’t in the case? I don’t know the philosophy behind that,” said Gonzalez.

    The case is being tried, so is sub judice.

    Parang nakikinita ko na ang ganitong order:

    “The Secretary of Justice is ordered to show cause within five days why he should not be cited in contempt for making public comments about a case that is before a court of the Republic of the Philippines, and for questioning the court’s handling of a pending case.”

    Pagkatapos,

    “The explanation is unsatisfactory. The Secretary is cited in contempt, to spend two days in jail. His arrest is hereby ordered. Colonel Ariel Querubin is hereby deputized to effect this order of arrest.”

  102. Senor Habib and every all, like a pusang gala, I am glad to be back and thanks for the welcome Espana rotunda.

    Inspite of the swine flu from Mexico, the other day there’s Pacquiao’s thundering right cross that cut Hatton like a tinibang saging at kinilig ang buong mundo and out of the blue, there’s now Judge Lorredo in time for the celebration of a Happy Cinco de Mayo!

    http://www.dobhran.com/greetings/GRcinco.htm

  103. Engracio Del Reosario Engracio Del Reosario

    I have almost lost my trust and confidence in the Philippine justice system until I read this order. My support and fervent prayer for this kind of judge who has got the wisdom and fear of the Lord to be able to dispense justice accordingly. More power to Judge Lorredo! It seems to me that the Almighty has heard my prayers for someone like him to evolve from the present Philippines situation and condition. I hope and pray that every Filipino who is in his/her right mind will lift him up in their personal and devotional prayers.

    And the truth shall set us free!

  104. chi chi

    O, napikon na si siRaulo sa ‘jeproks’ order ni Judge Lorredo.

    Sana ay marami pang nagtatago na matitinong judges na lumabas na at sumunod sa style ni Judge L. Let’s see kung paano mataranta to the extreme si RaulGoon.

  105. ron ron

    nakakatuwa pero tama lahat mga sinabi nya. i’m glad me judge na ganitong ka prangka at walang takot na magsiwalat ng saloobin nya.

  106. Rose Rose

    In today’s Malaya, Ellen wrote about this. Law students take note. I will copy this to give it to my nephew..although he is a law student here. He loves to read Ellen’s column but he does not know Tagalog that much..this order of Judge Lorredo will really be a case study.

  107. saxnviolins saxnviolins

    What if Sen. Trillanes and his comrades join the mission to arrest?

    A friend just observed, if Senator Trillanes or General Lim get deputized, and others join the efforts to arrest, you cannot prosecute them for rebellion or coup d’ etat, because they are effecting a court order.

    This is getting to be very interesting.

  108. toyota revolucionario toyota revolucionario

    Magaling ang decision ni Judge Laredo – sana naman dumating na tayo sa level na ide-deputised na niya sina Trillanes na arestuhin si Ginang ng Magnanakaw na Asawa.

  109. Mike Mike

    Mike Defensor must be squirming in his seat right now. It’s a case of damn if you do, damn if you don’t situation. If he withdraws the case, it would mean he lost the battle, if he pursues with the case, he will still lose under a fair judge like Judge Lorredo.

  110. chi chi

    “They are no match against the PSG, the Presidential Security Group? What if Sen. Trillanes and his comrades join the mission to arrest? Get the picture, Mr. Railroadman Defensor?- Judge Larredo

    How could Sen. Sonny and his comrades (in jail) join the mission to arrest the bitch and her swine? Does Judge Larredo also have the power, according to the Constitution, to order Gloria to let Sen. Sonny and fellows out of prison to fulfill the court’s mission order?

    O, Judge Larredo…if you have the power, pakisama na sa aaresto kay Gloria at Mike Arroyo si Kapitan Nick.

    Hala, kung ganyan ang scenario ay ituloy na ni Little Mike ang kaso vs. Lozada.

  111. Can anybody inform Atty. Chel Diokno of Sir Raul O’s comments? I’m sure thay’ve been dying for such an opportunity.

  112. Luga Luga

    Buti na lang hindi sa St. Lukes Hospital itinakbo si Lozada. Kung doon itinakbo malamang siya ay dedbol na.

  113. Off limits ang katulad ni Jun Lozada sa St. Luke’s Hospital. Ang pwede lang dun ay ang tropa ng taga palasyo by the stinking river.

    Kung dun dinala si Lozada, magkakaroon ng duda ang madlang pipol na baka ginagapang na sya para umatras sa kanyang mga paratang. At kung sasamain … huwag na lang.

  114. Luga Luga

    JoeSeg, si FPJ doon itinakbo … yon dedbol. Hindi sa off-limit siya at palagay ko naman hindi siya babaligtad. Malaki ang tiwala ko sa kanya … sa lahat na pinagdaanan niya palagay ko sinsero siya. Sino nga ba siya … siya’y isa lang probinsiyanong intsik na naninindigan lang ng katotohanan. Mas matapang pa siya palagay ko kay Pacquiao. Ang mga kalaban ni Manny ay harap-harapan kung lumaban at iisa lang pero ang mga kalaban ni Jun … ilang batalyon yan at kung lumaban pa sila ay patalikod.

  115. Rose Rose

    na corner na si Defensor…saan siya tatago under the falda ni Gloria? Tomorrow is May 7..nakabalik na ba siya..ano ang mangyayari kung he will be represented only by his atty. as he is out of the country? what if he seeks asylum? will he be tried in absentia?..abangan natin ang susunod na kabanata..saan ba siyang state nagtatago?..kawawa ang asawa niya at ang mga anak niya..pero naisip ba niya ang asawa at mga anak ni Lozada?…hindi! kaya na karma siya…

  116. MrG MrG

    adebrux – May 5, 2009

    Lorredo’s calling Pidal Arroyo’s bogey man “Mr Railroadman Defensor” is spot on — he was trying to describe Defensor as a “con artist”, a fast and loose individual, which is almost synonimous to “to railroad something”.

    How very appropriate!

    Little Mike is the Chair of PNR, that is why the judge referred to him as Mr. Railroadman. See http://pnr.gov.ph/

  117. Remember what Susan Roces said about Mike Defensor…So young and already a big liar.

  118. Valdemar Valdemar

    A little offbeat topic, the BAYAN MUNA placard bearing rallyist yesterday made me walk a very long detour and of curse I course them. Many depend on my rounds yesterday, my dogs had to eat, a snatcher had to get perhaps medicine for his sick family and I even passed by MMDA stopping unusually buses. Cant this Bayan muna bolshetviks do something better whenever I get out rarely? They go harass Defensor.

  119. Rose Rose

    Catherine: glad to be a part of your prayer group..let us continue doing so..May 7 is Lozada’s trial..although it seems that Heavy Weight Defensor will do everying and with Gloria behind him..he just might win..sana itutuloy ni Defensor ang kaso niya..Judge Lorredo I think is serious with what he said although nakakatawa…I don’t think he is eyeing for a political spot…ang hinihiling lang niya at ang pinagdadasal ay maging Justice of the Supreme court so let’s help him wth our prayers to make him the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court…sana hindi uurong si Defensor..waray waray ba siya? Remember Nida Blanca’s song Waray Waray? ay bata ka pa pala…

  120. Rose Rose

    corr: Heavy Weight.. will do everything.

  121. fenix fenix

    Abraham Lincoln’s (16th president of US (1809 – 1865) Notes for a Law Lecture: Discourage litigation. Persuade your neighbors to compromise whenever you can. Point out to them how the nominal winner is often a real loser — in fees, expenses, and waste of time. As a peacemaker the lawyer has a superior opportunity of being a good man. There will still be business enough.

  122. asiandelight asiandelight

    “conflict of INTERESTing people and the shock absorber defensor has to defend authorities who helped his career to reach the top.

    It’s not too late for defensor to change his mind and join Lozada’s cause.

    great news. very motivational at least for a change.

  123. Hehehehe! Bumawi si Lozada sa pinag-gagawa ng Malacanang sa St.Luke.Mabuti at sa Makati Medical siya nagpunta.Kung si Bolante ay umubra ang flag raising ceremony niya kailangan bumawi na rin si Lozada.Paglabas niya sa Makati Medical ay laya na siya dahil sa “time serve” ng perjury case na isinampa ni Bingot sa kanya..

  124. In the recent press conference given by Mike Defensor, he mentioned that Lozada has two wives. That was foul. His having two wives has nothing to do with the perjury case filed by Defensor. I’m surprised Lozada and his camp did not react to that.

  125. habib habib

    Judge Lorredo is a man of principle.

    Let’s rally behind him. He is one of the leaders we need. This maybe the beginning of what we’ve been longing for, the prevailing of justice over greed.

  126. pugong_gala0101 pugong_gala0101

    Tol Mike,

    Puwede bang balato ko na lang sa iyo si Jun Lozada? Tutal, mahaba naman ang ating pinagsamahan. Walang oras na hindi tayo magkasama. Sa mga lakaran. Sa kasayahan. Sa kalungkutan (wala naman sa atin ‘yun, eh). Sa mga problema (‘andyan si ninang). Sa mga kaso (‘andyan si ninong at si lolo).

    Buong buhay mo ay alalay mo ako. Wala akong hindi, wala akong tanggi. Lahat nang hilingin mo, okey lang ang sagot ko. Bagama’t labag sa loob ko, sige lang saan ka man pumunta, nandoon din ako.

    Sa pagkakataong ito, aaminin ko, mabigat na para sa akin ang samahan ka at isaisantabi na lamang ang kasalukuyang nangyayari. Ang iyong kinasangkutang ikaw mismo ang pasimuno.

    Tol, hanggang dito na lamang ako. Ayaw ko na. Suko na ako.

    Ang iyong kunsensiya,

    Bingotilyong Miyak

  127. Wakanga, ibig mong sabihin Magno, meron pang konsensiya yang dipungal na yan?

    Merong sumulat kay Miyak:

    Tol Mike,
    Iatras mo na ang demanda hahaba lang ang laban sa bandang huli, wala ka namang panalo, kahit maipakulong mo si Jun.

    Mas mabuti pa, ikaw na rin ang magsiwalat ng lahat ng alam mo sa kalokohan ng mga amo mo. Siguradong panalo ka. Senado?Iyung-iyo!

    Kung hindi, ang kapalit naman e habambuhay sa kulungan simula 2010. Wala doong pokpok na taga Quezon Blvd. Puro maton na hawaiian shirt ang nakapinta sa balat. Lahat sila asawa mo, aruyku! Mamili ka.

    Patunay na seryoso ang alok ko, nagsama na ako ng isang sako ng pagkaing alam kong magugustuhan mo: Butong-pakwan.

    Umaasa,

    Tapia Slavi

  128. gurong pinay gurong pinay

    I love this judge.. his humor and courage shows in his classic order, but read between the lines, he is seriously admonishing the culprits..makapal na lang ang mukha ng hindi tinamaan..
    my prayers are with you, sir.. and may there be more like you..kaya lang,
    mahirap yatang maibigay ni Lord yon, bihira na ang kagaya ninyo..

  129. pugong_gala0101 pugong_gala0101

    gurong pinay,

    Ano’ng malay natin, baka itong si Judge Lorredo ang siyang magbubukas at gigising sa mga natutulog at nagtutulugtulugang gising?

    Problema nga lamang ay ‘yung mga pinatutungkulang hidni lamang walang kahihiyan kundi talagang kahit ano’ng gawin ay hindi na tatablan. Sabi nga, katukin mo ang bato at baka kumilos sa kinalalagyan, pero itong mga iskwater sa bahay-maligno sa tabi ng bulok na ilog ay hindi matitinag habang meron pang nasisilip na kakawatin sa kaban!

  130. I was watching an old movie, “King of Kings,” and there was a part there where a centurion asked what John the Baptist was jailed for. The reply was, “He told the truth.” It reminded me of what Lozada is being jailed for—he told the truth!

    We all know the Bible story, about where Herod, et al accusers of John the Baptist are now—in hell, in the brimstone pit!

Comments are closed.